Mafiascum.net

↑ PantherPunt wrote:

↑ PantherPunt wrote:Hey Postie you were just online, but you didn't post in here. What gives?

Rhaegar too.
Wtf am I the only one is excited to play?

Lol, i worked almost all Saturday. I could watch, but couldn't play.

@ranger, hope do your reads work. It's been a while since I've played here and i don't recall seeing that before.

↑ Rhaegar wrote:@ranger, hope do your reads work. It's been a while since I've played here and i don't recall seeing that before.

Yes pls

↑ PantherPunt wrote:I haven't seen reasons yet, just "Panther is scum" so I'm inclined to think all 3 scum are pushing that and others may be falling victim to perceived "thread consensus"

I'm starting to think PantherPunt might be town here just because of how brazenly arrogant and paranoid this kind of thinking is.

Nah, he looks like flailing scum. I'm honestly not feeling a town tone in his posts at all.

PP vs. Timu is town versus town I think. They both appeared genuinely frustrated with each other, however I liked how they were both able to engage and possibly work thing out.

I would be on a trollie lynch if I could vote him.

Nah, PP definitely doesn't seem like town. Trollie, I haven't looked into him, but PP has a scum mindset. You can tell that from his initial posts honestly.

↑ Killthestory wrote:Nah, PP definitely doesn't seem like town. Trollie, I haven't looked into him, but PP has a scum mindset. You can tell that from his initial posts honestly.

Can you point to a post and say how it has a scum mindset?

↑ PantherPunt wrote:So I just skimmed the micro 580 6er. WOW at the 2 town self hammers. Can the other 5 townies in this game please make a promise to me that you won't do that?

Also, RC was terribly scummy in those first few pages but that might just be bias from playing with him as town before.

Has anyone here played with anyone else before? As for me, I've not.

Unrelated content that has nothing to do with this game. Bad tone.

That's not unrelated. Taking about how a previous game of this setup was done seems ok to me.

I'll do another post then

↑ PantherPunt wrote:

↑ This is my username wrote:VOTE: PantherPunt
Mostly RVS, a little bit serious. I'm getting bad vibes from his comments on the lurkers.

^hedgeeeeeeeee. You can't have it both ways.

Tell me more about these bad vibes

Extremely defensive over a mostly RVS vote. It's not a hedge either lol. Bad tone too

You're really stretching here KTS.

↑ Killthestory wrote:

↑ PantherPunt wrote:

↑ This is my username wrote:VOTE: PantherPunt
Mostly RVS, a little bit serious. I'm getting bad vibes from his comments on the lurkers.

^hedgeeeeeeeee. You can't have it both ways.

Tell me more about these bad vibes

Extremely defensive over a mostly RVS vote. It's not a hedge either lol. Bad tone too

Why is his defensiveness scummy? And what do you mean by "bad tone" and why is it scummy?

u ppl are confusing.

I'm taking the first posts I see to prove the point that a lot of his shit is extremely scummy. Do you really want me to make a convincing post?

To answer your question, defensiveness in RVS is scummy as fuck, especially with a tone like that. The tone is that he's desperately struggling for townreads. Strongest word is Desperately.

to be clear. my scum read on PP has nothing to do with the lurker comment (though I do think that comment was just weird) nor does it have to do with his defensiveness

I just read shit ...ok it has to do a bit with defensiveness actually. let me ISO and find the post

↑ TheTrollie wrote:to be clear. my scum read on PP has nothing to do with the lurker comment (though I do think that comment was just weird) nor does it have to do with his defensiveness

I just read shit ...ok it has to do a bit with defensiveness actually. let me ISO and find the post

you havent read shit yet?

↑ Killthestory wrote:I'm taking the first posts I see to prove the point that a lot of his shit is extremely scummy. Do you really want me to make a convincing post?

Yes, because so far I'm not really seeing the obvscumminess you claim is there.

↑ Killthestory wrote:To answer your question, defensiveness in RVS is scummy as fuck,

Okay but why

↑ Killthestory wrote:especially with a tone like that. The tone is that he's desperately struggling for townreads. Strongest word is Desperately.

I'm not sure I understand. Do you not like the fact he's struggling for townreads or is he giving off an air of trying too hard to form townreads and not being able to?

