Civilization Mafia [GAME OVER]

[Nahdia]

Resolution Vote 3.01

Yae (0):

Nay (2):

Leonshade, Creature

Not Voting (15):

Akane and Nebby, Nero Cain, Yuri, MathBlade, Elbirn, Brian Skies, Caesar Wills It, Lil Uzi Vert, Vecna, ssbm_Kyouko, davesaz, Maxous, Sondam, NoticeMeSenpai, nancy

With 17 players alive, it takes 9 to pass a resolution by majority.
Resolution deadline is in (expired on 2017-03-04 09:45:13), at which point the resolution will be decided via plurality.

[Leonshade]

https://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=23&t=70313

My recently finished scum game with Alisae, it's the real reason I've been townreading them. Their play here is not their scum play.

[Creature]

We voted Nay

[Nahdia]

We voted Nay

shh it's early ok

[Maxous]

Not a chance

VOTE: Nay

[Maxous]

PeregrineV,

?????? [??????]

, has been killed during Night 2. They have become a treestump, and will retain posting access to the game thread.

*finger wag*

[Leonshade]

I don't think a town vig would've shot PV so he's pretty likely to be town.

[Creature]

Vigilante refrained from shooting.

Let's see if he'll use it or if he's a scum vigilante keeping his shot to endgame us.

[Creature]

Btw, maybe we'll get 2-3 scum if we look at the votes after ABR's claim.

[Maxous]

Yeah he was fairly obvtown anyway.
I guess it worked out.

[Creature]

nancy, Akane and Nebby, ssbm_Kyouko, Brian Skies

Okay, scum are there and should be sorted somehow.

[Creature]

I built the statue of Zeus. If I'm confirmed as town, scum can't kill me.

Any votes after this is bad.

[Maxous]

I was planning on chain lynching Kyouko and A&N anyway.
Kyouko's vote on ABR was bad and Nebby jumped on ABR as soon as the Kyouko flash wagon grew.
I.e. if Kyouko indeed flips scum I would guess Nebby is a buddy who panicked.

[Creature]

Btw, scum getting Alhambra equals scum

[Creature]

I'm not even sure if I should townread Akane and Nebby anymore.

[Creature]

NoticeMeSenpai also looks bad.

[Creature]

Only posts occasionally, not influencing game at all.

[Leonshade]

nancy, Akane and Nebby, ssbm_Kyouko, Brian Skies

Okay, scum are there and should be sorted somehow.

Kyouko and maybe Brian.

A&N and nancy are both town.

[Vecna]

wow, 4 out of these 5 wonders are incredible scum wonders.

Gay

[Creature]

Try to build them anyway so scum gets less of it.

[Leonshade]

Vigilante refrained from shooting.

Let's see if he'll use it or if he's a scum vigilante keeping his shot to endgame us.

There's a doc in play, so I'm not ruling out the possibility of a vig shot yet. Though with so many players a correct doc is much less likely.

Town vig saving the shot seems unlikely, unless they want to put the shot to a vote or whatever.

[Leonshade]

https://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=23&t=70313

My recently finished scum game with Alisae, it's the real reason I've been townreading them. Their play here is not their scum play.

Read this game if you scumread Ali, he's not confident enough in his scumgame to play like he has here.

[Vecna]

Vigilante refrained from shooting.

Let's see if he'll use it or if he's a scum vigilante keeping his shot to endgame us.

There's a doc in play, so I'm not ruling out the possibility of a vig shot yet. Though with so many players a correct doc is much less likely.

Town vig saving the shot seems unlikely, unless they want to put the shot to a vote or whatever.

really hoping theres 2 docs in play by now.

I also find it rather.....peculiar that scum just happen to hit the treestump straight away like that. I dont want to believe they would sac one of their own, but we cannot completely discount it.

Also, woops (ABR)

[Vecna]

https://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=23&t=70313

My recently finished scum game with Alisae, it's the real reason I've been townreading them. Their play here is not their scum play.

Read this game if you scumread Ali, he's not confident enough in his scumgame to play like he has here.

There may be some hydra dissonance in the mix, or weird OP-vig distortion in the game im referring to, but I still feel he plays very different from how he played in Code Geass as town.

[Leonshade]

Spoiler: Brian's read progression on ABR

ABR is always manipulative. It's one of his more endearing traits.

Hmmm those colours didnt quite come out the way they looked on the coloured palet.

ABR is my top priority lynch. Followed by Davesaz and Elbirn.

And then followed by Kyouko/Ceasar at a bit of a distance.

VOTE: Albert B Rampage

Is there a reason you want him lynched other than him being disruptive to the gamestate? I see a lot of people stating they want him dead, but not for anything that makes me believe they think he's scum.

Also, if it lands on scum, who cares if the Caesar wagon is a poor information lynch?

VOTE: Creature

I've fallen behind. But I do think Vecna was town flailing in response to the pressure of his wagon. I didn't like Creature saying he liked the Kyouko wagon and then jumping to Vecna before it could materialize. I also didn't like him asking who should volunteer to be lynched in the event Vecna flipped scum.

I don't know why people are townreading Uzi. A lot of his comments surrounding setup speculation is scummy. He says most of the abilities are bad and that town shouldn't invest in them, which could be scum hoping to skate by with for a few nights with relatively powerless town while scum get a better shot at getting the more concerning roles. He also had a crumb as early as page 25, so I feel the whole argument of ABR pushing a scumread on him for faking a claim to be either insincere or misguided. I thought maybe Vecna was a partner, but I can kind of see a townie just wanting to hold onto a shitty meta read.

I think A+N is town. I like most of their early posting and don't understand why people scumread them. I also have a townread on Yuri.

I'm busy today, but will return later tonight.

VOTE: Albert

@Brian Skies:

Why did you hammer ABR?