Mini 1935: Green Haired UPick (Game Over)

[1 Shot Vanilla Town]

And just to be clear, I don't have a town read on WhyMafia. I had one on Tuckers, I just don't have one.

Typo?

[Chickadee]

And just to be clear, I don't have a town read on WhyMafia. I had one on Tuckers, I just don't have one.

Typo?

Seems a few yea.

I'll be back after dinner

[Chickadee]

And just to be clear, I don't have a town read on WhyMafia. I had a scum read on Tuckers, I just don't have one on Why. Absence of a scum read does not equal a town read.

EBWOP

That's what that line should read.

[RadiantCowbells]

Chickadee vote jj or I have no reason not to lynch you

[Chickadee]

Chickadee vote jj or I have no reason not to lynch you

Thats bullying.

I'll look into it though.

[TwoInAMillion]

What's the jj case?

[RadiantCowbells]

Chickadee vote jj or I have no reason not to lynch you

Thats bullying.

I'll look into it though.

Call it bullying. Your current vote is terrible and unless you're going to help me when someone I am more sure is Mafia you can die first

[Chickadee]

Chickadee vote jj or I have no reason not to lynch you

Thats bullying.

I'll look into it though.

Call it bullying. Your current vote is terrible and unless you're going to help me when someone I am more sure is Mafia you can die first

That logic is terrible. You're just threatening my slot if I don't see things your way.

[RadiantCowbells]

I think you're scum and if I can't get the single superior wagon through, I will Lynch you instead. Bam, simple.

[Lucky2u]

I'm ok lynching chikadee

VOTE: chickadee
feel like they are WKing me here and looking for a buddy on rc. expressing suspicion on tucker but then TRing WM is an easy way to look like you have scumreads without making enemies.

partially because I think it would help confirm a RM scum wagon since her strong town read on him I think is a scum mistake and RC claiming its WKing is him telling her to stop it before they both go down.

[Lucky2u]

@1SVT, Why can't we go into day two with two miller claims?

If town ignore it day 1, they will ignore it day 2... Then we get that much closer to a situation of dealing with them late game.
Miller won't be a scum night kill.

The only other options I'll consider is Tarkus shoots the other.
But so many false reasons can be given against that.

I think enough people have said we're going to wait and see that you can stop pushing this now.

[Lucky2u]

sorry for multi posting here but that's my terrible style when catching up.

@RC I don't recall you being this decisive and pushy when I left the site. do you plan on letting chikadee off the hook if she actually gave into your demands?

[RadiantCowbells]

@RC I don't recall you being this decisive and pushy when I left the site. do you plan on letting chikadee off the hook if she actually gave into your demands?

o.O

[Chickadee]

@RC I don't recall you being this decisive and pushy when I left the site. do you plan on letting chikadee off the hook if she actually gave into your demands?

o.O

That's not really an answer. And it was a pretty simple question.

I'm ok with Why not being the lynch today. However, I do not negotiate with terrorists. I'll vote of my own accord RC.

UNVOTE:

Honestly, I see no town value in players who give in the demands like yours RC.

[RadiantCowbells]

this is it boys this means war

[Lucky2u]

@RC I don't recall you being this decisive and pushy when I left the site. do you plan on letting chikadee off the hook if she actually gave into your demands?

o.O

I actually wanted an answer but now I think since chikadee's post it won't matter.

[Chickadee]

this is it boys this means war

[RadiantCowbells]

@RC I don't recall you being this decisive and pushy when I left the site. do you plan on letting chikadee off the hook if she actually gave into your demands?

o.O

I actually wanted an answer but now I think since chikadee's post it won't matter.

Yes because I wanted someone lynched more than I wanted her lynched.

[RadiantCowbells]

So the question you're really asking: why am I so insistent that the wagons should be changed?

[RadiantCowbells]

WhyMafia (2): beeboy, Chickadee
randomidget (3): Lucky2u, esires, iDanyBoy
Tarkus (2): TwoInAMillion, 1 Shot Vanilla Town

Our 3 wagons, ladies and gentlemen.

Tarkus

: miller claim, for the record, but also the one that claimed miller vigilante. Which includes vigilante.
So unless you think it's scum vig, which I don't, it's not our fucking problem. We leash them, and lynch them if there's not a nightkill.
I agree that there's -issues- with the miller claims but we don't lynch this d1 ever.

