Mini Normal 1827 - No Flavor Mafia (Game Over)

[Creature]

Scummy or awkward?

[Transcend]

regardless i don't necessarily want your trust.

pedit: good question. awkwardly scummy? scummily awkward? idk. take your pick. a mixture of both.

[Naomi-Tan]

lol if I were scum I wouldn't simply join the wagon like this.

lol if I were scum I wouldn't simply join the wagon like this.

scumclaim

NAI/Wifom; Hey you remember that post I made, my second post. yeah for the same reasons thats NAI/Wifom so's this one. It shows you thought about what scum wouldn't do and then did it. Which is pretty much what I did earlier Because of this, its entirely Wifom/NAI Depending on use. The way you structured it is more WIFOM while I feel my one is NAI. Either way though, you cannot determine anything from it..

Additionally; If you feel XYZZY is not scum you should expand why you feel that way else your just saying words. Its why when I said I was starting to get someone I felt was scummy I purposely left out who because I don't really have more than GUT on that side as there isn't that great of stuff going on.

Speaking of that though

BS'd list of reads so far

{KTS}
{Naomi}
{Jord, BlackStar}
{massive, pistachi0n, Skelda}
{Io}
{Vedith, light, Creature}
{xyzzy}

At the time I didn't question this list, but now I am so.. yeah; Can you explain each of these reads other than the Null line; {massive, pistachi0n, Skelda} Unless you wish to say stuff about them in which case feel free (but those are really low activity people so far) This will allow more conversation hopefully and get some momentum as I feel we are running kinda slow on the conversation front. For the same reasons for wanting his vote expanded apply to this list; Without knowing why on these things we will be unable to look into them deeper and a quick summery on each is great for helping discussion some of the time. More is better but a couple sentances is good too this is D1 and only a few pages in after all.

I'm kinda slow to make my own reads, but I'll aid to get the first list up around page 10, (or as soon as im awake post page 10)

[Creature]

Let's see:

Scum would want to make their posts less awkward.

Town is usually awkward at beginning.

[Creature]

Additionally; If you feel XYZZY is not scum you should expand why you feel that way else your just saying words. Its why when I said I was starting to get someone I felt was scummy I purposely left out who because I don't really have more than GUT on that side as there isn't that great of stuff going on.

Either, I don't have anything more than say other than "was there when she could lurk"

[Transcend]

Can you explain each of these reads

no

it's early and i'm not going in too deeply.

like i said the reads list was bs'd as in i quickly composed it based on what little input we had so far this game.

i'm not explaining my reads on the 9 players not in the null tier.

i will however, explain some reads (if i haven't already) give or take 2 or 3 of your choice.

[Creature]

You have more scumleans than the usual number of scum (3).

[Transcend]

Bravo! Not like I already made that observation or anything!

[Creature]

Naomi

If you do like explanations, why not do some of them yourself?

[Creature]

Naomi

If you do like explanations, why not do some of them yourself?

*poofs*

[Naomi-Tan]

Additionally; If you feel XYZZY is not scum you should expand why you feel that way else your just saying words. Its why when I said I was starting to get someone I felt was scummy I purposely left out who because I don't really have more than GUT on that side as there isn't that great of stuff going on.

Either, I don't have anything more than say other than "was there when she could lurk"

On your lurk statement I reviewed there activity in an iso and its not that great. No better than mine though so eh? But anyway they seem to ask pretty okay questions. but this wasn't the focus of my iso. It was to check your statement and tbh I'm not seeing it from your perspective. They have done 8 posts so far 2 of which was RVS (which arguably we are still in kinda?) some stuff talking about general game meta (the day talk, Putting people L-2) but when it comes to your statement I find it rather perplexing. Not sure what else to say on this topic.

PEDIT; Hey looks like my activity stimuli has kicked in! but can you cover your scum reads as they are most important to game flow? (I know you said 3 but Scum reads are the important ones as it allows to cross check for fake reasoning)

PEDIT2; I haven't been asked for explanations on anything because so far I haven't given out many reads As far as I'm concerned I like Transcend for his early read list (though I'm currently squeezing it for more information to assist town and to try and get a more active scum hunting // create discussions over stuff to get the ball flowing a little better.) and KTS ...... And then KTS was moved back to null.. just noticed the entire game he has been using friendly terms and acting like I'm town which is extremely strange as we are not linked in a role (aka we are not masons//lovers) and I don't think I've done anything too townie yet. I guess this is a strange case of me thinking he was being too friendly? he also uses terms like I'm always right.. so i'm kinda suspecting psychological tactics are at play there, or he is just being really friendly and nice and reads me as town and I'm being paranoid.. Could I get some 3rd party opinions on this matter in relation to his interactions with myself?

