Open 690: Kill All Townies - Game Over

[MarioManiac4]

Why don't you think Balki vs GNB is TvT?

[CommKnight]

Hey Comm, since you're here.
Why haven't you poked at my vote yet?
-Ali

Because it's like a trash can. Garbage. (That and you never bothered to explain the vote, so why should I care about a single naked vote?)

[CommKnight]

Why don't you think Balki vs GNB is TvT?

Why do you think it is? Remember, there's 2 scum factions here. Can just as easily be SvS.

[Siblings Pet Doggo]

Hey Comm, since you're here.
Why haven't you poked at my vote yet?
-Ali

Because it's like a trash can. Garbage. (That and you never bothered to explain the vote, so why should I care about a single naked vote?)

Now why is it bad? Come up, we're not newbies, we can go beyond surface level analysis and beyond just saying "this is bad."

-Ali

[Siblings Pet Doggo]

I've been mostly playing reactionary right now because I've been waiting for you.
Now that you're here, I wanna dance
-Ali

[Flubbernugget]

I still have no idea why Balki and GNB are being scum read instead of ignored

[MarioManiac4]

Why don't you think Balki vs GNB is TvT?

Why do you think it is? Remember, there's 2 scum factions here. Can just as easily be SvS.

I like both individually. They seem unconcerned about their images. It would be unlikely for GNB!scum, in particular, to pick a fight with Balki so early.

[MarioManiac4]

Flubbernugget, why is Sesq scum?

[Balki B]

Why don't you think Balki vs GNB is TvT?

Why do you think it is? Remember, there's 2 scum factions here. Can just as easily be SvS.

Odd response from someone who said, without reasons, that my discussion with GNB is more than likely not TvT. You're the one who said that's an unlikely scenario. Mario asked you why you think it's unlikely. Do you have a reason for thinking that?

[Siblings Pet Doggo]

Odd response from someone who said, without reasons, that my discussion with GNB is more than likely not TvT.

That's because he's scum. Aggressive players aren't usually this tame unless they're trying to be careful, which they won't happen as town because when you're town, you feel comfortable on going all out.

-Ali

[Balki B]

I still have no idea why Balki and GNB are being scum read instead of ignored

I don't think Balki and GNB are generally being scum read. It's a small minority who have said that. Why would you say we are being scum read so generally? Who is scum reading Balki and GNB? What are their reasons? Do those reasons look sincere?

And why should I be ignored? I am a town treasure.

[Balki B]

Liking Ali. Agreeing on CommKnight.

VOTE: CommKnight

[MarioManiac4]

Let's flashwagon Delta

[CommKnight]

I've been mostly playing reactionary right now because I've been waiting for you.
Now that you're here, I wanna dance
-Ali

What kind of dance Ali? I'm good at slow songs.

Seriously though, when have you played with me that I care much about being voted/lynched. I'll fight to lynch scum, but I don't SR people for voting me and I don't pretend I'm perfect.

But if you want a reaction to a naked vote, you get a naked answer of it being bad. If you care to explain the vote more, then let's go. otherwise this dance might be a cold one.

[CommKnight]

Odd response from someone who said, without reasons, that my discussion with GNB is more than likely not TvT.

That's because he's scum. Aggressive players aren't usually this tame unless they're trying to be careful, which they won't happen as town because when you're town, you feel comfortable on going all out.

-Ali

Ali here thinking she can read me. Huehuehuehue.

[Siblings Pet Doggo]

Good job.
Now let me hardpush CommKnight.

CommKnight is playing unusually passive rigbht now, in Bill Wurtz and in Timeshift there was more too him starting out. Here there's nothing
It's like he's a fucking ghost. He's not aggressive, he's cautious, and here he feels completely absent from the game.
Everyone of his posts reads to me as "Investigate me"

Posts like 11 and 13 read to me as "Yeah yeah, whatever, right now I'm trying to be helpful while not really adding anything to the game on page 1." I mean like yeah, it's page 1, but when I read those posts, they read to me as if he doesn't actually care about them. It reads fake.

His Game vote is just way too passive from him for my liking, and from town!Comm I would expect more from that.

245 I feel like Comm is holding himself back here, and that doesn't happen you roll town. Same complaint about 251 and 252. I explain more about it in 259

249 just straight up, does not add anything to the game.

-Ali

[Siblings Pet Doggo]

I've been mostly playing reactionary right now because I've been waiting for you.
Now that you're here, I wanna dance
-Ali

What kind of dance Ali? I'm good at slow songs.

