Open 647: Diffusion of Power (Game Over)

[podoboq]

GONNA FINISH THIS

Dunnstral / Maruchan

: Obv town. Read his interactions with me. It's not just because he's buddying me, it's because he refused to hammer me when it would have been easy as scum to make that mislynch happen WHEN HE WAS AT RISK.

karnos

: Obvtown because fantastic reads and interactions.

SirCakez

: All of his reads and comments are perfect, but he isn't active enough.

Chip Butty

: Pretty cooperative, and doesn't mind going out on a limb.

PenguinPower

: The response to the wagon on him is pretty damn good, I have to admit. I couldn't in good conscious let him get lynched, knowing that if we mislynched him, I'm basically a guaranteed mislynch tomorrow.

Aneninen

: I like this active at the deadline. Thanks for helping, buddy.

Transcend

: I like a lot of his interactions and reads, but his absence at deadline concerns me.

drmyshottyizsik

: The way he handled my wagon is a little shoddy. I just needed to put that joke in there. But also, it's true. He could be scum going for town points by looking indecisive on what ended up being a milsynch.

MURDERCAT

: This is mostly a gut thing. His interactions aren't entirely consistent. Way too many contentless posts.

Smithereens

: Could be town who just doesn't know how to have pro-town interactions with people. Like, Smith isn't engaging with anyone in a helpful way to generate good reads or help us understand why he has his reads. He's given some shitty explanations, but they are shitty, and when that's pointed out to him, he either doubles down and repeats his bad explanation, or just ignores you. REFUSES to respond to the case Transcend made on him. Not exactly happy with this.

DixC

: Literally nothing of value has happened from his slot. Just throwing shit at things, calling it scummy for stupid reasons, then ducking away and hope it caused enough chaos to fuck with the game.

Ranger

: Her reads are absolute trash (for someone who I've heard has basically the best reads on mafiascum), she refused to really explain any of her reads or take any real stance near deadline, and when it looked like I wasn't about to be lynched (and flip town), she back peddled and started to say basically "I don't know, maybe he is town." Someone please watch this.

[PenguinPower]

GONNA FINISH THIS

Dunnstral / Maruchan

: Obv town. Read his interactions with me. It's not just because he's buddying me, it's because he refused to hammer me when it would have been easy as scum to make that mislynch happen WHEN HE WAS AT RISK.

karnos

: Obvtown because fantastic reads and interactions.

SirCakez

: All of his reads and comments are perfect, but he isn't active enough.

Chip Butty

: Pretty cooperative, and doesn't mind going out on a limb.

PenguinPower

: The response to the wagon on him is pretty damn good, I have to admit. I couldn't in good conscious let him get lynched, knowing that if we mislynched him, I'm basically a guaranteed mislynch tomorrow.

Aneninen

: I like this active at the deadline. Thanks for helping, buddy.

Transcend

: I like a lot of his interactions and reads, but his absence at deadline concerns me.

drmyshottyizsik

: The way he handled my wagon is a little shoddy. I just needed to put that joke in there. But also, it's true. He could be scum going for town points by looking indecisive on what ended up being a milsynch.

MURDERCAT

: This is mostly a gut thing. His interactions aren't entirely consistent. Way too many contentless posts.

Smithereens

: Could be town who just doesn't know how to have pro-town interactions with people. Like, Smith isn't engaging with anyone in a helpful way to generate good reads or help us understand why he has his reads. He's given some shitty explanations, but they are shitty, and when that's pointed out to him, he either doubles down and repeats his bad explanation, or just ignores you. REFUSES to respond to the case Transcend made on him. Not exactly happy with this.

DixC

: Literally nothing of value has happened from his slot. Just throwing shit at things, calling it scummy for stupid reasons, then ducking away and hope it caused enough chaos to fuck with the game.

Ranger

: Her reads are absolute trash (for someone who I've heard has basically the best reads on mafiascum), she refused to really explain any of her reads or take any real stance near deadline, and when it looked like I wasn't about to be lynched (and flip town), she back peddled and started to say basically "I don't know, maybe he is town." Someone please watch this.

