Newbie 1742 Earth - Game Over

[Accountant]

even without my game or town accountant -> scum huntress or any of that gimmick, huntress is objectively scummy

1) start of day push on pp
2) votes icy, then immediately OMGUSes me once I scumread her
3) only interested in throwing shade rather than actually wanting questions answered

[Huntress]

1) Yep. It's called scumhunting. I was satisfied with Penguin's responses so moved on to Icy.

2) Nothing immediate about it. It was three days later than the vote on Icy that I moved my vote to you after you sheeped Penguin's vote on me then scumclaimed in 171. The fact that you had ignored my question in 118 challenging your claim of convenient inactivity on Icy's part was another factor.

3) I

always

want my questions answered. However, as you have made it clear you won't, or can't, give me answers I don't see any point in banging my head against a brick wall over them.

In short, I'm scumreading you because you're not trying to work out my alignment, instead you're just trying to get a lynch on me.

[hinanawiscarlet]

Reee

I trust my gut better than my mom's life decisions for me
VOTE: Huntress

[Accountant]

Just play the game, guys. Humor me on this. Also, anyone who's trying to say me and Huntress can be town together is scummy. Looks like they're trying to lynch me while keeping their buddy alive.

[Accountant]

Wow, didn't expect that Scarlet vote. Not sure what to make of it. Good job Scarlet!

[PenguinPower]

then scumclaimed in 171.

That's a pretty weak example of a scum claim.

[Accountant]

then scumclaimed in 171.

That's a pretty weak example of a scum claim.

It's not a scum claim at all. Huntress is literally sitting there lying their ass off.

[Huntress]

That's a pretty weak example of a scum claim.

If he is town there is no way he could claim a confirmed win from lynching two players whose alignment he could not know. He

knows

that but he said it anyway to try to convince you to lynch me. Setting up lynches like that is not town play. Hence the action was a scum claim.

[PenguinPower]

That's a pretty weak example of a scum claim.

If he is town there is no way he could claim a confirmed win from lynching two players whose alignment he could not know. He

knows

that but he said it anyway to try to convince you to lynch me. Setting up lynches like that is not town play. Hence the action was a scum claim.

Nah. I just got beat by town the same way.

[Accountant]

That's a pretty weak example of a scum claim.

If he is town there is no way he could claim a confirmed win from lynching two players whose alignment he could not know. He

knows

that but he said it anyway to try to convince you to lynch me. Setting up lynches like that is not town play. Hence the action was a scum claim.

Nah. I just got beat by town the same way.

when scum lies go wrong

[Icy]

Just play the game, guys. Humor me on this. Also, anyone who's trying to say me and Huntress can be town together is scummy. Looks like they're trying to lynch me while keeping their buddy alive.

So now I'm scummy AGAIN.

If I wanted you lynched why did I move my vote off you when you were at L-1?

[Accountant]

I didn't name any names :^) I don't see how you jumped to that conclusion

But seriously, play the game. Do it. Take a side, don't be a wuss. You know one of us is scum. Don't try to claim we're both town, because that's impossible.

[Icy]

@Huntress, are you arguing that Accountant and Scarlet are partnered? Who are your other scumreads?

No, although that is a possibility. I think the likeliest partner for Accountant at the moment is you but I don't have an individual scum read on you.

Other reads: Still unsure about Icy but I don't think he is partner to Accountant due to the fact that Accountant didn't unvote when Icy was at L-1, which was a bit risky with a player missing. Possible scum team in BlackVoid and Icy if Accountant isn't scum. Penguin, Shadow and Scarlet look like town although the latter two have been playing the newbie card a bit which makes me wary of them.


Town

Penguin
Scarlet
Shadow
BlackVoid
Icy
Accountant

Scum

Huntress what the hell is up with this post. First you say Blackvoid is most likely Accountants partner, then you list Accountant and I as most likely scum?

Care to explain that to me?

[Icy]

I didn't name any names :^) I don't see how you jumped to that conclusion

But seriously, play the game. Do it. Take a side, don't be a wuss. You know one of us is scum. Don't try to claim we're both town, because that's impossible.

