New York 196: My Game, My Flavor Mafia (Mafia Win)

[kraska77]

im gonna need a little hand holding here
so we have an even night doctor, a doctor, a nurse and a back up nurse?
but then whats the point of the even night doctor's presence?

[kraska77]

wait one more question
lets say day 2 ended in a mirhawk lynch and mirhawk was indeed an even night doctor
would the nurse take mirhawk's place then? or is the nurse a stand by for the full doctor only?

[beeboy]

I would assume the nurse takes any form of doctor.

[Boem_u_dusi]

wait one more question
lets say day 2 ended in a mirhawk lynch and mirhawk was indeed an even night doctor
would the nurse take mirhawk's place then? or is the nurse a stand by for the full doctor only?

Good morning.

Something doesn't add up here. I think Mirhawk lied. Possibly Almost50 too.

VOTE: Mirhawk

[Transcend]

Yo dunn who did you shoot?

[Mirhawk]

Nurse would also inherit from a scum doc.

That being said B's right, there are too many protectives. I think fifty would have to be scum unless they have some serious power.

I protected podoboq last night.

Vote: fifty

I think our setup is light on full power roles hence the double backups, the half doc, and the one shot vig. I don't think the full JK sense with thus.

[implosion]

Mirhawk, why did you choose to protect podoboq with all of the anti-podoboq rhetoric near the end of the day?

[kraska77]

yeah why not zach or idk someone else

[Boem_u_dusi]

Saving podoboq makes around zero sense.

[implosion]

Okay actually though this post

I'm thinking the main reason Scum killed Titus is because she continuously butted heads with me this game, and my ability will kill anyone who tries to kill me at Night. It's actually pretty sneaky, but it won't work and I'll be waiting for Scum to approach.

Please explain what you mean by this on any level. And why are you choosing this exact moment to claim PGO? Why would scum know that you were a PGO, and therefore choose to kill Titus over you, as you're implying here? And why would scum want to kill one of two townies who were butting heads and distracting the town?

[Transcend]

Don't vote yet we need to acquire as much information as possible.

[Boem_u_dusi]

Transcend, you lost about every ounce of credibility when you hammered town doctor.

[Transcend]

Oh well.

[kraska77]

my head hurts but i'll try to make sense of this
podo said he'll vindicate mirhawk on day3 or his nk alone would be enough to vindicate him
so why would mirhawk protect him?

[podoboq]

Nurse would also inherit from a scum doc.

That being said B's right, there are too many protectives. I think fifty would have to be scum unless they have some serious power.

I protected podoboq last night.

Vote: fifty

I think our setup is light on full power roles hence the double backups, the half doc, and the one shot vig. I don't think the full JK sense with thus.

You're wrong about a lot of things.

I'm V/LA, so not really gonna get a big chance to engage until late tomorrow. That said, here we go.

I'm Macho.

WHAT THE FUCK IS HAPPENING

I thought the other large I played was chaos, but what even is this? We have two different mason pair claims, four macho claims (I think two were serious), and one of the masons is also macho? Like, do the other masons want to claim a modifier too while we're at it?

Are they all macho? Is every townie macho this game? Do our protective roles serve any purpose?

(This isn't a crumb, it's a train of thought. If you doubt the validity of my claim, please read my ISO and just go ahead and ctrl-f macho.)

I think our protective roles are offset by roles that can't be protected. We have at least 2 machos. I'm gonna guess that we have a (x-shot?) strongman mafia. Mirhawk just demonstrated why the doctors suck this game. He just tried to save a macho.

[Transcend]

Who knows

Still think Mirhawk is town lol

[podoboq]

I'm going to bed. Having too much fun in DC. See you in about 24 hours.

Hope I left you all with a fun nugget of information to chew on.

[implosion]

podoboq continues to be transparently town

[Mirhawk]

It was between him and Zach really. Zach is super town but podoboq hinting a pr and saying he knew about the weak roles means he's probably the first nurse, so I went for him.

The other claimed PR's are a backup nurse and a one shot vig. Fiftys probably scum so he wasn't in the running for me

Also I'm now thinking that maybe Dunn Is town after all, the one shot vig makes sense thematically with the other PR's.

Pedit:

Shit

[Boem_u_dusi]

So our

doc

protected Macho

[implosion]

(actually i suppose that isn't particularly townie since he could theoretically be macho mafia but he's still town)

[Mirhawk]

This further reinforces me thinking that fifty is scum though.

[implosion]

Also I'm now thinking that maybe Dunn Is town after all, the one shot vig makes sense thematically with the other PR's.

When exactly did you come to this conclusion?
During the night? Just now? Near the end of yesterday? Because these roles have been claimed for a while.

[Boem_u_dusi]

Wake claiming bomb yesterday makes no sense, why would you do that?

[implosion]

And @beeboy, can you explain why you believe Mirhawk's claim? I think early d1 will largely revolve around trying to sort mirhawk and a50, and I'd like to see some cogent arguments for both sides of each of them.

It'd also just be nice to see you doing more stuff since you've been taking a back seat and I'm still not convinced you're town, though I'm leaning that way.