Page 5 of 10
Posted: Mon Apr 25, 2005 1:56 pm
by chaotic_diablo
technically, if mathcam was SK, than there would be one night kill during night one. One because of the doc save, and that leaves at least one of them open. That alone disproves mathcam being an SK.
There's a very good reason not to now that i think about it.
Posted: Mon Apr 25, 2005 2:08 pm
by chaotic_diablo
technically, if mathcam was SK, than there would be one night kill during night one. One because of the doc save, and that leaves at least one of them open. That alone disproves mathcam being an SK.
There's a very good reason not to now that i think about it.
Posted: Tue Apr 26, 2005 11:53 am
by PBuG
Could you at least elaborate on what kind of message it was?
And we don't know about the SK thing yet, we have at least three cops, we may have multiple docs.
Posted: Tue Apr 26, 2005 1:08 pm
by Quagmire
Hey, everybody! I forgot to mention that milkman has asked to be replaced, and I have since found a replacement for him. That's
Save the Dragons
. Welcome him or die!
3 - Save the Dragons [inHimshallibe, PBug, chaotic_diablo]
2 - mathcam [Maximumum, Astronaut]
1 - Astronaut [mathcam]
6 to lynch!
Posted: Tue Apr 26, 2005 1:25 pm
by Save The Dragons
Ouch...3 vote welcome.
I'll be back in a bit to catch up, and it shouldn't be too hard.
Posted: Tue Apr 26, 2005 1:45 pm
by armlx
At least 3 cops? How so? Unless you are counting C_D's hint he recieved.
Posted: Tue Apr 26, 2005 3:09 pm
by Maximumum
I don't think C-D's hint was presented as a cop investigation. He called it a "hint".
StD, are you still following me?
Posted: Tue Apr 26, 2005 4:26 pm
by Save The Dragons
Yeah, I'm a complete stalker. Watch your mail...I'm taking it.
inHimshallibe wrote:I have to say that I want to rely upon mathcam's experience here
PBuG wrote:and I have reasons to trust him.
It's things like these that make me wonder...if Milkman were the one in mathcam's shoes (which at this point, it's hard to say what they are), would the bandwagon have formed?
OMG. Well aparently you all know my role now. Maybe I should read before I offer to replace. Oh well.
Armlx...why did you look at yourself? I don't get it...it seems like a lie to me. There's no point. In one game, I had a sort of investigative role, but it was rendered useless because it was endgame. I used it on myself and the mod didn't even bother to send anything back. I think assuming that a RB blocked him if mathcam didn't is a faulty assumption. I'd recomend not investigating yourself at all cost. Unless you're scum. Then go ahead.
Now I'm torn. Yet still, I think it would help the town more than it would help the mafia if mathcam claimed his avatar.
I don't know if this is the same sentiment others share, but I wouldn't think of lynching you based off of what you claim unless it's really absurd. Telling the truth should be fine.
BTW, I wouldn't ask you to claim without claiming myself (since I am outed as well.) I really think there's at least 50 or 60 avatars Quagmire could have choosen, and they don't necesarrily have to be current.
I am Marcos's avatar, the wizard dude.
I can think of five people that C_D could be; there's probably a few more, so scum won't have trouble claiming anyway.
I have no opinion regarding your coming out with whether or not you blocked armlx. Personally I think you should, but I think it'd hurt the mafia/help the town either way.
Posted: Tue Apr 26, 2005 5:13 pm
by Maximumum
Excellent points, StD.
The one about there being lots of avatars to chose from for a false claim was what I tried to say earlier, but you did it so much more eloquently. There are so many potential avatar's out there that a good guy claiming their avatar would not help mafia significantly and it would go a long way to proving a claim.
For example, a wizard being a vig makes sense. I can see him zapping bad guys with his magic wand.
If there were only 12 famous avatars then I could see where the hestiation comes from, but there are lots out there.
(P.S. please pay any bills you find in my mail)
Posted: Wed Apr 27, 2005 3:03 am
by mathcam
(P.S. please pay any bills you find in my mail)
Heh.
StD wrote:
It's things like these that make me wonder...if Milkman were the one in mathcam's shoes (which at this point, it's hard to say what they are), would the bandwagon have formed?
A fair question, but either of these could have been statements made with some kind of information in the background.
And okay, if it will put the discussion to rest, I'm MGIA's underwear gnomes...I'm sure you can guess how I distract people from doing their jobs.
Cam
Posted: Wed Apr 27, 2005 3:24 am
by Astronaut
The gnome is most likely in this game, and his ability makes at least some kind of sense.
unvote: mathcam
Posted: Wed Apr 27, 2005 4:39 am
by Maximumum
Hehe, underwear gnome.