↑ Killthestory wrote:

↑ PantherPunt wrote:

↑ This is my username wrote:VOTE: PantherPunt
Mostly RVS, a little bit serious. I'm getting bad vibes from his comments on the lurkers.

^hedgeeeeeeeee. You can't have it both ways.

Tell me more about these bad vibes

Extremely defensive over a mostly RVS vote. It's not a hedge either lol. Bad tone too

It's not defensive. The hedge was mostly random/little serious- as in leaving room to go either way with it. In retrospect, I'm ok with it. But I pushed on it to help determine TIMUs alignment.
"Bad tone" is a generic way to call someone scummy without an actual reason. If you'd like others to buy into your tone read, can you describe how the tone was bad? How does it differ from what you expect?

↑ Killthestory wrote:I'm taking the first posts I see to prove the point that

a lot of his shit is extremely scummy.

Do you really want me to make a convincing post?

To answer your question, defensiveness in RVS is scummy as fuck, especially with a tone like that. The tone is that he's desperately struggling for townreads. Strongest word is Desperately.

"A lot of shit extremely scummy" is just speaking in superlatives without, again, saying why or how. I wasn't desperately struggling for tow reads. Quite the opposite- I was being adversarial which obviously attracts scumreads--especially when people aren't used to that.
I think you're just saying shit..and hoping/assuming it won't be questioned. But I really think the entirety of what you've said about me lacks truth and merit. It's a bad look imo

↑ PantherPunt wrote:

↑ This is my username wrote:I didn't really believe the case anyways, it was likely a playstyle thing but seemed worth mentioning. It got some conversation going, like I wanted.

I know you didn't try to call either of them as scum, what does that even have to do with this?

How is it a playstyle thing to say "hey, why didn't you check in"

You called it a little bit serious vote, now you're walking that back saying you didn't believe the "case"

Tell me, what was the "case" that you didn't believe?

↑ PantherPunt wrote:

↑ This is my username wrote:It is a playstyle thing because most people would try to create content rather than inviting others to do it for them.
...wait that's what scum would do

hmm

Anyways, the original case was simply that I found it weird that someone would call out others on lurking on Page One because I've never seen anyone do that before at the beginning of the game. Hence, it seemed forced.

I was inviting others to just pop in, not asking for content to be made so I didn't have to. You'll find I won't have a problem posting freely and loosely.

Saying "called out others for lurking" implies that I was calling them scummy. And calling it "forced" implies that I was trying to push some agenda. So that's where my confusion comes from, as I was doing neither of those things.

I find you voting me for it is definitely the objectively "forced" part of the whole thing. And walking it back by saying you didn't believe the "case" (which further solidifies you were scumreading me for it) doesnt feel natural. Like your thought process isn't clear, and in my opinion not natural and believable.

↑ PantherPunt wrote:

↑ TheTrollie wrote:TIMU is being too reckless for scum

PP is calculated but says some off things

You are town-mediating their argument

p-edit: my scumread of PP has nothing to do with the post about lurking

The ole too scummy to be scum argument? That's how you're justifying a townread on TIMU?

I'd love it if you could cite where I'm saying "off" things. Anyone can give a scumread and say "he said scummy things" or "he said off things", it's lazy and scummy and a cop out. Point to something and justify yourself. Otherwise you're just saying words without logic.

I dont like these posts. Flailing and very aggressive D

+ after I realized I'm in the same group as PP and TiMU, it made my reads easy. I have a strong townread on TIMU

p-edit: no, that was me interrupting the sentence "I just read shit and got bad vibes" or something like that

"Lacks truth" Motherfucker how the fuck do I lack truth when I'm calling you out on your shit?

Anyway Postie, RVS is a time of silliness. Getting overtly defensive over a silly vote is extremely scummy for reasons I'm assuming you don't need to know. If you need to know, just ask again.

He's struggling to gain townreads. He wants to be massively townread early, so he started off on a serious note.

PantherPunt stop scumreading everyone who tries to case you

It wasn't flailing. Did I say anything that was nonsensical? That didn't follow a logical train of thought?

And aggression =/= scummy. That's just not true. Wasn't it you, trollie, who said scum would want to blend in and not make waves? Let me go look

You aren't aggressive. You're more just trying to get serious very early on and produce a lot of content. Unfortunately, that hasn't happened.

Also, yes you're flailing. Responding to anyone who makes a case so seriously with a ton of words is flailing.