New Year's Eve Masquerade Ball - [Game Over]

[Gamma Emerald]

What specifically: did you just want to play a game with her?

[Shadow_step]

Hydra practice

Already said this

[Gamma Emerald]

Hydra practice

Already said this

So you intend on making a hydra with MariaR
good to know

[Shadow_step]

Already made. There's just not fun game to play.

[pieguyn]

if we're discussing why we picked who we did, I largely didn't care who I ended up with. I didn't see any gamestate where mhsmith0 was being left out, he seemed slightly more compatible with me than the remaining gentlemen in terms of our play styles, and I didn't care what his alignment was (either he's town, in which case it only really matters to me if the consensus is that we're a town/town pair, or he's scum, in which case whatever). I have no intention of defending my partner or being the last pair left unless I feel *really* sure he's town and consensus wants it, mostly because I just straight up wouldn't be able to live with myself if I was left at the end and my partner was scum for the second game in a row.

if you're worried this is ATE (mhsmith seems to be in our PT), just ask Nahdia.

[MariaR]

did you talk about this post before posting it because idk how he'd know that post is ate before you posted it?
Or am I reading that wrong

[pieguyn]

mhsmith asked me in our PT why I was OK with accepting him so easily, I basically gave him that same answer, and he said he was probably fine with it but thought about the possibility of it being ATE. this happened maybe a few minutes ago, but I don't really see any reason to withhold it from here since I'm pretty sure he asked the same question in this thread forever ago.

[MariaR]

mhsmith asked me in our PT why I was OK with accepting him so easily, I basically gave him that same answer, and he said he was probably fine with it but thought about the possibility of it being ATE. this happened maybe a few minutes ago, but I don't really see any reason to withhold it from here since I'm pretty sure he asked the same question in this thread forever ago.

Ah okay that makes sense then I was a little confused.

[Gamma Emerald]

My list I promised
Cerberus v666 - Nahdia: team is literally conftown, never lynch
Gamma Emerald - Vedith: really confident in Vedith being town, and of course I am. Only team that surpasses us is of course Nahdia's
The_Jester - MiniDeathStar: This pair feels like that *extra* scumread people have to round uot their list. Lots of shade has been thrown here, specifically at TheJester. Thinking it's town.
mhsmith0 - pieguyn: This one is just a flat null. Neither has really left a lasting impression on me yet.
Ser Arthur Dayne - inspectorscout: kinda the "blind spot scum" pair. SAD is a nullscum, IS is a townlean
Dunnstral - Kagami: Kegami's flip-flopping is not good at all. Dunn is a townread though.
Human Sequencer - Parama: If Shadow isn't happening, this is DEFINITELY my next pick. If HS flips scum, Shadow is likely scum, if Parama flips scum, Shadow is probably town. Very informarionally rich.
Shadow_step - MariaR: I've pretty much hashed out all of my thoughts here. You'd have to have REALLY skimmed to have not seen it.

[Parama]

13 pages... let's see if i can catch up in half an hour lol

[Parama]

'Hey look how townie I am'
You're alive. If you know you're town, you can use VCA ~right now~ to analyze your wagon and point out who you think is most scummy, and we can use your views post-flip.

shadow, why didn't you do this?
like this would be a legit helpful thing to do but you follow up with an unrelated question and then another bitter useless post

[Parama]

i legitimately do not understand how anyone could think HS is scum, page 65 is literally an entire page of HS trying to wring information out of shadow that could only possibly benefit town regardless of shadow's alignment

[FakeGod]

@Mod if someone walks from the dance does the deadline get reset?

Yes.

[Parama]

okay gamma's one on 66 and 67 is legitimately starting to worry me tbh. between the lining up lynches and the ridiculously confident attitude while spewing absolutely absurd reasoning it's really adding up to a big ping on the scumdar

[Parama]

Like seriously gamma look at how I interacted w/ Vedith earlier,

if I was scum

and shadow was scum there is no way I wouldn't switch to pushing the Vedith lynch.

Day 3 lynch this if no scum in Maria/Shadow.
Day 2 lynch me and Gamma if no scum in Maria/Shadow

1. this is dumb
2. vedith's still town guys

[Parama]

Why is everybody suddenly arranging lynches for like 2 days from now? Calm down please.

^this, it's literally useless to line up lynches until you have actual flips to work with

unless y'know you're scum who knows how everyone will flip

[Parama]

Sorry I'm not pushing the Shadow wagon but Jester is pretty set on both of them being town and I trust his judgement.

Unvote

Vote: MDS

This is scum she has literally done nothing but fence sit how aren't people seeing these terrible posts. And now she uses Jester reads to give more non commital reads.

I'm sorry but I refuse to believe that MDS is a townie who is so attached to Jester that she is literally playing the game through him.

1. this vote is bad
2. but seriously MDS stop blindly sheeping Jester

[Parama]

Also I'm pretty sure it has been said already
But if Shadow/Maria are both town Kagami is probably scum

holy christ you've lined up like 5 lynches based on this one wagon alone

[mhsmith0]

Lol I'm starting to wonder if smith-pie is the only hood where both sides aren't just TRing each other.

[Parama]

I think Parama is town based on how she is pushing Shadow

remind me to get back to this one

[Parama]

No I'd actually be more inclined to lynch them if you flip SCUM based on my current reads.

nvm no need to get back to it, i found it

[Parama]

Human Sequencer - Parama: If Shadow isn't happening, this is DEFINITELY my next pick. If HS flips scum, Shadow is likely scum, if Parama flips scum, Shadow is probably town. Very informarionally rich.

i'll get into how bad this stance is later but this is also inconsistent with the above two posts

[Parama]

MDS has no scumreads
You have no scumreads
Shadow has NO reads
Dunn has NO reads
Maria has NO reads
Vedith has 1 read
Parama has 1 read
Cerb has done nothing
mhsmith has done nothing (except discuss setup early on ~so~ helpful wow)
Gamma has ????????? reads
Kagami has ????????? reads

Scum don't need to read the thread, they already know everybody's alignment.

[Parama]

You can't tell me this equates to no reads

MDS has no scumreads

like there is literally a scumread very visibly marked are you colorblind too???

[Parama]

SS is a lot more complex. It comes down to the "case" against him feeling like shit(do you all seriously think scum!shadow blatantly contradicts himself? That's a dumb town mistake, not a scum one). I'll iso him after I'm done catching up though,and then I'm going ot iso pie who pinged me with her first few posts today, but I don't really know why.

Town would own up to their mistakes IMO. Instead he just outright denies there was ever a contradiction to begin with.