To condense my Robbnva vote into a few points that are not just snippets of notes:
Robbnva is immediately dismissive of suspicions on himself (starting as early as
Post #18 where he rolls his eyes at Dwlee99 for placing a serious vote on him). For example:
In post 32, Robbnva wrote:Since I'm not scum not have I done anything remotely scummy it would be just plain stupid to vote me but hey whatever floats your boat
In post 669, Robbnva wrote:I haven't done anything townie yet?
Calling out a weird 180 and doing research to catch a player in a lie isn't townie?
In post 671, Robbnva wrote:Dude my posts scream town. Saying I haven't made any townie posts is like saying Jeremy Lin is the best player to
Ever play in the nba.
In post 847, Robbnva wrote:There is literally no way you can read my posts and think I could be scum right now.
There are a few more 'subtle' ones (such as pointing out how he has looked into games other than this one, pointing out how he has questioned ha[lf] of the player list, indicating how engaged he is, etc.). Of course, all of this rather contradicts the following gems:
In post 430, Robbnva wrote:I'm genuinely worried that at this point he doesn't have more reads. Tbh I have posted enough I should be more than a null for anyone. People should be able to tell if they think I'm townish or scummish. the fact that anyone is null reading me still is worrisome. As for not having anything AI in my posts, I find that quite amusing. I fee there's plenty I've said that can lead people to determine my alignment.
Robbnva
is
fairly concerned about how his actions are perceived, or else he would not immediately jump in to dismiss people who find him suspicious. And apparently, everybody should have an opinion on Robbnva, but the only possible opinion conceivable is that Robbnva is Town.
~
For somebody with 135 games under his belt he has been prone to seemingly not understand very basic things. Off the top of my head:
->
a.)
He seems to consistently not understand how Creature can use process of elimination to narrow down players into a suspect pool. (This is done by putting everybody think is Town in the Town pool, and then everybody
not
on that list goes in the Scum pool).
->
b.)
He very badly attempts to direct investigations:
In post 610, Robbnva wrote:Fuck it
vote: crab
Somebody please investigate creature. Clearing that slot would make me sleep better
And he has attempted to direct investigations a second time as well in
Post #848.
This is basic mafia theory. In fact, I had a
post about this over ten years ago that is still applicable. For somebody claiming to have played in 135 prior games, this is fairly egregious.
~
I do not like Robbnva's assessment and push of Eggman's lynch for a few reasons.
First, he attacks Creature's unvote of Eggman as being "weird." It should be evident that removing a player from L-1 is prudent play for any player with doubts about the lynch, but this goes unaddressed.
Second, he fails to consider Eggman's relative newness to the game when assessing Eggman's claim / "crumb":
In post 345, Robbnva wrote:If anything VTs should try and give off a vibe they are a pr rather they are a vt
Essentially he tries to hold Eggman to the standards of an experienced player, and then using Eggman's failure to meet those standards as evidence of Eggman being scum.
Third, he puts Eggman back at L-1. When he moves his vote, it is while attempting to connect Creature to Eggman (as Smithereens hypothesized). His efforts thereafter go towards lynching Creature. While he
did
go to lengths to effectively state he was not trying to set up lynches (i.e., "lynch Creature today, lynch Eggman tomorrow"), I
do
get that impression from his vote switch.
[Note: Smithereens has very similar offenses when it comes to Eggman / Creature].
~
Stopping there. Will try to write up another post or two about other things. It's past midnight and I'm getting tired.
