Newbie 1735 - Banana Split (Game Over!)

[GuiltyLion]

DDD won't flip scum, I'd bet the game on it.

[JaeReed]

DDD is roleblocker. GL is goon.

Accountant, you did well. Thanks.

How are you determining that DDD is RB and GL is goon?

The way GL was scumclaiming all day yesterday to try to get the lynch off DDD. The way he scumclaimed with the hammer on copper to stop DDD getting lynched.

DDD's refusal to claim because he can't even claim a PR without getting CC'ed and potentially lynched anyway. Yet he can't claim VT because he'd definitely be lynched. Basically, his play and GL's play indicates DDD is the roleblocker.

[goodmorning]

jae what are you talking about


ddd it's this fucking game

[JaeReed]

Iron asked how I determined GL was goon and DDD roleblocker. That was my answer.

[Dragonfire]

I feel pretty indifferent to that at this point.

I think we should lynch you, are you fine with that then?

We're not lynching someone who the cop softed an innocent report on.

I thought drealmerz (and as a result, jon) slot was a PR. Now I think he's much more likely to be scum

I really want to do this today though
VOTE: ironstove

Again, you're trying to steer the lynch off DDD. Please tell me why you'd bet the game on him being town. The way I see it, looking at the way the past two days have played out in an objective manner quite clearly shows that DDD and I are not the same alignment. Since I know I'm town, that makes him scum.

Looking back over the vote counts, GL and DDD's votes stayed on seperate slots until the lynch was imminent Day 1. It looks like the same thing was happening Yesterday.

@ GL, you can start pushing the case on me all you want. I'm convinced it is you and DDD.

Pedit me either, I'd rather see your flip Today, tbh.

@ everyone else I don't care which goes first. I think we found the scum team.

Just because nobody has mentioned it already, this is MyLo. Unless the doctor pulls off another successful save tonight, we will lose if we mislynch today. That said, I'm convinced DDD is scum so I'll take that risk.

I'm not yet ready to call GL definite scum though. Although his associations with DDD make him look suspicious if DDD turns out to be scum, I'm definitely not discounting the possibility of you being scum. And there's always a chance that Accountant's report was on DDD not GM, or that he was roleblocked on Night 1, so GM's not confirmed town either. But a scum-flip from DDD would clear Jae and iron beyond all doubt for me.

jae what are you talking about

I think he's trying to say that DDD is the roleblocker because the other scum (which he thinks is GL) is trying very hard to save him. But I disagree, I think it's equally as likely that DDD is the regular goon. I don't think his specific role has anything to do with this.

[jon_h61]

lol, that's absolutely a scumpost

VOTE: jon_h61

Omgus. Make a case, I'll still be Town. I'm interested to see your scum play anyway.

[goodmorning]

jae, lion doesn't really look that scummy is what i meant

[goodmorning]

Actually, I'd expect Scum to approach a wagon on their RB exactly as I've approached the DDD wagon.


Make of that what you all will.

[JaeReed]

Just because nobody has mentioned it already, this is MyLo. Unless the doctor pulls off another successful save tonight, we will lose if we mislynch today.

Incorrect. We're at 7 people currently, 2 scum.

Assuming worst case scenario which is DDD town, we lynch him today, and no doc save, we end up at 5 people, 2 scum. Which is then 3 town, 2 scum. Lylo.

So we still have a mislynch. Worst case in DDD town means I have to re-evaluate based on his flip and we step carefully in lylo. Best case is he's scum and we end up 5 people, 1 scum. 4 town, 1 scum. So still we can mislynch.

For those who think both myself and DDD are town: I'm autovoting DDD in lylo if it gets there. Use your mislynch wisely, and only risk it on either me or him, because in the case that we're both town we're both going to end up in lylo for that scenario to happen, and I will not pause to consider wifom. I will just autovote him in my first post of the day and town will have lost if we're both town.

So yeah, best thing town can do right now is choose between myself or DDD, regardless of reads on anyone else.

[JaeReed]

jae, lion doesn't really look that scummy is what i meant

I've found him to be extremely scummy, but it's obvious by now that we both look for completely different things. Either way; looking at GL can wait until DDD flips.

Actually, I'd expect Scum to approach a wagon on their RB exactly as I've approached the DDD wagon.


