Timeshift Mafia III [Game Over]

[Land of Xanth]

If he were really a role cop, and he really believed that was incompatible with me being a 1-Shot Cop, he would have claimed it immediately. He didn't, ergo he's lying.

You are projecting what you would so in a given scenario as what anyone do in that same scenario.

That is bad. Stop it.

-G

[Land of Xanth]

If he were really a role cop, and he really believed that was incompatible with me being a 1-Shot Cop, he would have claimed it immediately. He didn't, ergo he's lying.

You are projecting what you would do in a given scenario as what anyone would do in that same scenario.

That is bad. Stop it.

-G

Edit.

-G

[James3]

Grey is really trying hard to save his scumbuddy.

[CommKnight]

Grey is really trying hard to save his scumbuddy.

Says the guy who Grey is trying to stop from being lynched. Nice job throwing him under the bus with yourself.

[SlySly]

@Everyone: If you could daykill someone right now, who would it be? (Looks like a weird question, but it has its reasons).

Undoubtedly, James.

[James3]

Grey is really trying hard to save his scumbuddy.

Says the guy who Grey is trying to stop from being lynched. Nice job throwing him under the bus with yourself.

He likely believes that my mislynch would implicate you (which it would). I'd guess he prefers for us both to stay alive as long as possible so as to nullify my ability without you being lynched.

[CommKnight]

He likely believes that my mislynch would implicate you (which it would). I'd guess he prefers for us both to stay alive as long as possible so as to nullify my ability without you being lynched.

Your "ability" is garbage. You have yet to even say any modifiers, so I take it there are none. Which means your ONE SHOT can be trained, roleblocked or just be useless on a dead townie. It's not even confirmable without you dead. So the role is pointless and I don't think the mod would've overlooked such a role being so unreliable for a PR. It can't even be counted as a PR due to its' limitations.

You will hang today. None of your scum buddies can protect you without themselves being implicated.

[Vifam]

Yeah I don't like James OMGUSING everyone that calls him out, when he said he always claims D1 for reactions I expected more but I don't see any reads so far that go deeper than "he thinks im scum"

[Vifam]

I can't tell if he's lying or just playing badly tho

[Vifam]

How are you guys playing Yu gi oh when dueling network shutdown

This must be what it feels like when someone who doesn't know Michael Jackson died finds out Michael Jackson died

UNVOTE:

???????

[Tywin Lannister]

They both strike me as TvT. Specially, newtown vs newtown. Will look at it more after work, but comm looks new to Mafia based on him thinking his claim there was a good idea, since it doesn't really cc anything. They're both modified cops, although one is a non-consecutive role cop, the other a 1-shot normal cop. They both basically outted themselves without reason. Being a role cop should've told comm to expect things like a scum/town roleblocker, scum/town cop, etc, because there's no point to a role cop over a normal cop otherwise. Usually, town role cops need a reason to search for roles instead of simply guilty/innocent, so I think that should've been common sense to him. Due to that, also having a weak 1-shot cop makes sense and fits balance-wise, especially with the 'time shifted' mechanic in play. I think they're both newtown at this point, and regardless, neither are the correct lynch D1.

[Vifam]

Yeah

more people should post

[CommKnight]

However Tywin, the problem that arises from his ability is that it's basically a Sheriff good/evil check of a single person. Unless it is unblockable/can't be messed with in any way, then I doubt that role. It would've made more sense to have me be limited shot and him be non-consecutive balance wise, but since that's not the case I doubt the claim in its' entirety. Because the role itself cannot be proven without his death and his target has 2 chances to die before we even know they're innocent! (3 if you count the lynch possibility).

That just doesn't add up in my head. It sounds too much like an easy scum claim and if anyone thinks logically I believe they can come to the same conclusion. It just DOESN'T MAKE SENSE. I mean I could just shoot in the dark and say Tywin is town. Whether or not that's true, you wouldn't know unless me or him died and even then one cleared townie over a majority chance of him being scum is just too damn high.

The mod also said it isn't a bastard set-up so why would he have a cop that cannot prove himself unless I check him and confirm his role or he or his investigated target dies.

The only argument I can think of is if he somehow manages to find scum with his one-shot then when he dies after he outed his result anyway then we get one confirmed scum. That's a low possibility.

