why?In post 268, Postie wrote:Although I am gut townreading Aristo, ftr.
In post 248, Aristophanes wrote:I was not throwing shade at Postie, I'm refuting something I believe to be incorrect. Responding to "her scumgame is weak" with "no, she literally got Nommed for a Scummy for it" is not throwing shade.
For us to be a scumteam, I'd have to be scum. And I'm not scum. So...
In post 249, Aristophanes wrote:I didn't vote Postie because I obviously need a better footing here, as I'm missing too many things (as Elyse noted). I need to reevaluate things before proceeding.
These feel gut towny for some reason.In post 251, Aristophanes wrote:Oh.
Well, from my experience, your scum game is not weak at all. I may be tainted by that first encounter though. RC talked you up A Lot! And I respect his opinions on players quite a bit.
I like how you call me out on being different but then just leave those comments hanging in the air without saying anything about what you think they mean with regards to my alignment.In post 278, GuiltyLion wrote:I guess I will just say that Postie's approach towards her gut townread on Aristo feels different this game than her approach in Word Sneak 2, and I thought Aristo was far townier in WS2 than he is here. In WS2 she said she thought he was probably town but still pushed him on things and asked for explanations, here she's kinda just ignoring him.
Those have had zero traction though. And the fact that the Aristo wagon has sprung up so organically and no one is being particularly forceful about it I feel rules out the possibility of scum bussing.In post 281, Elyse wrote:There was an attempt to counter wagon on me and one on Bullet.
a) Why are you townreading the people on the wagon?In post 281, Elyse wrote:I am townreading everyone on the wagon and strongly scumreading Aris.
When did this opinion change?In post 205, Postie wrote:Don't have one. I agree his opening was a bit off, but not off enough for me to consider him a scumread.In post 202, GuiltyLion wrote:Postie what's your read on Aristo?
I think his wagon is largely, if not completely, town-driven. Maybe there's a scum sitting on it somewhere, but I think the people actually pushing it are likely town.
Then why don't you just come out and say it instead of aimlessly throwing shade?In post 283, GuiltyLion wrote:I think it's pretty clear what they mean with regards to my opinion of your alignment
Around post 248.In post 285, GuiltyLion wrote:When did this opinion change?
Because one says "here is why I'm scumreading Postie" and the other says "hey guys have you noticed this thing Postie did? isn'tIn post 288, GuiltyLion wrote:P-EDIT: what's the alignment-indicative difference between me explicitly saying "Postie's townread on Aristo doesn't look like the last time I played with town!her and she has a townread on Aristo,therefore I think she's scummy" vs omitting that last part? That feels like a semantic point from you
You ruled out bussing but then ask why everyone being town on the wagon has to do with Aris' alignment. Lol. Bussing this early on day 1 in a micro when Aris isn't an obvious lynch is an unlikely move for scum so a wagon with a bunch of townies on it looks good to me.In post 284, Postie wrote:Those have had zero traction though. And the fact that the Aristo wagon has sprung up so organically and no one is being particularly forceful about it I feel rules out the possibility of scum bussing.In post 281, Elyse wrote:There was an attempt to counter wagon on me and one on Bullet.
This is a mislynch. Unvote.
a) Why are you townreading the people on the wagon?In post 281, Elyse wrote:I am townreading everyone on the wagon and strongly scumreading Aris.
b) Even if everyone on the wagon were town, what does that have anything to do with Aristo's alignment?
Yeah because town never wagon town amiriteIn post 291, Elyse wrote:You ruled out bussing but then ask why everyone being town on the wagon has to do with Aris' alignment. Lol. Bussing this early on day 1 in a micro when Aris isn't an obvious lynch is an unlikely move for scum so a wagon with a bunch of townies on it looks good to me.
Do you see my vote?In post 291, Elyse wrote:Not going through my reasons for townreading the three of them, do you disagree with any?
In post 293, Elyse wrote:Are you seriously trying to argue that a town led wagon is more likely to be scum?
No. I'm saying town-led wagons on town happen often enough that saying "this wagon is likely on scum because the people on it are town" is bullshit.
Okay. Why?In post 293, Elyse wrote:Your reason for voting GL is bad.
I'm saying it's a town-led wagon on town.In post 296, Elyse wrote:Except both of us agreed bussing is unlikely. So what wagon composition should I be looking for?
Hmmn, perhaps. It's still giving me weird feelings though. :/In post 296, Elyse wrote:GL didn't back down or take a wishy-washy position when you questioned him which makes me think his intention was to scumread you.
