In post 132, Tywin Lannister wrote:Comm: while I already stated how dumb I think it is for a cop to claim in his very first post, it's also scummy for you to want to push a cop claim without even considering anything/anyone else. Even if he is scum, which I find unlikely due to how big of a gamble it would be to fake claim on his very first post (without any reason for it that I can think of if scum), there are more scum than just him. Without a CC, he isn't lynchable. That's common sense. To push for his lynch because 'he's practically a VT' is scummy reasoning. The only legitimate reason I can think of for scum to fake claim there is to become unlynchible D1, but it still doesn't make any sense in the long term. It isn't a good move whatsoever for scum to make (not that it's a good move for town either), so I can't see any reason to disbelieve it currently.
A CC or another cop flip would easily out him as scum
, so with 18 players in the game (glad you counted, cuz I didn't), a fake claim there makes less sense than him just being a VI used to a different meta. Do you have any other reasons for your SR on James? Is there any reason that you've ignored the rest of the players thus far (who have posted at least) and want a quicklynch already?
Well then I guess I should out myself because I promise he's 100% scum with this claim. I'm a non-consecutive role cop. Meaning when I check tonight I'll have to wait 1 night before I can check again. Which is why I would have believed a 3-shot cop because of *some* limitation. But one use when compared to my role? From his own claim he's not even a role cop, just a guilty/inno cop (which he did not deny).
So you can see where my logic came from. I tried to very lightly soft that I knew his claim was BS but it's obvious the consensus would be to not believe me. Instead of wasting a doc on a fake claim for 2 nights in a row, we might as well have him dead D1 and doctor protecting a real cop.
Let's say they got some mechanic to kill me tonight or even today. Well, at least I was service enough to town to eliminate one anti-town from the pool. But if not, I look forward into checking people out throughout the game and helping to clear people.
He's a viable lynch candidate today and for those who have said he's not yet provided zero argument as to why he isn't. Well, you're in the pool of me checking. So guess if you're scum, you should off me as quick as possible now.
