Real Folk Blues Rematch [GAME OVER]

[Titus]

@Titus: I dont care about the claim itself. I care about why you did it. The response you gave, your non-answer answer, is an issue for me.

I'm a mason. You were a mason and I didn't like your claim or how you did it. It's just a fact of life. I'm playing mason like this. You do you. If you're on my list, I'd like to know so we can stop sniffing each other's butts. Otherwise, I'll just pencil you in as uncooperative. Rare I'd see the day where Math is more cooperative than you.

Titus -- What do you make of my reads so far? I know you said you were going to sheep RB but I would like someone's input so I am not shouting into the abyss. :/

-- Math

Pedit: Rach I would be no help then. I would take each player and go through their ISO unless memory stood out. I don't alt hunt. If someone slips then they do. But I don't alt out or alt hunt. FMPOV if someone is an alt they are for a readon.

Pedit2: Not Fury and RM are top townreads for me.

-- Math

Which post? I wanna make sure we're current here. Can you include Narna's too. Feedback either fast or in a few hours.

[Gamma Emerald]

What type of analysis would you like of Kid's posts.

[mhsmith0]

Only been skimming a bit, RachMarie is a townlean mainly because I've seen her scum game twice and both times it was ridiculously obvious and it isn't here (https://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.p ... er_sort=Go and https://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.p ... er_sort=Go for the curious). Titus isn't playing her usual town game at all but I guess I'll buy that it might be how she's choosing to play mason for whatever weird reason.

Will try and catch up more substantively tonight, leaving work soon.

[KidAmn]

Kid is a newb
One of his first games is a newbie

Kid held his own in Civ mafia. If Kid is a newb he is one of the better ones. I would lean alt but as I don't alt hunt please tell me what you think of this game's posts for Kid.

--Math

I'm not sure if I'm complimented or offended

Compliffended will have to suffice

Pedit: yeah that about sums them up

They'd probably be an entirely acceptable Mafia player if they did a little more reasoning and a little less self-fellatory spamposting about how right they are tbh

[mhsmith0]

Kid is a newb
One of his first games is a newbie

-Disappointed klaxon-

But we won!

(also I helped mislynch kid for lurking )

[Insomniacs]

https://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.p ... 0#p9183950

Start there on my ISO. It has been mostly me because Narna comes on super late. I have his latest thoughts on Discord.

--Math

[KidAmn]

Above pedit comment refers to NF since a bunch of obsolete mules ruined it

Pedit 2 That Weight Carries You: the klaxon is for assuming I'm actually a newbie and didn't just want a completed newbie game for the purpose of getting accepted into real games

[Insomniacs]

Kid is a newb
One of his first games is a newbie

Kid held his own in Civ mafia. If Kid is a newb he is one of the better ones. I would lean alt but as I don't alt hunt please tell me what you think of this game's posts for Kid.

--Math

I'm not sure if I'm complimented or offended

Compliffended will have to suffice

Pedit: yeah that about sums them up

They'd probably be an entirely acceptable Mafia player if they did a little more reasoning and a little less self-fellatory spamposting about how right they are tbh

How is posting questions and having to beg for feedback when people aren't reading my posts self fellatory?

--Math

What are your reads?

[Gamma Emerald]

Alts aren't allowed in newbies unless they replace or have the games to SE/IC

[KidAmn]

Alts aren't allowed in newbies unless they replace or have the games to SE/IC

Not an alt though

[Insomniacs]

What type of analysis would you like of Kid's posts.

Just tell me what you think. Like get a read on Kid and share it and why.
--Math

[mhsmith0]

Kid is claiming to be a player with offsite experience, i.e. new to MS, but not an MS alt. Now can this pointless AND non-entertaining conversation drop?

[Wall]

_|___|___|___|___|___|___|___|___|___|___|___|___|___|___|___|___|___|___|___|___|___|___|___|
___|Kid if you're town what will it take for you to get your head in the game day one vs mid day two.|___
_|___|___|___|___|___|___|___|___|___|___|___|___|___|___|___|___|___|___|___|___|___|___|___|

[mhsmith0]

I mean, if people want to talk about kid in this game cool, but "is he or isn't he an alt" is boring timewasting garbage.

[Gamma Emerald]

I feel like Kid is town with a bit of a mouth on himself. His posts read as "I don't give a fuck what you think of me this is what I think".

[RachMarie]

yeah ok this is getting annoying especially since hes so sketchy so we are not really getting any info

so since hes a newbie not acting like a newbie I am going with hes getting coached by his scum budz


VOTE: Kid

[Insomniacs]

I feel like Kid is town with a bit of a mouth on himself. His posts read as "I don't give a fuck what you think of me this is what I think".

