Mini 1935: Green Haired UPick (Game Over)

[Tarkus]

Yeah, where's the issue? I got pretty convinced in the lack of scum motivation for a miller CC

[CookieDotJay]

Was talking to TIAM about his plausibly self-consistent train of thought here, and I'll go somewhere with it when he answers.

[TwoInAMillion]

Let me get this straight- you think that if there are 2 miller claims, the second claim is usually true, and if the first claim is true then the second claim is still probably true?

I never said anything about the first claim being true, you are fabricating my statement. If, assuming the millers are one town and one scum, and you lynch both, the scum player has much more to lose because there are always fewer scum players than town players. If the scum player was the second player, the optimal move would be not to counterclaim, and you would stand a better chance at long term survival.

[CookieDotJay]

No, because he should know that a second miller claim is likely town.

This was from when I asked you to consider Tarkus' perspective

[TwoInAMillion]

No, because he should know that a second miller claim is likely town.

This was from when I asked you to consider Tarkus' perspective

The scum perspective?

[iDanyboy]

But your second reason doesn't fit with what you've posted and you are guilty of your first reason.

Usually if there are two miller claims the second one is the correct one. Scum won't fake miller claim if they know there's a real miller in the game.

Please respond to Post 361/362.

[CookieDotJay]

Accusing me of fabricating your statements when you literally said that if Tarkus was town he shouldn't have assumed you were scum is interesting though.

For the record I remember things and don't just take account of one post in these 1V1s so try to do the same.




ALSO when you claimed you said you didn't realise Tarkus claimed miller which makes your whole point bullshit anyways

[TwoInAMillion]

See 364.

[TwoInAMillion]

Accusing me of fabricating your statements when you literally said that if Tarkus was town he shouldn't have assumed you were scum is interesting though.

For the record I remember things and don't just take account of one post in these 1V1s so try to do the same.




ALSO when you claimed you said you didn't realise Tarkus claimed miller which makes your whole point bullshit anyways

Not at all. I based my Tarkus read on after I found out he claimed miller. Your BSing is getting really old.

[iDanyboy]

See 364.

When I asked you if you had any reads you said no.
Why do you know say you town read RC and scum read Cookie but you didn't say that when I asked you?

[TwoInAMillion]

See 364.

When I asked you if you had any reads you said no.
Why do you know say you town read RC and scum read Cookie but you didn't say that when I asked you?

It was a day or two later.

[iDanyboy]

Cookie voted RC before I asked you that question, therefore you must of scum read Cookie and town read RC back then. So that wasn't a day or two later

[CookieDotJay]

Wow, do I need to rail out the logic train for you? Let's have some facts.



When asked to consider whether town!Tarkus' perspective, you said that he should think you're town based on the miller claims, while claiming you are justified in scumreading him, both because you claimed second.

You place more value in the second miller claim because you do not think scum would make a miller claim if they knew there was a miller in the game already.

You did not know there was already a miller claim when you claimed miller.


See if you can make a deduction

[TwoInAMillion]

Talking to you is like talking to a brick wall.

[iDanyboy]

Talking to you is like talking to a brick wall.

[iDanyboy]

VOTE: TIAM

[CookieDotJay]

Fake frustration is one way to end a 1V1 I guess

[RadiantCowbells]

Don't hammer or l-1

anyone

until I get back

Jjh can one of you be on in four hours thirty minutes

[CookieDotJay]

Probably not. We're both in the UK and Cookie is already asleep. You're asking me to be on at 5am which only really happens by accident

[RadiantCowbells]

In like 17 hours?

[CookieDotJay]

Yes definitely, probably both of us

[RadiantCowbells]

Thoughts on randomidget? Scumreads? But I'll be on tmrw.

[CookieDotJay]

I like Random but then I think I usually like Random. TIAM is scum, Esires could be scum, not sure about anyone else

[WhyMafia]

VOTE: 2IAM

[Tarkus]

Well I feel pretty dumb now lol. 387 is a good post and the basis for my TR on the claim is gone
VOTE: TIAM