Mini Normal 1982: anagrams (endgame) (egad, men!)

[Chumba]

@MOD Can we get an update on Randomidget?

He has like 2 hours to post or he’ll be replaced per mods previous post.

[eth0s]

@MOD Can we get an update on Randomidget?

He has like 2 hours to post or he’ll be replaced per mods previous post.

Ah I missed that earlier. My apologies schadd

[UnaBombaH]

VOTE: sergtacos
only voting to put some pressure

....you should be above saying this.

[UnaBombaH]

The funny thing is, sergtacos might not be a bad lynch today.

I also think Kop made the first legit "case" on why Red could be todays lynch.
I normally dislike lynching lurkers and/or lynchbaity slots, but after creature flipped red, I'm willing to reeavaluate.

[profii]

VOTE: sergtacos
only voting to put some pressure

....you should be above saying this.

What’s the issue?

[Tchill13]

"only voting to put some pressure" means he's saying its not a real vote. once again dunk says one thing but doesn't fully commit to it.

[Tchill13]

Lol fine

There was a suggestion on day 1 that Taco has a scummy playstyle,

Firstly, do you agree?
Secondly, can you share what he did to cause your vote and explain why?

Last one- I’ll assume you are not on board with my theory if you are voting but do you acknowledge it as a possible option or do you say 0% chance

i agree. he's just sitting back not doing anything which is probably what scum would do but i voted him instead of... lets say havo because havo actually did something day 1 where tacos didnt. your theory is possible. its also possible your getting ahead of yourself and nero died simply because he was pushing tacos.

[Sergtacos]

sorry, been sick, will try to catch up tomorrow, saturday and sunday.

[profii]

Lol fine

There was a suggestion on day 1 that Taco has a scummy playstyle,

Firstly, do you agree?
Secondly, can you share what he did to cause your vote and explain why?

Last one- I’ll assume you are not on board with my theory if you are voting but do you acknowledge it as a possible option or do you say 0% chance

i agree. he's just sitting back not doing anything which is probably what scum would do but i voted him instead of... lets say havo because havo actually did something day 1 where tacos didnt. your theory is possible. its also possible your getting ahead of yourself and nero died simply because he was pushing tacos.

I acknowledge my theory is essentially a coin toss and I could be wrong, scum can only be pro or anti town (just played a game with a serial killer hence that phrase) but given this game is progressing fairly slowly, It’s a fair bet to me

[Dunkerdoodles]

"only voting to put some pressure" means he's saying its not a real vote. once again dunk says one thing but doesn't fully commit to it.

I wasn’t voting tacos cause I scumreas him but just to put some pressure to make him post.
I’ll go back now that he’s posted and hopefully he posts more
VOTE: fykus

[Tchill13]

Good lord...

[Lycanfire]

that being said, you guys are probably right in saying i should try and evulate the game without considering boon so i'm going to try and not use his read anymore.
im going to be a bit mad postgame if boon was bang on though

so you were serious about leaning on boon's read?

so do you have like a meta read on him?
ive never played with him before so.

to me he sounds genuine, but idk

VOTE: Fykus

i'm actually going to vote here for now.
i don't think anyone particularly townreads fykus and i'd like to hear a response to my post

zzzz his post was scummy as shit and still managed to do more to progress the game than this one

VOTE: sergtacos
only voting to put some pressure

say anything else with this post and it's a good vote

now i see why you needed boon's reads so badly use ability: act naturally roll: 1.

also, profii, when tchill ignored my question it was cute. when you did it it was a dodge. is havo still getting that pass?

[schadd_]

Vote count 2.2

profii (3):

Havo, Chumba, eth0s

Chumba (1):

Sergtacos

Dunkerdoodles (1):

Lycanfire

UnaBombaH (1):

profii

Sergtacos (1):

Tchill13

Fykus (1):

Dunkerdoodles

not voting (3):

randomidget, UnaBombaH, fykus

with 11 alive, it takes 6 to lynch. day 2 ends january 22 at 17:30 central US time; in (expired on 2018-01-22 17:30:00)

mod notes

getting replacement for randomidget now

[/area]

[profii]

Do you mean your havo question in 308? The answer is in my post 311 but admittedly it was long winded

Succinct version:

I think what he did on D1 was a scum move that can be talked out of by just saying RVS is poop and most people will say yea true. He gave himself a ticket to hammer so if he is scum as soon as a town is L-1 ... bang.

When I said he is getting a pass, I meant I was surprised the group didn’t come down on him hard for doing it. I know he said he would but could have just measured reactions.

The other point I made was this is my 3rd game on my site - because he disregarded etiquette but stated he would - if that’s acceptable to everyone else, I’ll move him down the scum scale but I wasn’t giving him a pass. I was expecting people to grill him a bit more

[Lycanfire]

Okay, but did you think everyone agreeing that he made a shit vote was productive?

[profii]

When was that conversation ?

[Lycanfire]

Supposedly, it's what you wanted to have happen.

[profii]

I’ve no idea. I guess some people will say my theory. Some people will agree Day 1 is poop. Later a scum will hopefully flip and be defending one of those sides and it could be questionable which I think is where I liked Unas idea of going back to earlier days after we’ve had this discussion... right now, not as useful. But let’s say we got people saying that AND if they thought Taco was town framed or not. Then it really adds up after flips

[Tchill13]

Lycan do you think scum are sitting back and letting town lead town to a mislynch?

[profii]

I just went to look at boon, but more the votes than the reads.

Summary of events:
-Vote count= Morality 4/7 ( Una, tchill, me, lyc)
-Morality self votes (5/7)
-tchill goes to Nero Cain 4/7 after making about 8 posts, he doesn’t even acknowledge the self vote until Morality reveals he is boon.
-Chumba votes Morality (5/7) no reason
-Morality OMGUS votes Chumba (4/7)
-tchill back on Morality and finally asks about the self vote (5/7)
-Morality self votes 6/7
-Havo Hammers


For me 3.5 things happened

1. I put the original voters into shit day 1 reads or RVS. They were pre-self vote so I’m less concerned with them. By all means call me scum for justifying me being there... idc
1.5 - Chumba gets in on the Morality action after the self vote. For me, I’m only giving it .5 in the things that happened scale because Chumba saw weird stuff relating to a player he already scum read and voted. I’d say totally natural reaction here.
2.5 - tchill Ignore’s the self vote for a while, didn’t really get into the subject even when boon revealed his alt, gets off the wagon and then gets back on without really giving a reason
3.5 - havo hammers a whole 2 mins later


1. = NAI to all for me
1.5 = town points to Chumba
2.5 = scum points to tchill
3.5 = scum points to havo, but less so than tchill I suppose


VOTE: tchill13

[profii]

Just realised I NAI and scum read tchill which looks silly

Obviously his actions moved him up the scale so w/e

[Tchill13]

I mean I only used his self vote as a reason to vote him and end the first day phase. Is that what you want to hear profii?

[profii]

Not my call, that’s on you

[Tchill13]

well there you go. thats why i did it.

[profii]

gets off the wagon and then gets back on without really giving a reason

Well that's the reason I can see, you've just said "thats why I did it" so I'm a bit lost. I don't care if that's all you want to say but doesn't seem helpful to town to leave it at that.