Kids TV Show Characters Mafia - Endgame

[Fox McCloud]

Do you think lurking would get him through the game as scum? Nope. It never does. At some point he would be up for noose (if not Vigged / whatever prior to that point) for non-performance if associations are bad enough.

I think I'm pretty proficient at reading Snarky. At least as proficient as you can get with someone who plays as he plays. So far this is not Town Snarky in my mind.

Nah. I don't necessarily find it particularly compelling to think that he would necessarily be posting more to try and avoid being labeled as a lurker by people if he were scum.
I feel like there are a bunch of more likely possibilities.

What would you say your track record is percentage wise with reading him?

are you townreading any of snarky's content?

[Cheetory6]

Shrug.
I haven't forgotten fortnight though.

[Waco Kid]

@Waco Kid

Oopss. My comp just lagged.

Well uhmm,

First: I am confused.
Second: I did go back and read to see
Third: Diamond is trending so I focused myself around him a bit.
Fourth: He does sound scummy and a gut feeling.

Is this okay?

Which in itself is fair, but given you made a bit of a case, and then backed it up with the "I have evidences," in my mind that implies more than the gut feeling you mention here

[keyenpeydee]

Snarky feels town for me but it could change. Probably because of his avi that makes me think he's a townie but I half read him as a scum and it sounded scum. It could change though.

[Fox McCloud]

like...

i get "defensiveness" thrown in my face when my overall point is that none of the things he called scummy are really that scummy

claiming town is pretty solidly nai and has more to do w/ individual habits/idiosyncrasies than anything. anyone who's played a few games here should know that some ppl's routines include "town claiming"
even ignoring the fact that luna townhunts (which snarky wouldnt know if he never played w her), how is calling someone town after 3 posts inherently scummy? is there a magical threshold for giving a read? what is it?
the other one he just glommed onto what imperium said so... ok

[keyenpeydee]

@Waco Kid

Oopss. My comp just lagged.

Well uhmm,

First: I am confused.
Second: I did go back and read to see
Third: Diamond is trending so I focused myself around him a bit.
Fourth: He does sound scummy and a gut feeling.

Is this okay?

Which in itself is fair, but given you made a bit of a case, and then backed it up with the "I have evidences," in my mind that implies more than the gut feeling you mention here

Read back the one you quoted about me. That's what I meant as evidences

[Fox McCloud]

Shrug.
I haven't forgotten fortnight though.

how is that germane to anything that's been said?

[Fox McCloud]

you dont have to preach to me about the importance of differentiating lynchbait-y behavior from scummy behavior

is that the point or what?

[Cephrir]

hmmmmm

[keyenpeydee]

hmmmmm

what? got anything?

[Cheetory6]

Well, firstly, your entire post about snarky was you just taking every point he made and asking why it was scummy.
In particular you being nitpicky about him asking you guys about why you were townreading luna felt pretty wonky. The way you were framing it was like "snarky is trying to make us look bad" when to me it seemed pretty plausible that he could just be trying to parse you? because him wanting to press on something that doesn't make sense to him seems like something pretty standard?

Also, IIRC you couldn't read snarky in fortnight and that read was based largely on his tone. If you're being serious about scumreading Snarky here, I would question why?

[Cephrir]

a head full of empty

does that count?

(don't worry about it)

[Fox McCloud]

VOTE: cheetory

[Cheetory6]

Why you were townreading DS* gah. Workposts are hard.

[Cheetory6]

I'll probably vote Fox if they keep playing at this level.

[Fox McCloud]

The way you were framing it was like "snarky is trying to make us look bad" when to me it seemed pretty plausible that he could just be trying to parse you?

yes that is ALL my point
as i JUST made a post explaining

like...

i get "defensiveness" thrown in my face when my overall point is that none of the things he called scummy are really that scummy

claiming town is pretty solidly nai and has more to do w/ individual habits/idiosyncrasies than anything. anyone who's played a few games here should know that some ppl's routines include "town claiming"
even ignoring the fact that luna townhunts (which snarky wouldnt know if he never played w her), how is calling someone town after 3 posts inherently scummy? is there a magical threshold for giving a read? what is it?
the other one he just glommed onto what imperium said so... ok

[Fox McCloud]

I'll probably vote Fox if they keep playing at this level.

wow...

[Fox McCloud]

Also, IIRC you couldn't read snarky in fortnight and that read was based largely on his tone. If you're being serious about scumreading Snarky here, I would question why?

you dont remember correctly. it was based on his inactivity.

[Cheetory6]

So it's shocking to you that snarky would find other aspects of your play sketchy and was poking at the strongest stance you'd taken to that point?
Wow almost like people ask questions about details that might not lead to anything because holy canoli who would ever try to poke at things to see if there's maybe something there that doesn't fit.

It was a fucking bad reason for you to be throwing pushback at Snarky.
And it's even worse that you're throwing shit at me because I'm pointing out that it was needlessly overdefensive when earlygame is literally everyone in the world trying to pick at things that might not lead anywhere.

[Cheetory6]

I might be being slightly scattered because I'm fucking exhausted today, but if I get home and you look as terrible then as you do now I'm gonna rip your ISO in half.

[Fox McCloud]

So it's shocking to you that snarky would find other aspects of your play sketchy and was poking at the strongest stance you'd taken to that point?

him poking MORE at the fact that the read was made after 3 posts rather than the position itself didnt give me that vibe

[keyenpeydee]

Why are you so over defensive at Snarky?

[Cheetory6]

Okay, why is it weird to poke at something that doesn't necessarily make sense to him?

[Fox McCloud]

Wow almost like people ask questions about details that might not lead to anything because holy canoli who would ever try to poke at things to see if there's maybe something there that doesn't fit.

64 is a lot less on the "inquisitive" side and a lot more on the "attacky" side

[Fox McCloud]

Okay, why is it weird to poke at something that doesn't necessarily make sense to him?

...

that's a really weird interpretation of what he posted