PEDIT3; Give me a chance to type XD

[BlackStar]

VOTE: io You haven't done anything useful so far and you haven't even laid down a vote yet after all this time

[Naomi-Tan]

VOTE: io You haven't done anything useful so far and you haven't even laid down a vote yet after all this time

You know what they say about people in glass houses... Yeah I saw this and then read the ISO on IO followed by yourself. your about equal.. so yeah..

[BlackStar]

VOTE: io You haven't done anything useful so far and you haven't even laid down a vote yet after all this time

You know what they say about people in glass houses... Yeah I saw this and then read the ISO on IO followed by yourself. your about equal.. so yeah..

You don't think it's weird that they haven't voted for anyone?

[Creature]

Let's go, 81 is a huge filler.

[Transcend]

Vedith is a bit scummy since he was rvsing (i believe) Blackstar when he had a fos on light.

Lights first few lines were weird, i don't think they were a scum slip but gave me a bit of a bad feeling.

Io isn't super strong scum for me but i kinda agree with Blackstar that she's saying so much yet doing so little.

I've explained my xyzzy fos p thoroughly.

I've quoted a few of creature's weird lines, but the initial sr on him was because i felt him saying that J was guilty was a bit forced.

/phonepost

[Creature]

Jordarrian

Someone got a guilty on you.

lol

[Transcend]

Yeah i assume that was an rxn test attempt (correct me if wrong) but i find it forced because it was pretty clear cut that there was no cop report. I've seen people fake claim cop on d2 to where it's a credible reaction test. But that just looked feigned to me.

[Naomi-Tan]

Let's go, 81 is a huge filler.

o and Light, Vedith, Naomi, Creature, Black, and Io.

All wagon this with me friends

Ew friends are gross.

If scum use daytalk right, any interaction or 'slip' can be fake.

Doesn't make it less believable I fake town slipped in my first newbie game which had day chat. But really any scum 'sliping' town is fake no matter what, daytalk just means they could do it earlier and maybe a bit easier, though in that game I posted that 'slip' was before my partner got on.

I'm just an eager beaver! I'm first on the list because I was the first one to sign up for the game, and I refreshed the thread like 20 times today waiting for it to unlock.

the fact that the scum have daytalk is interesting. it implies a higher than average power level among the town, or a lower than average power level among the scum.

Also a side note I haven't played a closed game before so is this right, and is there any general things to note that are very common to see in closed games? I've read the link provided by Dunn in the OP, and looked at setups for a few games, but that doesn't really get a very good feel for what is common.

P-edit:

Does this mean everybody who has posted besides Jordarrian is town?

I'm pretty sure Kill didn't say everyone other than Jord was town. Not as scummy sure, but not scummy on page 3 wouldn't be a town read for most people.

Quoting so we can see the post (and so I can write with less tabs open)
Okay so First part is filler!
Second part; Shows he thought about if it was a scum slip or a town slip and decided its too much WIFOM to go off of and explains that
Third part; is an inquirey into normal setups for these mini's
Fourth part; is confusing and I'll need to look up what you was talking about at the time, Sec!
Fortuh part take 2; Okay so.. looked it up this post just makes no sense and is entirely backwards given at the time and statements I looked like KTS was scum calling Jord while town calling myself. This is a pretty freaky misunderstanding that I dunno how it came about.

[Transcend]

What did i just read

[BlackStar]

What did i just read

Psuedo-analysis

[Naomi-Tan]

What did i just read

I broke down IO's post 81 to filter out content?

[Transcend]

I don't think it's fake, but you completely lost me on the part 4 analysis

[BlackStar]

Just noticed that you didn't answer this

VOTE: io You haven't done anything useful so far and you haven't even laid down a vote yet after all this time

You know what they say about people in glass houses... Yeah I saw this and then read the ISO on IO followed by yourself. your about equal.. so yeah..

You don't think it's weird that they haven't voted for anyone?

[Naomi-Tan]

I don't think it's fake, but you completely lost me on the part 4 analysis

its cause or poor quoting. I starting looking at it. Then I found I was missing vital information namely KTS's reads at the bottom of page 3. So I had to look those up and created a new line to analyse it properly. I could of redacted line 4 take 1, but I wanted to have my thought process down.

PEDIT: Thanks missed it. not really nor have I.