Randomidget

: So I do have one major problem with them and that's this set of posts here

VOTE: 1svt
this does not feel like town 1svt. if it was i would be more willing to follow their push.

RC im not sure but were you in Cult of Kira Mafia run by SnarkySnowman?

thats what im comparing 1svt's play to here.

Yes: I had the exact same first impetus from 1SVT. But I find it hard as fuck to believe that Randomidget forgot I was in cult of kira.
Cult of kira was literally me as confirmed town playing dictator and leading on scum (mostly the wrong scum tho) till we won.
1svt basically did fuck all that game and the idea that Randomidget forgot about my involvement
Scum!Randomidget will not have shit reads. This is a decent read but it's also something that I can see randomidget pushing and there's a sketchy as fuck aspect.

So if we're lynching in the major scumreads, this is the one we hit up.

Now Whymafia? That's a fucking trainwreck of a lynch waiting to happen.

Tucker was never, like, -scummy-. I said and I stand by they were either scum or reaction testing. Their reaction was to indicate that it was a reaction test.
So sure, whatever, but unless you're reading into something less shallow than 'durr gutread that they were playing things up' which was obvious: no.

Whymafia has been pretty towny since replace in. we're not lynching them.

1SVT

is lame. I expect better from them but I have an alt guess finally for them and I don't think it's unreasonable that they're low activity.
Nothing that they've done is especially like egregiously scum indicative.
Absolutely we should force more content from them but we're not fucking d1 lynching them.

Chickadee

is like bad. Not scummy bad. I take back my interest in lynching them but their whymafia vote is terrible.

As for the god wagon on

Cookieguys

?

Okay, but I am aware that your angle is to insult people who vote you

-jj

THE FUCK KIND OF REACTION IS THAT
I DIDN'T EVEN INSULT THEM. I CALLED THEM SCUM AND THEIR REACTION IS TO DISCREDIT IT BY ACCUSING ME OF INSULTING PEOPLE WHO VOTE ME.
ALL MY WHAT.

Oh okay, that works for me as well.

So, from your perspective, is 2 millers a physical impossibility here?

-jj

Really don't like them putting the prerogative on me to make this call. It feels like they're trying to stay clean of the whole situation. Just like before.

As someone who once replaced into an unclaimed miller slot in a game with 2 millers, I'm gonna suggest we let them place each other while we get on with the rest of the standard day 1 antics, then revisit them later when they have more developed opinions on each other.

No desire to put their hat into the ring and make any sort of commitment on their thoughts on the miller read, just staying clear of the situation as best they can.
Exactly what I would expect scum to do if neither miller is scum. Let townies get their hands dirty pushing the mislynches onto the double miller claim.

Fuck, actual bona-fide confirmation bias there probably means you're town. Like, that "line of reasoning" can only exist because you're so certain no logical person could disagree with you.

UNVOTE:

-jj

This is -such- a 'make a show of how much I'm thinking!' post. No one fucking talks like that. That's scum trying to be 'towny' by showing their thought process.

JJ has dragged me back into this - for some reason the forum wasn't loading properly. From what I can see it's all a bit messy - so fairly usual day 1 nonsense.

- C.j

0 contribution from the other hydra head at all. none. and like, aggressively not contributing while trying to make a comment that actually says nothing about the game.
It's really bad.



I want Cookiedotjay's head on a pike. I will compromise on Randomidget. I will not accept any other lynches today.

[RadiantCowbells]

Oh, and scum?

We are going to leash Tarkus and if they are proved to have a shot we are -never- going to lynch them until you're all dead.
Don't keep them around thinking that you can get us to mislynch them. we are never lynching them.
If you have some reason to believe that they're serial killer, that's on you because we're not lynching them.

[RadiantCowbells]

Tarkus: I am leashing your shot. Do you have any objections to this?

[RadiantCowbells]

VOTE: Cookiedotjay for now.

If I can't make this happen, I'll switch over to Randomidget.

All other wagons are terrible.

[WhyMafia]

VOTE: Random
I'll compromise here

[Randomnamechange]

VOTE: CookieDotJay
FINE