What do you think Kid thinks?
What gives you that impression?

--Math

[KidAmn]

Kid is a newb
One of his first games is a newbie

Kid held his own in Civ mafia. If Kid is a newb he is one of the better ones. I would lean alt but as I don't alt hunt please tell me what you think of this game's posts for Kid.

--Math

I'm not sure if I'm complimented or offended

Compliffended will have to suffice

Pedit: yeah that about sums them up

They'd probably be an entirely acceptable Mafia player if they did a little more reasoning and a little less self-fellatory spamposting about how right they are tbh

Above pedit comment refers to NF since a bunch of obsolete mules ruined it

Pedit 2 That Weight Carries You: the klaxon is for assuming I'm actually a newbie and didn't just want a completed newbie game for the purpose of getting accepted into real games

Kid is a newb
One of his first games is a newbie

Kid held his own in Civ mafia. If Kid is a newb he is one of the better ones. I would lean alt but as I don't alt hunt please tell me what you think of this game's posts for Kid.

--Math

I'm not sure if I'm complimented or offended

Compliffended will have to suffice

Pedit: yeah that about sums them up

They'd probably be an entirely acceptable Mafia player if they did a little more reasoning and a little less self-fellatory spamposting about how right they are tbh

How is posting questions and having to beg for feedback when people aren't reading my posts self fellatory?

--Math

What are your reads?

Quoting them both together so you can realise that wasn't aimed at you (MB and NF aren't even that close on the keyboard, come on keep up)

A50's post I talked about earlier pinged me, NF/Rach is a weird ol fight that probably has someone who needs to die on it but I'm not in a position to objectively comment on NF rn, Wall is townleaned because shit I'd vote me

_|___|___|___|___|___|___|___|___|___|___|___|___|___|___|___|___|___|___|___|___|___|___|___|
___|Kid if you're town what will it take for you to get your head in the game day one vs mid day two.|___
_|___|___|___|___|___|___|___|___|___|___|___|___|___|___|___|___|___|___|___|___|___|___|___|

I don't "do" RVS and I don't "do" opening day scumhunting well

So all I really need is some flips and blips and chitz and we're on a 1 way ticket to flavourtown baby

Pedit: ho shit someone finally realised I just straight don't give a fuck any more, we did it fam

Pedit 2: oh u Rach. Oh. U. I'm about as coachable as Tim Tebow

[Gamma Emerald]

Don't get the first question but I can pull up some quotes to explain what I mean.

[Insomniacs]

Still don't see an answer to what are your reads Kid.

--Math

[Insomniacs]

Don't get the first question but I can pull up some quotes to explain what I mean.

Who do you think KidAmn scumreads or townreads and why?
His ISO is barren.

If you think he is Town who tells it like it is, show me where Kid explains his reads.

--Math

[KidAmn]

yeah ok this is getting annoying especially since hes so sketchy so we are not really getting any info

so since hes a newbie not acting like a newbie I am going with hes getting coached by his scum budz

VOTE: Kid

What part of "not a newbie" didn't process

Or is this just real convenient to extricate yourself from that whole mess you already got going

Because I can do 2 messes

I will serve up a mess of messes

Pedit: I mean I literally just posted them but okay Math you keep on being you and not reading A+ would get baited by again

[RachMarie]

If you are not an alt then how are you not a newbie?

That is my point And I am not talking newbie to mafia at all I mean newbie to THIS site because sites not devoted to Mafia play it very differently from the way we do here.

[Gamma Emerald]

the above is a scumclaim

VOTE: ramcius

i keep thinking he might be overzealous town and lynchbait, as per usual but every single post he makes pings me to no end. like i have sorted him games i've played even though i wasn't in a town slot. i got town from reading him. quickly.

this time. not so much. scumfuck mcgee posts all over the place. the most recent one basically seals the deal.

probably staying here for a while until giga has time to talk to me.

Look, Trans! I have a TR on your slot for <reasons>, so let me remind you of our last game together where Scum!Me easily managed to mislynch Town!Ram for this exact posting style. I would have expected you to know better and wait for someone else to make a push and then evaluate that someone else's behaviour.

In other words, let's leave Ram for scum to sort him out. If he doesn't get pushed he needs to be copped or investigated by some means, but I certainly am not interested in lynching him on D1 in this game.

"Remember when scum!me did this? Well I'm not doing it now, and I have a town-read on you! *nudge nudge*"

This feels hella off

This reads as a scumread on A50
As for telling it like it is it doesn't really relate to his reads, just an analysis

[Titus]

Math/Rach, common sense says noob but skilled. I got the same crap.

Driving so I cannot look at iso yet.