Newbie 1806 - The Ffery Garden: GAME OVER!

[fferyllt]

Vote Count 2.3

Actually I do know where I'd like to plant a moon garden It requires changing some partially implemented plans. I'll probably do it.

WhyMafia

(2): RadiantCowbells, WhemeStar

Not Voting

(5): King Cankles, Miles Edgeworth, PersephoneSidekick, WhyMafia, WhaleBarnicle

Deadline: July 23 Midnight US Eastern Time.

Countdown: (expired on 2017-07-22 21:00:00)

Mod Notes:

-

[WhemeStar]

One of these days I will get page top

[WhemeStar]

Hey guys can we start posting I don't like dead games

[WhyMafia]

VOTE: wheme

[WhemeStar]

Lol ok

[WhemeStar]

That's a bad vote btw

[WhemeStar]

Sure let's do it

VOTE: Wheme

[WhaleBarnicle]

Alright, I wanted to wait a little bit before I posted to see if he would produce anything substantial, and he didn't. So....


VOTE: WhyMafia. L-1 and anyone with a quick hammer declares a scum spot with this much time left. Here's the way I see it:

Barnicle:Town
RC: May as well be confirmed town now with no CC
Peri: Also towny (watch they end up being scum )
Cankles: Still just no content...makes me very sad.
WhyMaf: Been wary of them for a while now, and I think that the vote on Wheme was pretty weak
Wheme: ?? Maybe scum who knows.
Miles: Towny in effort, and like I said earlier I don't think that PestoSwami was ever that bad of a slot. He's the only person who ever thought it was strange how much I tunneled on Cankles day one. Admittedly it was a wrong lead anyway, but a healthy does of skepticism is good.

Anyway, I thought it over and I think it would be stupid for mafia to hammer right now. If we truly do have a one shot BP then we can survive an extra day night cycle before it's game over if we mess up, and I think that will give town a bit of an edge. And I wouldn't mind seeing WhyMaf get some extra heat on him. If we lynch and he's scum...well that's all the better really.

[WhaleBarnicle]

But seriously guys we need to be more active because if there's one thing that Miles said that I really agree with is that scum will only ever hide unless provoked to do otherwise. We need to be more active in this scum hunting. I know I'm at fault because work is crazy and I can't post as much as I would like. That being said we need to move this game along somewhat with MHS gone (he was really the only one who pushed on D1), and I'm going to try and post at least once or twice a day.

[fferyllt]

King Cankles has been prodded.

[RadiantCowbells]

Hi!

I'm sorry that I shut down conversation. It wasn't my intention and I got really frustrated that I was getting wagoned when I thought that I was obvtown.

Can I get a readslist with reasons from eveyrone?

[Miles Edgeworth]

Shameless prod dodge goes here

[WhyMafia]

Hi!

I'm sorry that I shut down conversation. It wasn't my intention and I got really frustrated that I was getting wagoned when I thought that I was obvtown.

Can I get a readslist with reasons from eveyrone?

When I flip town power lynch wheme like you did to me

[WhyMafia]

This was absolutely disgusting

[WhyMafia]

And then I am undecided
But it's either whale or miles

[WhyMafia]

The main thing I'm hesitant with whale is that he refused to give a read on wheme

Sure let's do it

VOTE: Wheme

And wtf is this self-vote
Let's go through this person's ISO
Oh wait ....
He has no content! Nothing screams town in Ciara's ISO either
And overall, this slot has been very awkward (the RVS, sheep RC, and his one opinion with RC "scumreading mh" was complete bs

[WhemeStar]

Oh no! No content! Must be scum!

[WhemeStar]

Hi!

I'm sorry that I shut down conversation. It wasn't my intention and I got really frustrated that I was getting wagoned when I thought that I was obvtown.

Can I get a readslist with reasons from eveyrone?

I don't know if I can make a reads list

[WhaleBarnicle]

How can you not make a reads list this late in the game? Are you just trolling WhyMafia?

[PersephoneSidekick]

I kind of have no idea what's going on anymore but whatever here's my reads list.

RC: Confirmed town. Moving on.

Whale: Was towny yesterday; keeping up the same attitudes and activities now. Almost too towny really :p

Cankles: No data since yesterday, default to my previous townread. Reactions to wagon yesterday were town despair not scum despair.

Miles: I don't know if he has a scummy tone or a towny tone, but he sure has a Tone. I wish this wasn't his first game so I could know if he always talks like this. Analysis looks good but he kind of looks like he's showing off? Works out to slightly scummy I think. Really wish I had meta.

