Mini Normal 1983: Winter Wonderland [Endgame!]

[sheepsaysmeep]

people obviously seemed to be annoyed by you bc this feels very you + me vs everyone else and sheep kind of unsure

yay im special
tbh it's more of you two powering and everyone else lurking
i mean i feel like this means smth that i dont want to be thinking about 20 minutes before an exam

[Flubbernugget]

Consistency is not inherently townie, but trying to say is scum is flat out wrong. It speaks nothing of motivations.

Also saying it makes more sense to put town in a POE list than a null is probably the strangest thing I've heard, like, ever.

[Katyusha]

How would monkey know which of the contentless slots to put in? They're basically all identical

at least with sheep he has previous suspicion that makes sense in that team dynamic.

[Navigator]

wait i saw the word hydra
can someone hydra with me after this game

hell yeah. on two different sites!

name ideas
SheepSays "do you know de way"
DeWayOfSheep
waysaysmeep

[Flubbernugget]

How would monkey know which of the contentless slots to put in? They're basically all identical

at least with sheep he has previous suspicion that makes sense in that team dynamic.

Well you then have to argue why putting someone at the top of his reads list that he was suspicious of makes sense.

Ans typically people will say something along the lines of "and one of the lurkers".

Like, if lurkers never made it into scum lists, the optimal strategy for scum would have to be staying as inactive as possible.

[Katyusha]

I mean I concede that that's what most people (including myself) would do, but the point is I see where monkey is coming from and it makes sense. It might not be intuitive for everyone but saying it's a scummy trajectory and that it doesn't make sense is wrong when you take into account that he's had doubts about Sheep's alignment.

That does remind me that if Serg is going to keep doing nothing game advancing I wouldn't mind offing his slot at this point.

[sheepsaysmeep]

ive outposted everyone D:

[sheepsaysmeep]

can we talk about serg wanting to massclaim

[Katyusha]

ive outposted everyone D:

I'm only 3 posts behind you.

I do want to take a break though bc mozamis needs to post imo

can we talk about serg wanting to massclaim

probably a dumb joke and im not going to act like it's ai

[sheepsaysmeep]

like it's pmuch dependent on why he wanted to massclaim

@SERG WHY YOU WANT MASSCLAIM

pedit he asked "why not"
it's likely serious tbh

[sheepsaysmeep]

i feel all over the place
like i want to fix it
i dont have the actual motivation to

[Sergtacos]

like it's pmuch dependent on why he wanted to massclaim

@SERG WHY YOU WANT MASSCLAIM

pedit he asked "why not"
it's likely serious tbh

Who wouldn't want a massclaim?

[Katyusha]

a lot of people

... you have over a 1000 posts on mafia games, surely you know by now outting PRs day 1 means that scum can figure out who to kill?

this is a normal game so set ups are designed to be hurt by massclaims more than helped.

[Flubbernugget]

I mean I concede that that's what most people (including myself) would do, but the point is I see where monkey is coming from and it makes sense. It might not be intuitive for everyone but saying it's a scummy trajectory and that it doesn't make sense is wrong when you take into account that he's had doubts about Sheep's alignment.

That does remind me that if Serg is going to keep doing nothing game advancing I wouldn't mind offing his slot at this point.

How does 605 account for having a suspicious player at the top of your reads list

[Flubbernugget]

Lol at the quote

[Sephiroth]

I don't know if this is scum serg or town serg tbh

[Sephiroth]

serg is as serg does

[Sergtacos]

are people seriously taking my quotes seriously omg yall need to tone down a bit man. like its common sense that we shouldnt have a mass claim on d1, i just wanted to see some answers to my post lol jesus

[Sephiroth]

top is scummiest. Bottom tier I don't really want to lynch today. Could be persuaded otherwise. Middle tier I don't have a particularly strong read on.

Bu
Sheep

Mozamis
Serg
Schism
DYKDW

HEM
Inter
Hopkirk
n_m
Flubber
Kat

The Bu wagon stalled kind of awkwardly and that intrigues me.

unvote, vote: Bu

[Sephiroth]

People are ordered within their tiers, though.

[Katyusha]

Not_Mafia
sheepsaysmeep
Internecine
Katyusha
Sephiroth
mozamis

DeWay
Schism

Sergtacos

BuJ
Flubbernugget
Hopkirk

i just sort of assumed this was an unordered list since i'm not at the top but

sure, the list isn't putting that suspicion into account. does it need to?

HEM said that he feels sheep is mostly town and only didn't like some parts of his gameplay. I don't think you can act like this is a smoking gun though if he has reason to not act on the parts he disliked and thus townreads sheep, and if the read was taking associatives into consideration.

Both of which are the case here.

If you want to talk about scummy trajectory let's talk about Bu.

are people seriously taking my quotes seriously omg yall need to tone down a bit man. like its common sense that we shouldnt have a mass claim on d1, i just wanted to see some answers to my post lol jesus

called it lmao

[Katyusha]

Serg, what did you get out of your massclaim call in terms of reads?

[Flubbernugget]

All HEM had to do was say his list was unordered. . He didn't. He backpedaled instead.

[Katyusha]

It isn't backpedaling if he already stated reason to scumread sheep, which is the point.

[Sephiroth]

Flub stop tunneling for now and vote bu. Its the cool new hip thing to do.