New Year's Eve Masquerade Ball - [Game Over]

[mhsmith0]

the way you used that quote of me trying to get a tr based off of picking shadow sounded to me like you were trying to dismiss it as a scummy thought.

It was slightly scummy, seemingly like your concern with picking shadow was how it made you look. I don't think it's a major point though.

[inspectorscout]

Hey just lynch mhsmith already


I have seen that actually explaining yourself doesn't have any effect here so I'm just gonna post this until it happens

[mhsmith0]

Mh, town! You can make better cases on people in his sleep. I don't think you buy your own case.

Also, what exactly about my case makes you think I don't buy it? I feel like that's a statement that ought to be substantiated by quotes/explanations that back up the idea that I'm somehow just going through the motions or faking my case etc.

the way you used that quote of me trying to get a tr based off of picking shadow sounded to me like you were trying to dismiss it as a scummy thought.

I wonder how many times I have to type "game throwing" before everyone eventually gets it through their heads that suiciding, especially in early game, is game-throwing and really bad.

[MariaR]

the way you used that quote of me trying to get a tr based off of picking shadow sounded to me like you were trying to dismiss it as a scummy thought.

It was slightly scummy, seemingly like your concern with picking shadow was how it made you look. I don't think it's a major point though.

Do you want to know why I picked Shadow here let me tell you and listen closely now *ahem*

BECAUSE I WANTED TO FUCKING PICK HIM

[mhsmith0]

Also I wonder how many times the board's quote function will screw up and add stuff to my posts before I remember to hit preview before posting.

[mhsmith0]

the way you used that quote of me trying to get a tr based off of picking shadow sounded to me like you were trying to dismiss it as a scummy thought.

It was slightly scummy, seemingly like your concern with picking shadow was how it made you look. I don't think it's a major point though.

Do you want to know why I picked Shadow here let me tell you and listen closely now *ahem*

BECAUSE I WANTED TO FUCKING PICK HIM

Your picking him because you wanted to do so is relatively null; after all that seems to have been the norm, see

I'd say that just about everyone seemed to be lazy about who they were taking and why (and/or just going w someone they wanted to pair with regardless of alignment); why does kagami stand out in particular on that end?

Your discussion of the point afterwards was SLIGHTLY scummy in that you seemed concerned with how you were viewed in light of that decision. But like I said,

I don't think it's a major point though

[Shadow_step]

I'd say that just about everyone seemed to be lazy about who they were taking and why (and/or just going w someone they wanted to pair with regardless of alignment); why does kagami stand out in particular on that end?
Other examples: jester/mds wanted to pair together

Pie took me because I was getting taken anyway, she thought we were compatible, and why not (in PT she expressed a preference for being paired w scum so she could eventually die before endgame, fwiwi)

I don't recall why Maria took you do but I do remember her being clear on it being a useful source of a TR for her

If you think I picked shadow as scum to draw a giant target on my back Vedith that's really bad thinking when I could've went with 2 others.
Can you answer my question.

Pedit: I'm saying you're sudden call out on me was sus as fuck when you had nothing to back it up besides calling something fake and that's the easiest thing you can ever say as scum

It would be nice if I could get something useful from the accepts but enough seem lazy that it seems like a non productive avenue (I recall asking about it and nit really getting anything useful from the excercise). Do you disagree? Maybe you think a partuclar accept was especially towny in nature?


As far as scum!you goes, you certainly could be voting me, but maybe you are concerned with not looking opportunistic or OMGUS-y, maybe pie is your buddy, maybe you have a strategic reason to be pushing Dunn/kagami (possible distancing? Possible hoping to throw dirt on a town pair?). I don't feel like your non vote on me is especially clearing at this point; do you think I'm mistaken in this evaluation and your being elsewhere is an important point in your favor?

I could make 1000 townie posts right not and people still would be okay with okay with voting me. When I'm "so ob scum" some OMGUS isn't going to change anything for me. As scum I'd be thinking of self preservation.

[Ser Arthur Dayne]

Okay new plan.

I will need n*-1 people to proxy their votes to me everyday.

Thanks in advance.

*n=the amount of players needed to lynch.

[MariaR]

Are you saying I wouldn't care about the viewpoints of others on my pick?

I'm not a robot.

[Shadow_step]

Hey just lynch mhsmith already


I have seen that actually explaining yourself doesn't have any effect here so I'm just gonna post this until it happens

Kagami/Dunn has a higher chance of flipping scum.

[MariaR]

The thoughts in my head are not happy ones with this group I swear

[mhsmith0]

Are you saying I wouldn't care about the viewpoints of others on my pick?

I'm not a robot.

I'm saying it's slightly scummy, but also not a major point. Why does this seem unreasonable to you?

