The problem with this is that there was no resistance to the Gideon lynch, so it was pretty much going to happen. Spyre (if he was scum) would have no reason to participate in the wagon, especially considering how suspicious a sudden read switch would seem. The point seems to be that he gains town cred if he stays out of the vote counts.In post 505, copper223 wrote: @Toto
Your narrative doesn't hold because Spyre town-read Gideon before he was a possible mis-lynch, if anything he may have decided he did not need to switch reads and raise suspicion because someone and maybe even Gideon was going to get lynched anyway, the question still remains, why would you waste a strong town-read on someone that looked like a juicy mis-lynch, and that's why the case that the town-IC did not want to lynch what he consider newbie town makes more sense.
I'd like to highlight this.In post 526, TownCop wrote:It doesn't tell you much: it could have been a coincidental town read which just happened to be the bw of D1
Is not that it's inherently townie. It's the fact it feels genuine. Which contextually would mean hes town.In post 523, TownCop wrote:Yes, but isn't that just like saying doingIn post 519, SpyreX wrote:Frank asking as scum is a smart move cause it feels genuine enough it gives me pauseanything townyas scum is a smart move?
In post 531, Human Sequencer wrote:Beyond that, a lot of Jason's behaviour was inconsistent and quite stupid, like how he would argue with Gideon over the reasoning for an RVS vote, and then jump on Copper for hiding RVS from the newbies, even though this is effectively what he was doing a few posts earlier. This didn't stick out to me before, but it does in isolation.
What changed exactly?In post 389, Human Sequencer wrote:Jason doesn't look scummy to me. Just silly.
In post 534, Human Sequencer wrote:When did I even say that I 'accused' you? I voted for you because I want to lynch you. I thought that was obvious. Where exactly did I say I accused you?
In post 531, Human Sequencer wrote:You're my top scumread because your contribution so far has been 'Hop onto the current wagon' and 'Lurk and selectively reply to somebody who has accused me'.
And you'll see that in 448, you posted zero reasoning for why you changed your mind. The Gideon lynch was a lock, so you were looking for your next mislynch? Yeah, you were the first to vote for me, but that doesn't mean shit, you got approval from Grand Emperor Spy in 470.In post 534, Human Sequencer wrote:You'll see that by post 448 I began to change my mind, and by the end of D1 I had completely decided to swap over to your wagon. So 'Jumping on' is actually a statement you've pulled completely out of your ass, because I was the first to vote for you, and the second to suspect you after Spyre, and I'd displayed intention of voting for many posts earlier. It's not like I took a complete 180 like your post implies, I had him as 'Null read' before changing my mind.
Or it wasn't scummy before, but now I'm trying to get you lynched, so now it is.In post 534, Human Sequencer wrote:Didn't I just tell you about how he was acting with RVS? This is a clear contradiction in motive. First he pressurizes Gideon for not knowing what RVS is, and then calls out Copper for withholding what RVS is. What changed was my perspective-- It's a lot easier to pick this out when you're reading over it for the fourth time.
This reads as scum motive, looking for easy lynches over finding scum.In post 534, Human Sequencer wrote:As soon as I started considering the lynch for D2, you and Frank popped to the top of my mind, and when Spyre mentioned that he was ready to lynch you D2, I realized lynching you had some support, which is what made me decide to vote for you.
Not sure on Frank, but I don't post a lot as town or scum, so *shrug*.In post 534, Human Sequencer wrote:Frank and you? Your slots have been consistently flaky all game.
It was more than just an 'accusation', I was directly replying to your question.Human Sequencer wrote:You're my top scumread because your contribution so far has been 'Hop onto the current wagon' and 'Lurk and selectively reply to somebody who has accused me'.
Dig deep on why because in getting a very inverse feeling.In post 527, Toto wrote:Im starting to like towncop
I just like his reasoning. I also like how he now seems to be more active. But maybe I just got my hopes up.In post 541, SpyreX wrote:Dig deep on why because in getting a very inverse feeling.In post 527, Toto wrote:Im starting to like towncop
In post 546, Human Sequencer wrote:It's not L-1.
