Newbie 1806 - The Ffery Garden: GAME OVER!

[WhemeStar]

Like I don't refuse to it but I tend to keep them to myself because I'm bad at explaining

[WhyMafia]

Whymafia, sing me a lullaby

Also:

We are not lynching Whemestar today. Foot down.

[WhemeStar]

Whymafia, sing me a lullaby

Also:

We are not lynching Whemestar today. Foot down.

Your scum

[WhemeStar]

Hmm is Miles scum

[WhyMafia]

I realize that nothing I say will dissuade y'all that I am scum. Well played scum. I just hope town lynches you tomorrow

[WhyMafia]

Hmm is Miles scum

Idk is he?
Why don't you make a case?

[WhemeStar]

Someone said cases are scummy and I agree

[RadiantCowbells]

I realize that nothing I say will dissuade y'all that I am scum. Well played scum. I just hope town lynches you tomorrow

Let's lynch elsewhere!

I don't have to lynch you.

[WhyMafia]

Someone said cases are scummy and I agree

......

[WhyMafia]

I realize that nothing I say will dissuade y'all that I am scum. Well played scum. I just hope town lynches you tomorrow

Let's lynch elsewhere!

I don't have to lynch you.

who then

[UnaBombaH]

What is going on with this game?

Is it scummy to try ask RC put to words what he is doing here?
I said I grew to admire his play by reading games he was in, but I know realize playing with him feels rather terrifying..
Like someone has a gun with one bullet in it, and he is pointing it wildly around..!

What baffles me the most is how hard he pressured WhyMafia, and now seemingly is willing to relieve the pressure?
Also the way he just declares that Wheme isn't lynched today..WHY?

I'm leaning more towards Wheme being obv.scum, but I'm hesitant in putting my vote on him (in case he really is town, and scum quickhammers or RC flips out )
And for the same reasons I am now hesitant to put my vote on my first #1 candidate WhyMafia.
I can't even sheep our one conf.town because he is voting me!

I usually think sitting on your vote and not committing is scummy play, but currently I'm more afraid about the potential abuse that could happen if I vote.

Please, anyone, give me something to do! (bored at work)

[UnaBombaH]

My own thoughts on UnaBombaH is that he's kind of sketch, but not really enough to overcome my townread of Cankles.

I'm actually interested in hearing what makes me look "sketch" in your eyes.
Is it being very vocal and upfront?

[WhemeStar]

What is going on with this game?

Is it scummy to try ask RC put to words what he is doing here?
I said I grew to admire his play by reading games he was in, but I know realize playing with him feels rather terrifying..
Like someone has a gun with one bullet in it, and he is pointing it wildly around..!

What baffles me the most is how hard he pressured WhyMafia, and now seemingly is willing to relieve the pressure?
Also the way he just declares that Wheme isn't lynched today..WHY?

I'm leaning more towards Wheme being obv.scum, but I'm hesitant in putting my vote on him (in case he really is town, and scum quickhammers or RC flips out )
And for the same reasons I am now hesitant to put my vote on my first #1 candidate WhyMafia.
I can't even sheep our one conf.town because he is voting me!

I usually think sitting on your vote and not committing is scummy play, but currently I'm more afraid about the potential abuse that could happen if I vote.

Please, anyone, give me something to do! (bored at work)

RC thinks he knows who scum is but he wants to find scum partner because RC is super duper good so he's trying to act carelessly to make his target feel comfortable

[WhemeStar]

If you vote me RC is gonna flip out so be careful!

[UnaBombaH]

If you vote me RC is gonna flip out so be careful!

Was joke about RC flipping out. I don't actually care too much for that, I'm just worried of the situation I'm in with my unplaced vote.

WhyMafia (2): WhaleBarnicle, WhemeStar
WhemeStar (2): WhyMafia, PersephoneSidekick
UnaBombaH (1): RadiantCowbells
WhaleBarnicle (1): Miles Edgeworth

This is the situation as of now.
What bothers me about my earlier feeling about WhyMafia/Perse, is that they have a counterwagon against you, JUST THE TWO OF THEM.
I'm not sure if scumbuddies would be so obviously teaming.
So I would feel more happy voting you,

simply because I can't see anyone quickhammering you.

BUT. BUT. BUT.
My initial feeling was to vote WhyMafia, but there was a real danger of quickhammering, and I do not want that even if he flips scum.
Like I said earlier, your posts confuse me, and I was worried about giving you a chance to hammer.
Good thing I didn't vote when I was going to, considering he went to L-1 momentarily and YOU asked for a hammer before RC backed off to give more time to us.

Now I feel like I'm in a situation where voting for the wrong wagon might end the day, because I can't trust you OR WhyMafia/Perse.

I'm feeling very neutral about Whale, and strongly townleaning Miles currently.

RC is chaotic-good-town.

[Miles Edgeworth]

VOTE: Unabombah

sorta think Cankles was scum now

This is interesting. Knowing his alignment would be useful for more accurate analysis of the wagons on day 1, since Cankles was on L-1 for three days and lived. It just strikes me as so unlikely that the mafia let things get to that point.

[RadiantCowbells]

I flagrantly disagree with your conjecture that inexperienced scum would have the know-how or the ability to derail the wagon.

[RadiantCowbells]

See right now I think that scum is WhaleBarnicle / Unabombah and rather than attempt to derail, scum sat on the wagon

[Miles Edgeworth]

I flagrantly disagree with your conjecture that inexperienced scum would have the know-how or the ability to derail the wagon.

When you put it that way, I'm a little disappointed I didn't discover the point in the first place.

You have a point. When I get time later on today, I'll dig into the implications of your idea here and see where I stand on it.

[Miles Edgeworth]

When do the mafia first get to talk to one another in a game on here?

[RadiantCowbells]

During pre-game, but given the replacements probably not until night phase.

[Miles Edgeworth]

So in other words, if Cankles were scum with someone who replaced in, those two would have had no prior planning to lean on in order to try to save him from the noose in day 1?

[RadiantCowbells]

yes.

plus most scumteams don't use their discussion much

[Miles Edgeworth]

RC. What do you think about a KingCankles/Unabombah + GinsengTea/WhaleBarnicle team? I recognize pre-flips aren't really useful, but I've been suspicious of WB this whole day cycle, and I couldn't help but notice that

WB replaced in for GT during the height of pressure on KC during day 1.

He still has yet to answer my questions about why he didn't push KC harder when he started "losing his lynch"... and of course it stands to reason that scum bussing a teammate would not object to that teammate's wagon losing traction in the later stages of the day.

[Miles Edgeworth]

Lol nvm you already said you liked that team. Dope.

So can we kill WB now?