WM: RC's opinion counts for something. Tone looks increasingly bad to me but that's probably me being impressionable so I'll just fold it into RC. Other than that, no evidence really. Scummier than most other people I guess.

Wheme: Flippant votes, opportunism and no content. Not even doing that good a job trying to look busy. Trollish self vote. And like all of Ciara's very few semi-contentful posts were scummy too. Seriously, lynch this slot.

VOTE: WhemeStar That's L-1, at least until he takes off his stupid self-vote.

[PersephoneSidekick]

I'm really not not sure what to make of the banter between Wheme and WM association wise. It's weird for scum versus scum but it's kind of weird for anybody? Okay lets think about all possibilities.

Both scum: WM unconvincingly accuses Wheme thinking that it will appear to clear Wheme after he gets lynched and flips scum. Wheme halfheartedly appears to fight back for appearances. It's plausible at this point that Scum!WM would feel already caught and might be primarily focused on protecting his partner with weird WIFOM shenanigans. With Wheme already under suspicion too, the situation is sort of desperate. I can see it, but it's still weird.

WM scum, Wheme town: WM cornered, and Wheme looks like good divert target because he's playing so unhelpfully. Wheme responses continue previous playstyle. This is plausible but depressing because it means we have even more ineffective townies than we realized. WM's partner would probably be Miles in this scenario, because if you look at ISO he kind of defends WM a lot.

Wheme scum, WM town: WM is real frustration and honest reaction to Wheme's scummy posts. Wheme tries to flippantly shrug off pressure. This feels like the most solid possibility. Partner could still be Miles, but only by POE. I wouldn't want to rule out Cankles for example; he's hardly cleared.

Both town: Real frustration on both sides, but then who the hells is scum? Miles + Cankles?

Conclusion: So a lot of what this is telling me is to take Miles more seriously as a candidate, because there are a lot of scenarios for him. I still think that the priors are highest for Wheme, so I'm keeping my vote there for now.

RC, who do you think WM's partner is?

[RadiantCowbells]

I kind of have no idea what's going on anymore but whatever here's my reads list.

RC: Confirmed town. Moving on.

Whale: Was towny yesterday; keeping up the same attitudes and activities now. Almost too towny really :p

Cankles: No data since yesterday, default to my previous townread. Reactions to wagon yesterday were town despair not scum despair.

Miles: I don't know if he has a scummy tone or a towny tone, but he sure has a Tone. I wish this wasn't his first game so I could know if he always talks like this. Analysis looks good but he kind of looks like he's showing off? Works out to slightly scummy I think. Really wish I had meta.

WM: RC's opinion counts for something. Tone looks increasingly bad to me but that's probably me being impressionable so I'll just fold it into RC. Other than that, no evidence really. Scummier than most other people I guess.

Wheme: Flippant votes, opportunism and no content. Not even doing that good a job trying to look busy. Trollish self vote. And like all of Ciara's very few semi-contentful posts were scummy too. Seriously, lynch this slot.

VOTE: WhemeStar That's L-1, at least until he takes off his stupid self-vote.

this vote makes me feel like Whymafia/Persephone might be a thing

[WhemeStar]

I kind of have no idea what's going on anymore but whatever here's my reads list.

RC: Confirmed town. Moving on.

Whale: Was towny yesterday; keeping up the same attitudes and activities now. Almost too towny really :p

Cankles: No data since yesterday, default to my previous townread. Reactions to wagon yesterday were town despair not scum despair.

Miles: I don't know if he has a scummy tone or a towny tone, but he sure has a Tone. I wish this wasn't his first game so I could know if he always talks like this. Analysis looks good but he kind of looks like he's showing off? Works out to slightly scummy I think. Really wish I had meta.

WM: RC's opinion counts for something. Tone looks increasingly bad to me but that's probably me being impressionable so I'll just fold it into RC. Other than that, no evidence really. Scummier than most other people I guess.

Wheme: Flippant votes, opportunism and no content. Not even doing that good a job trying to look busy. Trollish self vote. And like all of Ciara's very few semi-contentful posts were scummy too. Seriously, lynch this slot.

VOTE: WhemeStar That's L-1, at least until he takes off his stupid self-vote.

How am I opportunistic

[WhemeStar]

The only thing I can agree with PS vote on me is the no content thing.

[WhemeStar]

Since when is self voting opportunistic

Is self unvoting opportunistic?
UNVOTE: