Civilization Mafia [GAME OVER]

[Creature]

idk, is your case on LUV based on meta or just "textbook scumplay"?

[Brian Skies]

I've never played with him.

[Brian Skies]

I wouldn't call it textbook, I just think he's scum.

[Creature]

*slams door*

[Caesar Wills It]

Caesar regrets His absence from this discussion; We have been afflicted with an illness of late. Our Royal apothecary assures Us that We are on the mend and will be fit to return and serve Rome soon.

[Alisae]

Sondam this isn't scum!LUV.
Sorry.

Do me a huge favor and towntell please

This line will consist of a very long line and long sentence which will then result in a towntell.

[Alisae]

Is anyone townreading NoticeMeSenpai? Don't come with associatives.

I am

[Yuri]

same here id say theyre town

[NoticeMeSenpai]

However Creature is probably scum so that makes me want to wagon Senpai less.

Blah Creature and Senpai is a 1v1 IMHO

Stop. Creature is town.

[nancy]

However Creature is probably scum so that makes me want to wagon Senpai less.

Blah Creature and Senpai is a 1v1 IMHO

Stop. Creature is town.

Why? Don't give me this meta rubbish please babe.

[NoticeMeSenpai]

I will give you that "meta rubbish" because it's not rubbish. Stop pretending like you know better than vets who are fucking used to reading Creature, thanks. I've been through his ISO and compared him to the two times I've known him to be scum (once in a game I was in where it was multiball and another time in a newbie I spectated from start to finish) and this just plain isn't scum!Creature. He's active, stream of consciousness posting, he's confident in his townieness (pay attention, this is an ego tell for him and a fairly strong one), and he's not just taking the easy way out in all of his reads by reading the obvtowns as town and the lynchbaits as scum.

He's.town. You need to learn when the fuck to swallow your own ego and accept some people actually DO know how to read others a little better than you.

[Brian Skies]

I would lynch Senpai.

[nancy]

This has nothing to do with my ego, I don't have one.

he's not just taking the easy way out in all of his reads by reading the obvtowns as town and the lynchbaits as scum.

He is doing this, though, aside from like the read on you. Am I wrong? How is the other stuff not fakeable?

[Alisae]

UNVOTE:
Trusting BaeReed here.
Tho right now BaeReed Creature REALLY just looks like a dead man walking.

[nancy]

Honestly, if you think this is ego-related you're wrong. I've asked people to show me how he's Town and I haven't gotten anything satisfactory. His play this game has plenty of dissimilarities to other Town games. Is his scum game so drastically different or bad that he can't fake this stuff?

[Alisae]

I didn't know nancy had an ego :O

[nancy]

Neither did I

[Creature]

Tho right now BaeReed Creature REALLY just looks like a dead man walking.

If you mean in the sense scum will surely nightkill me, then yes, I am.

[NoticeMeSenpai]

This is Creature's scum game. Then take a look at this for a scum game where he stuck around.

There's a reason a handful of us are defending him. The confidence in his townieness is especially a point that I want noted.

Creature isn't just taking the easy road on the reads or he'd have LUV as lynchable. He doesn't. This is his usual PoE based on who he's townreading. What is it you like to say? You're scumreading someone because they have a playstyle you don't like. You're refusing to acknowledge that other people may just have a point when they say he's not scum and provide you with reasons based off experience with the player. That, my love, is a sign of a tunnel.

Like, you can ignore me on Maxous all you like. You can wagon Kyouko because he does need to post more and pressure might help with that. You can wagon me. You will

not

be mislynching Creature this game. Because I will literally vote anyone that's not a townread that I think can get traction to derail this shit.

VOTE: Maxous
Stand by for more on this, but add his attempts to buddy/defend me to the record of things from him that make me uncomfortable.

Creature just is not scum. LUV is not scum. The current leading wagons are fucking trash.

pedit: you definitely do, babe. It's fine tho since I do too

[Lil Uzi Vert]

LUV is scum, you guys just refuse to see it for whatever reason. Nothing he says is townish, his setup spec is scum motivated, and he faked a PR crumb on Day 1 (and we now know that all the roles started off as vanilla). Not to mention he always just claims town and puts on a frown whenever someone scumreads him. His defense on my hammer vote is also just weird, like he's trying to buddy me. Lynch LUV.

I've already explained why I've been acting the way I have about the Eras and the Wonders. I'm pretty sure I'm right about playing it safe as evident of Math shooting PV.

The rest of your points are garbage.

[Alisae]

Hey guys, did you hear the news? Did you hear the news?
Apparently you can ignore just about all the conflict that is happening on D1 by voteparking Kyouko.
VOTE: Maxous

[Alisae]

Also I like how a small early game wagon on Maxous was cool but then that shit was never brought up again.

[Maxous]

Yeah because I started town posting.
You should try doing that.

[nancy]

Uh OK if that is what scum!Creature looks like that is just awful. (No offense Creature.) If Creature isn't scum I need to go back to drawing board and see what's up.

UNVOTE:

(It's just the way I play/talk, it comes across as ego but there's nothing really there.)

[Alisae]

I don't care what people think of me so I don't tend to tailor my posts towards that.