Mini 1935: Green Haired UPick (Game Over)

[TwoInAMillion]

You haven't scum hunted though. So you are scum too?

I am scum hunting with my vote.

[iDanyboy]

You haven't scum hunted though. So you are scum too?

I am scum hunting with my vote.

Cookie voted too.

[CookieDotJay]

Scumhunting with your vote is where you pressure people to add to a conversation

VOTE: TwoInAMillion


Why do you still think Tarkus is scum after he claimed vig? Is it entirely because you don't believe there are 2 millers?

[TwoInAMillion]

Yeah, voted on a town read of mine.

[TwoInAMillion]

Scumhunting with your vote is where you pressure people to add to a conversation

VOTE: TwoInAMillion


Why do you still think Tarkus is scum after he claimed vig? Is it entirely because you don't believe there are 2 millers?

That and his OMGUS reaction. Combined with your OMGUS reaction you and Tarkus make sense being on the same scum team.

[CookieDotJay]

Oh okay so you're allowed to call him scum because THERE CAN ONLY BE ONE but if you consider the perspective of town!Tarkus isn't omgusing exactly what you would do

[iDanyboy]

Yeah, voted on a town read of mine.

You're saying cookie voted your town read RC?

[TwoInAMillion]

No, because he should know that a second miller claim is likely town.

[TwoInAMillion]

Yeah, voted on a town read of mine.

You're saying cookie voted your town read RC?

Yes.

[CookieDotJay]

No, because he should know that a second miller claim is likely town.

Can you cut the shit or do you refuse to cut it because it speaks the truth when it says you're bad at scumhunting?

I'm trying to evaluate your perspective here

[Randomnamechange]

twoinamillion's recent posts have been scummy as shit

[iDanyboy]

Yeah, voted on a town read of mine.

You're saying cookie voted your town read RC?

Yes.

But I asked you in Post 204 if you had any other opinions on the game and in Post 206 you said you needed a few days to get some more reads. I asked you if you had found anything AI in Post 216 and you ignored it. Your town read of TIAM and your scum read of Cookie based on his vote happened before I asked you if you have any reads and you never mentioned it then either. Your reasoning for voting Cookie has changed from 'his not scum hunting' to 'he voted my town read'. I don't see how you can't be town now.

[iDanyboy]

Yeah, voted on a town read of mine.

You're saying cookie voted your town read RC?

Yes.

But I asked you in Post 204 if you had any other opinions on the game and in Post 206 you said you needed a few days to get some more reads. I asked you if you had found anything AI in Post 216 and you ignored it. Your town read of RC's and your scum read of Cookie based on his vote happened before I asked you if you have any reads and you never mentioned it then either. Your reasoning for voting Cookie has changed from 'his not scum hunting' to 'he voted my town read'. I don't see how you can't be town now.

EBWOP

[CookieDotJay]

I mean yeah, I might actually keep my vote there

PEdit: You might need to EBWOP your EBWOP

[TwoInAMillion]

My reasoning didn't change, it's possible to have two reasons.

[CookieDotJay]

If those two reasons are good enough for you, then why did you need RC to case me and why isn't his case any of the reasons

[iDanyboy]

But your second reason doesn't fit with what you've posted and you are guilty of your first reason.

[TwoInAMillion]

If those two reasons are good enough for you, then why did you need RC to case me and why isn't his case any of the reasons

There's nothing wrong with agreeing with someone else's case. You are throwing crap against the wall and seeing if anything sticks.

[CookieDotJay]

You're making it all stick

[TwoInAMillion]

But your second reason doesn't fit with what you've posted and you are guilty of your first reason.

Usually if there are two miller claims the second one is the correct one. Scum won't fake miller claim if they know there's a real miller in the game.

[TwoInAMillion]

You're making it all stick

Not quite.

[CookieDotJay]

What the fuck are you basing that on

[Tarkus]

Alrighty

I support a lot of RC’s longpost. This terrifies me but I’ll roll with it. I’m having a hard time reading Random but those posts do seem off given what RC said about the kira game.

I like the cookie case as it lines up with my view of how at least one scum would want to play this day out. He wanted to wait and see, with good reason, but then let up as the push on me got hotter and the discussion stretched on. This this this: “Exactly what I would expect scum to do if neither miller is scum. Let townies get their hands dirty pushing the mislynches onto the double miller claim.”

I have no problem being leashed.

I don’t think I should shoot TIAM. In a vacuum I understand wanting a miller dead asap, but I reckon he’s town here. 1SVT’s push on me was ok but this is bad. If we’re doing a policy shot it oughta be beeboy imo.

309 I can see this reasoning, something to think about. Kinda just putting this in so I can remember to come back to it.

PEDIT: this post was written before TIAM's vote, walked away from it and now stuff's happening. Gonna jump in here now. Look I got the logic that a 2nd miller is likely town, just took me stepping back and thinking it through more. Gut reaction was "wtf is this CC? prob scum trying to lynch me!". I feel like that's pretty reasonable and acting like I should've immediately thought you were town is bullshit

[TwoInAMillion]

What the fuck are you basing that on

Experience.

[CookieDotJay]

Let me get this straight- you think that if there are 2 miller claims, the second claim is usually true, and if the first claim is true then the second claim is still probably true?