[inspectorscout]

Hey just lynch mhsmith already


I have seen that actually explaining yourself doesn't have any effect here so I'm just gonna post this until it happens

Kagami/Dunn has a higher chance of flipping scum.

But those are your reads, and everyone has an equal chance of flipping scum. Remember when I was so sure of PE scum? Follow my obvtownlead pls

[MariaR]

Are you saying I wouldn't care about the viewpoints of others on my pick?

I'm not a robot.

I'm saying it's slightly scummy, but also not a major point. Why does this seem unreasonable to you?

Do you hear yourself?
YOU ARE SAYING. I SHOULDN'T CARE. IF PEOPLE FIND ME SCUMMY. ABOUT MY PICK CHOICE.

[mhsmith0]

Are you saying I wouldn't care about the viewpoints of others on my pick?

I'm not a robot.

I'm saying it's slightly scummy, but also not a major point. Why does this seem unreasonable to you?

Do you hear yourself?
YOU ARE SAYING. I SHOULDN'T CARE. IF PEOPLE FIND ME SCUMMY. ABOUT MY PICK CHOICE.

Given that I'm saying it's a relatively minor point, why do you continue pushing on it? Do you truly think it's unreasonable to think that a WIFOM self-defense is slightly scummy?

[Parama]

Hey can everyone do me a favor.

Copy+paste this and post it:

Code: Select all

[v]Shadow_step[/v]

Thanks!

[pieguyn]

ya this has gone on for way too long.

I want to look through this game mhsmith is talking about (even though I don't know if I'll get anything from it. I am not particularly good with cold meta), but who here disagrees with just chain lynching Jester -> mhsmith0 -> S_S and going from there?

I'm pretty sure all three of these pairs are widely marked for death and aren't making it to endgame in any universe, but we continue to sit here trying to argue about a singular best lynch from all of them.

seriously, who here disagrees with this?

[Nahdia]

So I currently spend my days at work and after that in bed cause I'm sick and can't think at times, it gets worse the later the hour and I get back home pretty late... Gimme time until tomorrow, I'll post my final reads and after that do whatever you want.

>offering "final reads"
>isn't even the leading wagon

It's a terrible post, sure, but is it wolfy or lynchbaity? That post in particular feels like it could go either way.

It's fence sitting sure but is it wolfy or lynchbaity? This post in particular feels like it is.

My point was that Nahdia was reading into a post that, while bad, was essentially null. Your post here, meanwhile, is apparnetly just a shit post? And while you're here, could you answer my earlier post?

Would someone make sure a horrible white knight of their partner? It almost feels as if you know Jester is just scummy town here. Hrrrrrmmmmmm............

[mhsmith0]

Would someone make sure a horrible white knight of their partner? It almost feels as if you know Jester is just scummy town here. Hrrrrrmmmmmm............

I don't know whether he's scummy town or actual scum. I felt like that post in particular was non-indicative.

[mhsmith0]

ya this has gone on for way too long.

I want to look through this game mhsmith is talking about (even though I don't know if I'll get anything from it. I am not particularly good with cold meta), but who here disagrees with just chain lynching Jester -> mhsmith0 -> S_S and going from there?

I'm pretty sure all three of these pairs are widely marked for death and aren't making it to endgame in any universe, but we continue to sit here trying to argue about a singular best lynch from all of them.

seriously, who here disagrees with this?

Then help consolidate down to two wagons, either by pushing harder for jester or by self-voting. Or you could game throw by leaving the game like you occassionally hint at wanting to do.

[Nahdia]

Would someone make sure a horrible white knight of their partner? It almost feels as if you know Jester is just scummy town here. Hrrrrrmmmmmm............

I don't know whether he's scummy town or actual scum. I felt like that post in particular was non-indicative.

I disagree.

[mhsmith0]

Would someone make sure a horrible white knight of their partner? It almost feels as if you know Jester is just scummy town here. Hrrrrrmmmmmm............

I don't know whether he's scummy town or actual scum. I felt like that post in particular was non-indicative.

I disagree.

And I don't. He's either town being super sloppy about making a post that is transparently bad, or he's a wolf pretending to do this. And I don't particularly see why that post should be considered a strong indication of one over the other.

[Nahdia]

................................................................WHAT? Where did the option for "he's a wolf who made a transparently bad post" go????????????

[Nahdia]

Holy crap I'm so incredibly pos mhsmith is scum from that. I just feel bad about murdering pieguyn before the intermission tho.

[mhsmith0]

You think he's sufficiently incompetent as to make a transparently bad post for no reason at all, just dumping it out there with no thought attached to it? I mean, I guess it's possible, but I don't really associate that kind of extreme level of carelessness with wolves. I could MAYBE think it's an attempt to go levels deep and make a really bad post just for the sake of it being interpreted as town, but that strikes me as kinda tinfoily at this point.