Seriously.....I refuse to play your game!

Who is your scum team now that Scarlet is voting Huntress, L-1 buy the way.

PS: just posting that for me because it's a pet peeve, and yes I do realize no one else gives a shit

[hinanawiscarlet]

I didn't name any names :^) I don't see how you jumped to that conclusion

But seriously, play the game. Do it. Take a side, don't be a wuss. You know one of us is scum. Don't try to claim we're both town, because that's impossible.

Seriously.....I refuse to play your game!

Who is your scum team now that Scarlet is voting Huntress, L-1 buy the way.

PS: just posting that for me because it's a pet peeve, and yes I do realize no one else gives a shit

Yeah, because I'm never scum to begin with.

[Accountant]

I dunno. I could see BlackVoid as an edge case, perhaps. Or maybe Scarlet is trying to bus.

The only reason you'd refuse to play is if you think both me and Huntress are town. Why do you thinrk that?

[BlackVoid]

You mean half the players reacted logically. He reacted based on his "feel" that Accountant/Huntress interaction is TvT. Why does he "feel" that way?

How is trying to set up lynches logical? On the chance that Huntress is town, we'd be in lylo so lynching Accountant would end the game if he's town. Icy trying to shut down the 1v1 was pro-town. With that said, Huntress is in my pool of potential scum so I'm fine lynching there.

I think she's at L-1.

@Huntress,

claim please.

I still read accountant as town, but I don't trust my reads at this point. I don't trust anything at this point. And I have to know if I've been strung along this hard. A lynch on Accountant gives me closure, and it puts me at a point where I feel better about the game, because either
A. He comes up town, I feel that much stronger about Huntress.
B. He comes up scum and we are that much closer to winning.

I can understand the thought process here to a certain extent but if you feel strongly about Huntress and townread Accountant, you should just be lynching Huntress without the Accountant detour.

I disagree that Huntress's start of day pressure on Penguin was scummy. But I do think she was too quick to "like" the response from Penguin and move onto Icy, the hot wagon at the time. The sudden switch to Accountant right after he accused her looked like scum pushing back against their accuser despite both pushing on Icy before.

[mhsmith0]

Votecount 2.04

hinanawiscarlet (1)

BlackVoid ,

Huntress (3)

Accountant , PenguinPower , hinanawiscarlet L-1

,

Accountant (1)

Shadowlancerx ,

Not Voting (2)

Huntress , Icy ,

hinanawiscarlet (1)

BlackVoid ,

Huntress (3)

Accountant , PenguinPower , hinanawiscarlet L-1

Accountant (2)

Huntress , Shadowlancerx L-2

Not Voting (1)

Icy ,

Deadline is on Saturday, October 8th: (expired on 2016-10-08 16:00:00)

With 7 alive, it's 4 to lynch!

[/size]

[BlackVoid]

Scarlet's vote is bad. He was suspecting Accountant more than Huntress so I don't see why he would vote Huntress first. It's not consistent with his suspicions. But then I can't see why he would do that as scum either if both Huntress and Accountant are town. Most likely scenario, it's an awkward bus for towncred. Personally, I'd lynch Scarlet first if people join me.

[Icy]

@mhsnith0 I don't see where Huntress moved off of Accountant

[Icy]

I dunno. I could see BlackVoid as an edge case, perhaps.

Or maybe Scarlet is trying to bus.

The only reason you'd refuse to play is if you think both me and Huntress are town. Why do you thinrk that?

Maybe nothing!!!! For crying out loud admit it, your POE scum team is wrong.

Black has intent to hammer.

At this point I believe the Scum team is likely voting with you.

If Huntress turns town, you are for sure the day three lynch and town loses.

[Accountant]

WTF leads you to believe my poe is wrong???

[Accountant]

You're so full of ??? I can't even sort you. Please just stay hands off the Accountant Game if you're not going to participate. When Huntress flips scum, you can throw around your conspiracies about who is/isn't bussing and the scum team's precise mislynch order or whatever.

[Icy]

WTF leads you to believe my poe is wrong???

You really believe that Scarlet is throwing his partner under the bus?

[mhsmith0]

VC corrected.