Make of that what you all will.

Yup, I don't disagree with that either, but there are multiple ways for scum to approach a wagon on their RB, and also you're town.

[jon_h61]

So yeah, best thing town can do right now is choose between myself or DDD, regardless of reads on anyone else

VOTE: DDD

[ironstove]

Just a friendly reminder to everyone here that if DDD flips scum, I was the one who called it from D1 and you all had to lynch a town, then have the PR killed before you listened. Thanks!

[goodmorning]

i think that might have been hammer??????

[JaeReed]

Nope, one more is needed.

[goodmorning]

No, it's definitely four. You, iron, jon, Dragon.

I'd be annoyed with it but we've all said everything there is to say as of yesterday so...

[Dragonfire]

Actually, I'd expect Scum to approach a wagon on their RB exactly as I've approached the DDD wagon.


Make of that what you all will.

I would be scumreading you for the associations but I think Accountant had a town result on you so that kinda nullifies it.

Just because nobody has mentioned it already, this is MyLo. Unless the doctor pulls off another successful save tonight, we will lose if we mislynch today.

Incorrect. We're at 7 people currently, 2 scum.

Assuming worst case scenario which is DDD town, we lynch him today, and no doc save, we end up at 5 people, 2 scum. Which is then 3 town, 2 scum. Lylo.

Oh, my bad then. Nice to see we have a mislynch.

[goodmorning]

I think Accountant probably just read me well but LET'S NOT SPECULATE ON THAT STILL FFS

[JaeReed]

No, it's definitely four. You, iron, jon, Dragon.

I'd be annoyed with it but we've all said everything there is to say as of yesterday so...

Ah you're right. For some reason I had it in my head that we needed 5 to lynch. Cool.

Are your scumreads still the same as they were yesterday? What do you think of jon quoting my post as his reasoning to hammer when earlier he'd supposedly come to DDD/GL of his own accord?

[JaeReed]

I would be scumreading you for the associations but I think Accountant had a town result on you so that kinda nullifies it.

nah didn't need a town result to see gm was likely town for the way she approached the game.

[ironstove]

TBH, I think account copped me. Not GM.

[ironstove]

jon is town, gm is town, jae is town, iron is town but a dick.

That leaves DDD, Dragon, Guilty as scum bucket. If Jae wants to lynch DDD, I'm fine with this.

This is the post that made me think he copped me.

[GuyInFreezer]

VOTE COUNT 3.01

Debonair Danny DiPietro (4):

Dragonfire, JaeReed, ironstove, jon_h61

Dragonfire (1):

Debonair Danny DiPietro

jon_h61 (1):

GuiltyLion


Not voting: goodmorning

With 7 it takes 5 to lynch

The deadline is in (expired on 2016-10-12 12:34:46)

[GuyInFreezer]

Debonair Danny DiPietro,

Mafia Roleblocker

, was lynched Day 3.

Now it is Night 3.

The deadline is in (expired on 2016-10-02 08:24:43).

[GuyInFreezer]

goodmorning,

Town Doctor

, was killed Night 3.

Now it is Day 4.

The deadline is in (expired on 2016-10-16 09:13:32).

[Dragonfire]

Well, I'm glad that we finally saw the light and lynched DDD. Pity about GM's death though

Looking at GM's early D2 posts, I'm guessing she saved Jae on N1, like copper instructed in his night action plan.

Well, at least now we won't have 20-page arguments about who misunderstood what post.

I still have a townread on Jae. Other than that, I'm scrapping everything and restarting.

p-edit: Doc, JK, or BP.

Tempted to sheep Jae but it's probably a little early for L-1.

@Lion: Then why wouldn't they actually come up with something decent?

I think it's fair to say that DDD's scumflip basically confirms Jae, iron and I as town. Which leaves GL and jon. We have a mislynch today (4 town, 1 scum) and then tomorrow it will be LyLo if we lynch wrong. I'm feeling pretty good about our chances here.

VOTE: GL

Your associations with DDD look worse than jon's, and so I think we should lynch you first. If you flip town we'll lynch jon tomorrow. Because Jae is my top townread and very likely the target of the N1 doctor save, and I very highly doubt scum!iron would behave like that with regards to DDD. So I'm willing to write both of them off as confirmed town.