Mini Normal 1823 - Game Over

[BlackStar]

Isn't that L-3?

[Zyf]

oh hello
he could be newb town VI
or he could be newb scum

either way they deserve lynch
pedit-yeah sorry
i just got worried cuz all those votes were being thrown down

[Zyf]

I can't tell if Snake is noob town digging his own grave or just silly scum. Lots of votes on him in a short amount of time is a bit suspect.

do you have anything else to share
since apparently you were keeping track of the game but lurking

[BlackStar]

I can't tell if Snake is noob town digging his own grave or just silly scum. Lots of votes on him in a short amount of time is a bit suspect.

Do you have any reads so far?

[xSoniaNevermindx]

AM I NOT VOTING SNAKE BOY I THOUGHT I WAS ALREADY VOTING THE SNAKE if not

VOTE: snake

SPEED WAGON GOOOOOOOOOO

[Transcend]

Saru is scum

[Mimikyu]

Saru is scum

Agree.

[Transcend]

Ok mimi you can be town then

[Transcend]

My best guess for the 3 (usually there's 3 scum) wolves are texcat eager and saru

[Saru]

do you have anything else to share
since apparently you were keeping track of the game but lurking

Sure. I thought the case made against Gerry for not voting was a bit weak. Many players are cautious about just voting outright without solid reasoning, regardless of alignment. If there were evidence that Gerry not voting so sporadically was his scum meta, then maybe I see a point.

Do you have any reads so far?

Not any solid ones. I might have to re-read at a later point as this game is moving quite quickly and I'm mostly skimming to catch up. I'll take a look at the Snake wagon, as that built up too quickly, which usually means atleast 1 scum is on it.

[Mimikyu]

Not any solid ones. I might have to re-read at a later point as this game is moving quite quickly and I'm mostly skimming to catch up. I'll take a look at the Snake wagon, as that built up too quickly, which usually means atleast 1 scum is on it.

Do you think wagon speed day 1 is indicative of its alignment makeup?

[Transcend]

VOTE: Saru

His analysis of this bw is bs.

[Saru]

Speed wagons on D1 don't always mean scum is on it, it mostly depends on the person being wagoned. I'm slightly leaning towards Snake being noob town who is trying to show off by making what he thinks are astute observations. So that being said, there's a good chance scum is on his wagon, as he is easy prey for them.

[xSoniaNevermindx]

Is he even a n00b and also I stand by my point that noob not refusing to take human emotion into account is BS

[Xkfyu]

Can you explain to me why it's nonsense? I'm tired of hearing stuff like this in every game and I want to get better

Sure.

In post 47, gerryoat wrote:
Can I vote mimikyu cause I'm jealous of their name? That pokemon is so cute

He asks if he can vote for mimikyu instead of just doing it. Scum don't want to make any votes that bring down heat on them and tend to tread carefully. I would've expected someon who was town to just vote. Especially during RVS. Notice that he never actually places the vote down.

He is clearly joking here, but you (even while admitting that it was in RVS) still try to make something of it. That last sentence implies that you believe he's scum for this reason, and it's ridiculous.

In post 76, gerryoat wrote:
In post 73, Transcend wrote:
Can confirm

Guys, this is typical sonia and gerry. They'll be taking this game seriously in a bit.


lol stop trying to pocket me

Doubtcasting

You can't just throw Mafia terminology about all willy nilly like that. He wasn't doubtcasting, he was saying "stop buddying me," and with the "lol" at the beginning, again, this looks like another joke.

In post 77, gerryoat wrote:
I won't take this seriously until at least page 5 so don't mind me.

He's trying to drag out the RVS by making troll posts and sarcastic remarks. It benefits town to get out of RVS as soon as possible

This is either you as scum trying to get town credits or you as town just repeating some ridiculous game theory that you have heard in the past.

Honestly, in a 2 week long day phase, how much time is really wasted between RVS and page 5?

In post 86, gerryoat wrote:
Why are my maf partners bussing me? We didn't discuss this

This feels to me like he's nervous about the votes on him and wants to come across as relaxed so he jokes that he's getting bussed. Maybe one of his partners really is bussing him

Once again, an obvious joke, regardless of alignment. Anyone can see this.

How can you possibly see this as nervousness, when it's the exact opposite?

[Transcend]

Saru hard claimed scum lol

[Saru]

I took a quick look at Snake's post history and he's apparently played IRC mafia and then like 3 newbie games before this game. Unless he's played forum mafia before he came here, then I guess he is a n00b to an extent, as newbie games have fixed set-ups that are known whereas normal games are a different ballgame. I could be wrong though. Would like him to clear that up.

[Mimikyu]

Speed wagons on D1 don't always mean scum is on it, it mostly depends on the person being wagoned. I'm slightly leaning towards Snake being noob town who is trying to show off by making what he thinks are astute observations. So that being said, there's a good chance scum is on his wagon, as he is easy prey for them.

Not saying this can't happen, but I have never seen noobtown enter a game and try to show off. Seems like a stretch for such an early read.

[xSoniaNevermindx]

Saru hard claimed scum lol

Do you still think Snake is scum and Saru is defending a partner?

[Xkfyu]

What scummy thing did I do again?
when I said this i was referring to "why do you need permission to vote"

Right. You agreed with BlackStar that Gerry wasn't joking in his post about voting Mimi and that his post was scummy. That is clearly not the case.

[Mimikyu]

Saru hard claimed scum lol

Do you still think Snake is scum and Saru is defending a partner?

FWIW, I think Saru is scum either defending a partner or WKing Snake.

VOTE: Saru

[Saru]

Speed wagons on D1 don't always mean scum is on it, it mostly depends on the person being wagoned. I'm slightly leaning towards Snake being noob town who is trying to show off by making what he thinks are astute observations. So that being said, there's a good chance scum is on his wagon, as he is easy prey for them.

Not saying this can't happen, but I have never seen noobtown enter a game and try to show off. Seems like a stretch for such an early read.

Well reads need to start somewhere, no?

[Transcend]

I think snake contradicted himself pretty hard

But saru defending his contradiction looks more like he knows that snake is town rather than actually town reading snake.

I refuse to believe that the forming bw was telling for him as well.

I.

Refuse.

[xSoniaNevermindx]

Wouldn't...that be the only 2 cases it could be?

[Transcend]

Saru hard claimed scum lol

Do you still think Snake is scum and Saru is defending a partner?

FWIW, I think Saru is scum either defending a partner or WKing Snake.

VOTE: Saru

Qft, leaning latter