Seriously though, when have you played with me that I care much about being voted/lynched. I'll fight to lynch scum, but I don't SR people for voting me and I don't pretend I'm perfect.

But if you want a reaction to a naked vote, you get a naked answer of it being bad. If you care to explain the vote more, then let's go. otherwise this dance might be a cold one.

Even this shit reads fake to me.
There would just be more flair here if Comm is town, and that flair is absent.
-Ali

[CommKnight]

Good job.
Now let me hardpush CommKnight.

CommKnight is playing unusually passive rigbht now, in Bill Wurtz and in Timeshift there was more too him starting out. Here there's nothing
It's like he's a fucking ghost. He's not aggressive, he's cautious, and here he feels completely absent from the game.
Everyone of his posts reads to me as "Investigate me"

Posts like 11 and 13 read to me as "Yeah yeah, whatever, right now I'm trying to be helpful while not really adding anything to the game on page 1." I mean like yeah, it's page 1, but when I read those posts, they read to me as if he doesn't actually care about them. It reads fake.

His Game vote is just way too passive from him for my liking, and from town!Comm I would expect more from that.

245 I feel like Comm is holding himself back here, and that doesn't happen you roll town. Same complaint about 251 and 252. I explain more about it in 259

249 just straight up, does not add anything to the game.

-Ali

Now let me put on a slow song to start (so I don't go too fast for Ali).



- OH NO, Comm is joking about a vig killing him and telling vig half jokingly/half seriously to fucking shoot tonight because there's SIX scum in this game.
- It's almost like Comm isn't always aggressive and that he might have some idea of how he acts in different situations to get the reactions he's looking for to sort people with.
- I wasn't aware I had to be in their face to shamelessly sheep A50 onto someone who seems to not like a single vote on him, so we made it three votes.
- A50 asked me a question, I answered with my current reads. Did you prefer I ignore questions? I mean I can, I can say "Hey Ali, your questions are shit, I'm going to ignore them instead of giving answers when I can/remember to/care to."

[Balki B]

For chapter 6 of my forthcoming mafia textbook:

"What we see above is an excellent example of Scum CommKnight not acting with the indignation of the wrongly accused. In 263 he laughs it off. Then "seriously though," he asserts something about his meta. Then in 264 he acts arrogant while suggesting that he's just unreadable cause he's just so good. Then at 267 he starts super sarcastic.

No indignation.

Laugh it off. "Seriously though." Arrogance. Sarcasm.

The dance of the scumlord."

[Balki B]

[Siblings Pet Doggo]

A. Quite frankly, a vig doesn't

need

your permission to shoot whenever. It just shoots. It adds nothing. The joke feels out of place, so it's fake.
B. Okay, what have those reactions told you? Because I'm not seeing this, and I'm not seeing you do anything with them. And I get you're trying to be sassy here, but it reads fake.
C. I'm not saying you need to be in their face, I'm saying there would be more, and it would read more genuine if you were town. It doesn't, and it looks like you're holding back. The defensiveness reads fake here.
D. Comm getting defensive here doesn't happen by town. Town doesn't say "Well, you would rather I just not talk about my reads or ignore questions" the way he does here. And they certainly don't say "Hey Ali, your questions are shit, I'm going to ignore them instead of giving answers when I can/remember to/care to." It comes from scum with the mentality of "Hey, I am going to try to make you feel bad for hunting me, and disrupt you in your attempts to scumhunt."

-Ali

[Kawso]

In my opinion I'm ruling the siblings & Balki out as scumpartners, the intereaction seems genuine, although a tad sheepish on Balki's end.
I feel Comm's taking a little bit of style over substance, answering everything with a sarcastic tone, though it's not unreasonable for town to get bitter at being hard pushed.

[Balki B]

You'd think me messing up and implying that someone might be scum during the day might be because I don't have a scumchat?

UNVOTE:

This is not what you're accused of. You are accused of trying to identify a PR. Some people think this makes you scum because scum are big jerks who are tyring to kill our PRs, and town would be quiet about our deepest secrets like who our PRs are.

So please explain, in as much detail as you can, why you made comments about who might be a PR for all to see.

[Balki B]

@Kawso, still there? Will you ever explain this?

[Kawso]

The PR comment was admittedly a result of me rushing to get a post in & provide worthwhile content. I said it, as I wasn't sure of your alignment, and thus wanted people to stop fully scumreading you. Looking back, I'd have worded it differently as to not imply you may be a PR.


I'm pretty new, but would i be so obvious as to mark myself like that as scum?