I like this, though I would probably swap Murdercat and DixC. I was suspect about Ranger from the get go, but when she hopped on podo I felt better. Given what's just transpired, I don't anymore. I didn't hammer Smithereens because I thought he was making a risky gambit if scum and didn't think he would this early on. Now I'm not so sure.

VOTE: Smithereens

[Transcend]

Sorry just got back. I work. A lot.

Karnos: IN NO SITUATION IS IT EVER OPTIMAL TO NL AND LET MAFIA DECIDE WHO TO FLIP AS OPPOSED TO LETTING TOWN DECIDING WHO TO FLIP. WE NEED THE INFORMATION.

The Penguin bw has dissipated. I kinda think that was a maf flip but whatever.

Ranger is probably vanity at this point.

Someone giving reads and actively participating > Someone throwing shade the whole time.

VOTE: Smith

[DixC]

No surprise Podo has me low, i've had him marked as scum forever.

Smith didn't go after Penguin, nor did anyone else that could have hammered Penguin.

The probability of there being two-three scum in this list is high:
podoboq,
MURDERCAT,
Transcend,
SirCakez,
Chip Butty,
Aneninen

The probability of there being one scum in this list is moderate:
PenguinPower,
Smithereens,
Ranger,
karnos,
drmyshottyizsik,
Dunnstral

That literally only makes sense if both Smith and Podo are scum and I'm willing to bet my life that at least 1 is town.

Now this is telling. Not that MurderCat is on the side of pod or smith, but that murdercat is trying to imply a discordance between he two so large that he is 100% certain.

The only way to be so certain is to 1) lie or 2) know because you are scum.

Based on what we know we should restrict our kill to someone on this list:

podoboq,
MURDERCAT,
Transcend,
SirCakez,
Chip Butty,
Aneninen

[Transcend]

god just shut up

you suck

[podoboq]

VOTE: Smithereens

L-1

I'll put him back up here. Would prefer Ranger, obviously, but it's more important to just resolve the day than hold firm on a vanity wagon.

[drmyshottyizsik]

I don't know why I have been banned. I didn't harass anyone. I even told Oman I would leave them alone and I have. I sent Oman two messages and when asked to leave I'm alone I did. I said I will but get off your horse. That isn't harassment and is an insult to people who have been harassed. Two weeks ago I asked Shea to leave me alone over and over when she was actually harassing me telling me over and over that the baby my wife lost wasn't even a baby so it doesn't matter. Over and over. I reported him multiple times and nothing happens. This is ridiculous. Fine mods you win I will go away. I don't even want to be on this site any more the way I'm treated. I just wish I could mod my game. Nothing I've done is even related to mafia so a mafia ban is ridiculous.

[Transcend]

wrong thread?

[drmyshottyizsik]

No I've been sitebanned and I'm letting people know it is bull shit since I can't PM

[Transcend]

is it indefinite?

[drmyshottyizsik]

No it's until September 12th, but it's bull shit. I can't mod my games or play games, and this is just insane

[Transcend]

can't you appeal it?

[drmyshottyizsik]

I can't PM so I don't know how I would

[Dunnstral]

[drmyshottyizsik]

/I know and I spent like 10 hours on this LoL upick design

[Dunnstral]

RIP lol-upick, never lucky

[Dunnstral]

Ranger is scummy as fuck. Can somebody please take a look at that?

By the way.... I noticed

[Dunnstral]

UNVOTE:

Just saw the extension

[MURDERCAT]

#FreeShotty

[MURDERCAT]

I'm around tonight to catch up, we have time now right? I will probably hammer smith if no one else has.

[podoboq]

I'm around tonight to catch up, we have time now right? I will probably hammer smith if no one else has.

We have two days, actually, if we want them.

[MURDERCAT]

I like smith more than you. I think I still like penguin though because he refused to claim which was weird to me, but whatever that wagon is dead now I guess.

[MURDERCAT]

We are lucky, I wouldn't have given an extension and I don't think we deserved it, but the mod is benevolent.

[podoboq]

I like smith more than you. I think I still like penguin though because he refused to claim which was weird to me, but whatever that wagon is dead now I guess.

"Like" is an odd bit of vocabulary here. Do you mean "I would prefer to lynch smith more than you," or "I think Smith is town more than you"?

[MURDERCAT]

Sorry, I like the wagon, as in I would prefer to lynch.