That's a reasonable claimed avatar for your claimed role. Barring a counterclaim I'm ready to unvote.
Posted: Wed Apr 27, 2005 10:57 am
by PBuG
If it was milkman in mathcam's shoes, I'd still have reasons...
If you wish me to explain, I will, I already accidentally slipped up.
Posted: Wed Apr 27, 2005 2:34 pm
by Maximumum
PBuG wrote:If it was milkman in mathcam's shoes, I'd still have reasons...
If you wish me to explain, I will, I already accidentally slipped up.
A slip up? PBug, you've been voting for milkman/StD this entire day. If you have some info that would indicate we should follow suit, please do explain.
hehe, underwear gnome.
Posted: Wed Apr 27, 2005 4:24 pm
by Save The Dragons
I thought so. If you have reasons to keep your vote on me, I'd personally like to hear them, but I don't know if that's in the best interest of the town, unless you know for a fact that I'm scum (which I'm not
). If you have other information, I'm not sure if that's good to share either right now. Just try not to get yourself killed tonight.
Although it sounds like your reasons are just that we shouldn't kill mathcam. I kinda thought his avatar was a little iffy, but I'm not ready for a vote.
And I compel Inhim and C_D to come and either
1) unvote
2) Explain what it was about milkman's play besides his needing to be replaced that makes them still want to vote me.
Posted: Wed Apr 27, 2005 6:51 pm
by chaotic_diablo
I'm compelled to unvote STD
unvote STD
When you say you know of 5 people which C_D could be, do you mean the avatar I have, or my avatar which other people will have? Or are you mentioning something else?
Posted: Thu Apr 28, 2005 2:40 am
by mathcam
Max wrote:
hehe, underwear gnome.
Yeah, within like 3 hours of receiving my role I had busted out Season 2 and watched the episode again. Sweet.
StD wrote:
I can think of five people that C_D could be; there's probably a few more, so scum won't have trouble claiming anyway.
I was a little confused about this too...can you clarify what you're trying to say?
Cam
Posted: Thu Apr 28, 2005 5:48 am
by inHimshallibe
Unvote
- I thought I had once milkman was replaced (it was he from which I was waiting a response from, anyway), but apparently I didn't.
I'll be back with more in a couple of hours.
Posted: Thu Apr 28, 2005 8:24 am
by inHimshallibe
On Monday, April 25 Leonidas wrote:Had a busy week, sorry.
Will catch up tomorrow and contribute more from then on.
Stall post?
vote: Leonidas
Posted: Thu Apr 28, 2005 11:58 am
by Save The Dragons
The avatar that C_D could have.
Posted: Thu Apr 28, 2005 1:12 pm
by PBuG
Unvote: STD
What I know has nothing to do with milkman/STD. It's others that I know something about.
I'm digging myself a grave, aren't I?
Posted: Thu Apr 28, 2005 1:17 pm
by Leonidas
(Sigh)
Okay, so 5 pages from this thread, and... 32 new ones from another, my grey cells are reaching their maximal capacity - not that that figure was high in the first place.
I'll post something that makes sense and vote within 3 hours. If not, lynch me the hard way.
Posted: Thu Apr 28, 2005 1:26 pm
by Leonidas
vote: armlx
Extremely likely SK, based on his posts:
1) Bets on massive = scum, and tries to pose as a cop with a fishy claim
2) Claims MeMe's avatar -> MeMe is the best SK...
3) Tries to convince the town there is no SK (post 99)
Posted: Thu Apr 28, 2005 3:09 pm
by PBuG
Moderate FoS:
InhimshallIbe[/b]
I find it hard to believe anyone would assume that someone would just start posting stuff even though they might not have read the thread.
Bigger FoS:
Armlx[/b]
Okay, might as well just say it: I'm a cop. Probably Naive, I got both innocent so far on mathcam and armlx. I find it hard to see three cops in on Mafia game unless all but one is screwed up. I'm Gaspode's dog avatar, called wise old dog.
Posted: Thu Apr 28, 2005 5:41 pm
by mathcam
Hm, a bizarre claim, but it does fit with his earlier posts, so I'm inclined to believe him for now. Gaspode's dog doesn't strike me as a particularly notable avatar, though, so a slight FOS there.
While Leo's post makes sense as promised, I'm not that comfortable lynching a claimed cop right now, especially when another cop (who is admittedly possibly naive) has cleared him.
StD, if you've narrowed CD down to 5 choices or so, you probably have a decent feel for whether or not he's scum...thoughts?
Cam