New Year's Eve Masquerade Ball - [Game Over]

[inspectorscout]

wait, WTF?

I misread your post. scout, why is Jester/MDS the scum pair if we're town and not Dunn/Kagami?

If you're scum your constant townread on mds/jester is shit
If mhsmith is scum your jester/parama/smith thing comes to play
I'm not even accounting for you guys both being town; you aren't.

Smith scum --> kill dunn/kagami

Why?????

With mhsmith my lead ends, except fot jester, who should be the backup kill because im more confident in you being scum

[pieguyn]

I'm not even accounting for you guys both being town; you aren't.

this is a bad mindset.

there is a non-zero chance you're just wrong about this and that our pair is town town. I don't even disagree that mhsmith looks really bad, but *if* he's town I want people to have some idea of where they need to look next.

literally the only reason I'm asking people about this at at this point in the game is because... I obviously wouldn't be able to discuss it post-mhsmith townflip, since I would be dead. you can feel free to completely disregard whatever conclusion you draw from this if mhsmith flips scum - but there is no disadvantage to stepping back and thinking about it *now* on the off chance he *does* flip town. I do not intend for mhsmith not to get lynched today - the reason I'm asking this now and trying to get people to think about what happens if he's town now is because I literally can't after we're dead.

please reconsider.

[pieguyn]

the disadvantage to attempting to imagine a universe where me/mhsmith is town/town and thinking about what you'd do next after we flip is... ?

also, if mhsmith is scum I would recommend lynching Jester first; I don't think Dunn is likely scum with mhsmith based on 1. the way he's been pushing our pair all game and 2. the fact that if that's the team his scum approach to D2 apparently was to hard bus both of his partners and derail the lynch from a Jester town/town pair which doesn't seem likely at all to me.

[inspectorscout]

if both of you flip town my reads are horribly wrong and I shouldn't be the person to say who should get lynched. hell, if so, there is a huge chance arthur is scum which makes it better to get rid of our pair.

[pieguyn]

if both of you flip town my reads are horribly wrong and I shouldn't be the person to say who should get lynched. hell, if so, there is a huge chance arthur is scum which makes it better to get rid of our pair.

have you been paying attention to what I've been writing about Dunn recently? I don't think your Dunn read is wrong if mhsmith is town.

[MiniDeathStar]

@pie:

If Smith is scum, would you trust Dunn to be town? Should I leave the dancefloor in that case? Or are you worried about Kagami?

[pieguyn]

@pie:

If Smith is scum, would you trust Dunn to be town? Should I leave the dancefloor in that case? Or are you worried about Kagami?

if mhsmith is scum, Kagami/Dunn is town/town.

[MiniDeathStar]

That's what I was thinking, too.

[Dunnstral]

also, if mhsmith is scum I would recommend lynching Jester first;

I won't.

[Dunnstral]

if both of you flip town my reads are horribly wrong and I shouldn't be the person to say who should get lynched. hell, if so, there is a huge chance arthur is scum which makes it better to get rid of our pair.

So you acknowleldge that your pair should realistically go before their pair?

Except SAD isn't the reason I'm lynching it before mhsmith pair

[Dunnstral]

Should I leave the dancefloor in that case?

No.

[Dunnstral]

Don't leave unless I tell you to

[MiniDeathStar]

Fiiiine.

Bullies.

[Dunnstral]

With mhsmith my lead ends, except fot jester, who should be the backup kill because im more confident in you being scum

How come you're not considering that mhsmith and I don't really make sense as partners

[inspectorscout]

in what way less so than smith and me?

[Dunnstral]

I don't think it's you and smith. But it can still be SAD if it's smith, wheras it's prob not smith if it's you

If scout is scum he's probably with jester pair, in which case we probably lose due to pie

[inspectorscout]

HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA

You're delusional.

[Dunnstral]

...?

[inspectorscout]

Me and pie is lol

[Dunnstral]

Did you even read what I said

I didn't say you were with pie

[inspectorscout]

If scout is scum he's probably with jester pair, in which case we probably lose due to pie

[Dunnstral]

Yea because she suicides then my pair suicides

[inspectorscout]

Then i didnt say anything.

Im open to your ideas...

If smith flips scum.

[Dunnstral]

But you said I'm scum with him?
If smith flips scum you need to suicide.

[Dunnstral]

And before you say anything: the reason in that scenario is SAD