Open 658 Making Friends and Enemies | Game Over

[MiniDeathStar]

Actually scratch that, I would probably hammer Aubrey for information. Too many people suspect him right now and I think at least one of them could be scum, if he isn't scum himself.

I think I need to review open 649.

[MiniDeathStar]

Okay, I think I had just about enough of Open 649. I didn't see MariaR "whiteknighting" anyone though. Could you link to specific posts where she does that?

I'll get back to you on Ari when I review his town game, too. I need a break right now though.

[doomfeathers]

I think Creature is referring to MariaR's defense of Transcend's play when I started wagoning him, but it doesn't look like whiteknighting to me, either.

[Aubrey]

Actually scratch that, I would probably hammer Aubrey for information. Too many people suspect him right now and I think at least one of them could be scum, if he isn't scum himself.

I think I need to review open 649.

Only Creature and Transcend are scum reading me so far. That isn't much of a bandwagon.

[tojam2]

VOTE: MiniDeathStar

Choo choo...

Why the Deathstar wagon and not the doomfeathers one?

@tojam2

,

@Transcend

Reasoning please. Early wagons are totally useless if you don't give your reasons for voting that person in particular.

You honestly think my first post is who I think is scum.

[tojam2]

Looking at p.3 meta from a game I modded suggested that Transcend scum trolls significantly more than other players.

[doomfeathers]

Posting reads is not the same as posting reasons for voting. Also, happy birthday!

[tojam2]

[/vote] tojam2 dude has like 1 post over 9 pages
Also I think zealousness is a good thing for town

So posting Sunday morning, not being on in the afternoon and being at college for most of today is AlInd?

[tojam2]

How did you know @doomfeathers ?

[doomfeathers]

Look at your post. See the icon to the right of your avatar that looks like a slice of cake with a candle in it?

[doomfeathers]

Well, you voted, but you didn't give any reason to do so or help the town at all.

[Transcend]

Hbd tojam!

[Aubrey]

:\

sad can be town for now guys

word to the wise sad: EM does not play the same way as MS. There is no "clear" that we all sheep. We all discuss the game independently and collectively decide who the best lynch is together.

Sad followed typical protocol for mafia on another site. How does that immediately register a town read from you? That is like saying "WHELP this guy followed RVS which is typical on mafiascum, he can't be scum."

SAD should be nothing more than a null.

I think MDS's town. She's being mad at Transcend for a reason, although i dont quite agree that Transcend's post is so annoying you stop wanting to see him altogether

This is also not alignment indicative. Why can't either alignment get pissed with someone when they post in a annoying style to said person?

:/ I can't help but feel as if a number of you are writing people off real quick for silly reasons.

[MiniDeathStar]

@Creature:

is this Ari's town game you were talking about? Where he got RVS lynched? He seems a bit more engaged there but still posts the same sort of fluff. Unless you're seeing something I'm not?

@Aubrey:

Um, yeah, you're totally right. I didn't actually count how many people were suspecting you, but considering Creature and Transcend were so disproportionately more active on the last few pages it felt like half the town was after you. I really need to look at the big picture and compile a suspect list.

Hi

@tojam2

. Have you caught up yet? What are your reads so far?

Fixed URL

[MiniDeathStar]

Omg.

@Io

, would you please fix the formatting in my post above? Thank you!!

[MiniDeathStar]

What are the odds 2+ of the 5 lurkers this game are mafia? I don't think they are *that* high.

[doomfeathers]

True, but let's not assume that it's not true.

[Burgerking]

obv town here

[Burgerking]

i dont think Transcend scumtold but i think maria's defence of that was really scummy

VOTE: MariaR

[Burgerking]

just skim read a few pages and this is the only confident read i got:

creature seems town to me

[Creature]

Not talking about ongoing games.

[Creature]

I am talking about games like Micro 631.

[Io]

Vote 1.5

Happy birthday tojam!

Birthday bunny gives you a hug!


Aristophanes (L-4): doomfeathers, oddmusic, BK201
Transcend (L-5): Secret Agent Jin, Aubrey
MiniDeathStar (L-6): tojam2
Aubrey (L-6): Creature
doomfeathers (L-6): MariaR
tojam2 (L-6): sad1492
MariaR (L-6): Burgerking

Not voting: MiniDeathStar, Transcend, and Aristophanes

13 players alive majority is 7.

Day ends in (expired on 2016-11-16 12:00:00)

[Secret Agent Jin]

So, i am all caught up now and i have to say that Transcend is still on top of my list. That is probably more of a comment on his play style and less of a comment on his alignment. As far as Ari goes, he hasnt really been around to defend himself so i am willing to give him time to reply but the reasonings behind the suspicion on him, fluff posts and no substance, seem valid to me. For now i think my vote on Transcend will hold since its still early on. As far as Maria goes, my eye is still on her and she hasnt posted which might be due to not being on and im willing to wait and see but i still am not getting a town read on her.

FoS List: Transcend, Ari, MariaR

[Transcend]

terrible reads

but you tried, and that's all i can ask for