Open 642 - The Woodshed - Game Over

[Titus]

Before deadline. I don't think my schedule changes. I am just of the mindset that my reads would be altered if I had formed them. Best to trust the group ATM.

[mhsmith0]

@titus: You'd made a short comment a while ago on a specific parallel to your open w range (627 iirc) r; anything else seem notably similar to you?

[Titus]

Just that. It's not a great thing because gut but it's ok for Day 1.

[Xkfyu]

Also the weirdly high town read of alpaca

Yeah, I definitely see your point now.

[mhsmith0]

Just that. It's not a great thing because gut but it's ok for Day 1.

Its day 2 tho.

[mhsmith0]

Actually in kinda curious what alpaca thinks of all this. Haven't heard from him in a while.

[PantherPunt]

Hi guys
Who is scum

Well to be frank.
If we knew that, we wouldn't exactly have needed you in the game in the first place.
I've tried. I can't get a solid grip. The closest I've got is mhsmith, and even that's just a guess.

So I stopped my catchup to ISO ranger and of all her posts, this is the one that is blasting me in the face. I don't think Ranger is scum here for a very simple reason.

She's not pushing an agenda.

I've got some scum archetypes nailed down and she's not the kind to play the indecisive card, I don't think. When she has perfect information, I expect her to find something to latch onto and push no matter how shitty it is. It's odd from the standpoint that I don't expect this from my limited experience with her as town, but I just can't wrap my head around her making this post as scum.

[mhsmith0]

UNVOTE:
For now, will be back post floght

[PantherPunt]

like why go from the uberconfident play on IV and MM to saying she's lost?

I have seen that from wolves later in the game when they just push villagers with complete confidence then fall back to the "I don't even know" card later on.

But A) it's day 2

And B) she's on the brink of a lynch

I can maybe see the argument she see's the writing on the wall and doesn't want to spew anyone as town. But I think she's a good enough player to not worry about that and cast suspicion on her partner and town both leaving us pretty up the creek on spew.

Going to resume catching up and see if anything if there's things being overlooked

[PantherPunt]

So there is absolutely no possible short answer to this question?

Never said that. I'm just not in the mood to give blunt answers. Sometimes I will, sometimes I won't. Right now, I won't. Maybe later, I'll feel different and will. But for the time being, deal with it.

Claiming there's a reason while trying not to explain in.

I don't do try. I do, or I do not. I flat-out explicitly am choosing not to explain the townread.

this too btw. long night town ranger: "fuck you" attitude -

Spoiler:

What's the big deal about explaining it anyways when you've been asked politely by several people?

Because it's early-on. I simply don't feel like explaining until it's more relevant.

STD scum ranger: appeasing -

Spoiler:

How did you get a read on Shadow_Step on page 1?

Two sources.
First, mod error. Shadow_step replaced in for a slot who, as Persivul explicitly said, did not pick up their role PMs. If the slot were scum, then we wouldn't have had scum choose the setup.
Second, and using less controversial logic, 17 didn't look like an RVS vote on a scumbuddy.

I don't love giving away my tells on people but this is a semi critical lynch

[DrippingGoofball]

She's not pushing an agenda.

The agenda is non-committal passive scum.

[Xkfyu]

She's not pushing an agenda.

The agenda is non-committal passive scum.

And surviving this one day.

[PantherPunt]

She's not pushing an agenda.

The agenda is non-committal passive scum.

How much have you read

[PantherPunt]

You're not xkf from 2p2 are you?

who goes on vla for 3 weeks

No.

btw these were separate thoughts

second part was about btd saying he's on vla until august 9th

[Xkfyu]

You're not xkf from 2p2 are you?

who goes on vla for 3 weeks

No.

btw these were separate thoughts

second part was about btd saying he's on vla until august 9th

Oh, well, the answer is still "no" to both.

[Xkfyu]

You're not xkf from 2p2 are you?

who goes on vla for 3 weeks

No.

btw these were separate thoughts

second part was about btd saying he's on vla until august 9th

Oh, well, the answer is still "no" to both.

Wow, I just now got what you were saying.

The lack of a question mark after the V/LA comment really messed me up.

[Xkfyu]

Holy shit, the apathy in this game is real.

You guys have been doing this D2 thing for going on 6 weeks now huh?

[PantherPunt]

I'm through the first 200 posts and am finding it hard to find the drive when there is no posting and half the players haven't posted since I subbed in

[Xkfyu]

I'm through the first 200 posts and am finding it hard to find the drive when there is no posting and half the players haven't posted since I subbed in

I did a quick skim of the thread.

I'll be doing some ISOs, and read bits and pieces of it, but there's no way that I'll be thoroughly reading the entire thread from start to finish.

[AlpacaAlpaca]

So Ranger now would be a good time to explain your sketchy town read on me from the beggining because I am still wondering on it and it might help a little

[DrippingGoofball]

I'm through the first 200 posts and am finding it hard to find the drive when there is no posting and half the players haven't posted since I subbed in

I did a quick skim of the thread.

I'll be doing some ISOs, and read bits and pieces of it, but there's no way that I'll be thoroughly reading the entire thread from start to finish.

This guy is town.

[AlpacaAlpaca]

he is town because he doesn't read the whole thread?

[DrippingGoofball]

That's right. Scum would pretend.

[Titus]

DGB, I stopped reading massive sub ins ages ago, regardless of alignment.

[Ranger]

@ranger: you were pinged really hard by iv's "ranger or m&m I'd likely scum". Why does btd6's even lazier reprisal of this (and this is the like third time they've done it too) draw no interest or comment from you?

Well for a start: IV flipped town.