Just... for 1-shot in a game this size, the only claim I could really believe is if it's immune to being messed with/blocked or if it was from a JOAT with multiple 1-shot abilities (which he did not claim).

[Land of Xanth]

The Ali head be catchin up now

[Land of Xanth]

I always claim day one. It provides ample information for me to read people off of.

What do you claim if you are scum?

I fakeclaim as scum obviously.

Watson: No shit sherlock
Sherlock: Push harder Watson.

What role would you fakeclaim as scum?
-Ali

[Land of Xanth]

How are you guys playing Yu gi oh when dueling network shutdown

Percy
-Ali

[Land of Xanth]

Comm is obv town here though

You missed the because porition to this sentence.
-Ali

[Vifam]

There's no reason not to believe his claim

[Vifam]

Unless you think he's scum really trying to pull off a quicklynch on a townie this early in the game

[Land of Xanth]

Grey is really trying hard to save his scumbuddy.

Hi my name is James I really like pre-flip association and saying people are scum without using maxium effort to attempt to get them lynch.

See, I don't believe you truely think you think that your scumreads are scum. If you truely thought that your scumreads were scum, you would push them as hard as you can. You've shown disinterest in doing this and you're being very lazy about pushing your scumreads.

-Ali

[Land of Xanth]

Yeah I don't like James OMGUSING everyone that calls him out, when he said he always claims D1 for reactions I expected more but I don't see any reads so far that go deeper than "he thinks im scum"

The Ali head personally thinks he's just playing badly.
-Ali

[D3f3nd3r]

VC 1.3 (1/17/17)

CommKnight [L-7]

Land of Xanth, James3

Land of Xanth [L-7]

KainTepes, PeregrineV

Gamma Emerald [L-9]

KainTepes [L-9]

Pepchoninga [L-9]

SlySly [L-9]

Harp [L-9]

Vifam [L-9]

Narna [L-9]

PeregrineV [L-9]

Skelda [L-9]

TheFuzzylogic99 [L-9]

James3 [L-7]

CommKnight, Lil Uzi Vert

Zekromaster [L-9]

ssbm_Kyouko [L-9]

Tywin Lannister [L-9]

Lil Uzi Vert [L-8]

Skelda

No Lynch [L-9]

Not Voting [10]

Gamma Emerald, Pepchoninga, SlySly, Harp, Narna, TheFuzzyLogic99, Zekromaster, Tywin Lannister, Vifam, ssbm_Kyouko

Deadline is on 1/30 at 5:30pm EST, in (expired on 2017-01-30 17:30:00).

With 17 alive, it is nine to lynch.

V/LAs:
None.

KainTepes is being replaced.

[ssbm_Kyouko]

However Tywin, the problem that arises from his ability is that it's basically a Sheriff good/evil check of a single person. Unless it is unblockable/can't be messed with in any way, then I doubt that role. It would've made more sense to have me be limited shot and him be non-consecutive balance wise, but since that's not the case I doubt the claim in its' entirety. Because the role itself cannot be proven without his death and his target has 2 chances to die before we even know they're innocent! (3 if you count the lynch possibility).

That just doesn't add up in my head. It sounds too much like an easy scum claim and if anyone thinks logically I believe they can come to the same conclusion. It just DOESN'T MAKE SENSE. I mean I could just shoot in the dark and say Tywin is town. Whether or not that's true, you wouldn't know unless me or him died and even then one cleared townie over a majority chance of him being scum is just too damn high.

The mod also said it isn't a bastard set-up so why would he have a cop that cannot prove himself unless I check him and confirm his role or he or his investigated target dies.

The only argument I can think of is if he somehow manages to find scum with his one-shot then when he dies after he outed his result anyway then we get one confirmed scum. That's a low possibility.

Just... for 1-shot in a game this size, the only claim I could really believe is if it's immune to being messed with/blocked or if it was from a JOAT with multiple 1-shot abilities (which he did not claim).

Comm why are you rolefishing for a fuller claim from him if you have the ability to check his role yourself?

[Land of Xanth]

Didn't realize our vote was still on Comm.

UNVOTE:

-G

[CommKnight]

Comm why are you rolefishing for a fuller claim from him if you have the ability to check his role yourself?

1.) That'd be a major waste of my role.
2.) He's already outed himself, if there's more to his role, then he should claim so when he's being called out.
3.) He's scum.