Formerfish wrote:I get that. And I want him to respond first.
I guess I'm just curious why you single my vote out as something that needs discussing. You didn't say anything when flavor voted for me without any explanation. Or say anything about anyone else's votes.
Did I land on your scumbuddy and you need to figure out how much I know?
No, I already said that Acri is my SK buddy
.
Also, yours was the only one I really wanted to question the most because "He knows why" is really mysterious.
Everyone else's I've seen, are rather self-explanatory (IMO), or don't have a reasoning.
Flavor Leaf wrote:I took the “he knows why” as a subtle nod to them knowing each other, and having some kind of story from a past game. I do that a lot in RVS towards people that I had memorable games/moments with, especially if it’s the first game with said player since.
If that's the case, he just has to literally say that, (obviously I'd ask what the story is), then I'd be happy.
The bold part. What do you mean?
Reply to the bolded part: We have established very well that SK is an impossibility in this game. We're still somewhat in RVS, and as such, you'll still see jokes from me. I'm more prone to take a joke from RVS and run with it the entire game.
If I had said "my mafia buddy is acri" that's a different story.
I (jokingly) said that I'm a third-party role, and that Acri is a third-party role, that somehow both know each other...?
The original joke was because I didn't see the pun on FF's name, and saw that LCPL voted Acri, and decided to start a joke from that.
As for awkwardness, if you're talking about me joking around, that's normal for my town-meta.
I'm slowly trying to shift my meta to be more serious play, (however, it's kinda obvious that's not really the case here)
Posted: Wed Sep 26, 2018 9:56 am
by xx2008
^This post clears up that you do joke around while town, but the rest of it is confusing.
Posted: Wed Sep 26, 2018 9:57 am
by Korina
In post 99, xx2008 wrote:I understand you're joking, but something tells me they're scummy.
Is this your normal playstyle?
Yes, my normal playstyle is to joke around at the start of the game.
[Removed]
Don't talk about ongoing games --P
Posted: Wed Sep 26, 2018 10:12 am
by Plotinus
Posted: Wed Sep 26, 2018 10:17 am
by dojaj
In post 99, xx2008 wrote:I understand you're joking, but something tells me they're scummy.
Is this your normal playstyle?
Were ypuvreally just suspicious of korina or are you distracting everyone else from the possibility of you being scummy
In post 99, xx2008 wrote:I understand you're joking, but something tells me they're scummy.
Is this your normal playstyle?
Were ypuvreally just suspicious of korina or are you distracting everyone else from the possibility of you being scummy
I was suspicious of him, because the tone of his posts didn't seem natural at first.
True hmmmm
Posted: Wed Sep 26, 2018 11:18 am
by LCpl Jones
... I'm not entirely sure what you mean by that but ok, fair enough. Maybe you mean that I'm a bit "verbose" for lack of a better word? That's my normal playstyle, always has been.
Also, I don't like that you immediiately jump from attacking XX on his Korina push then to me then you agree with XX about Korina. That seems a bit inconsistent, kind of like you're flailing around a bit trying to push a few different people and see what happens. But... that's more of a towntell to me imo in this stage since that's the only way to get info this early.
This seems a bit out of the blue. Is there any reason for this or "just" RVS?
It’s not random at all I read all your posts and cake to the conclusion that you’re overly social
So you are saying that your vote is a serious one and your reasoning for your serious vote is that someone is too chatty in the first 4-5 pages? Thats weak sauce bro. Im not even a huge fan of the guy being voted, but for reasoning like that Im going to speak to it.
In post 99, xx2008 wrote:I understand you're joking, but something tells me they're scummy.
Is this your normal playstyle?
Were ypuvreally just suspicious of korina or are you distracting everyone else from the possibility of you being scummy
This also seems like a likely situation.
Why do you say this? What led you to believe that of all things that are possible in this world and in this game specifically that the hair brained, half cocked idea is a likely situation? I would love to see why you are so willing to call xx scum at this point. Care to point towards his posts that helped you for your read?
Posted: Wed Sep 26, 2018 7:29 pm
by Flavor Leaf
Hey, guys. Just got back home. It’s late, and I’ll get to this tomorrow.
This seems a bit out of the blue. Is there any reason for this or "just" RVS?
It’s not random at all I read all your posts and cake to the conclusion that you’re overly social
Care to eli5 (explain like I'm five) your thought process on overly social equaling scum?
I see someone being extremely social and talkative NAI (or Not Alignment Indicative), if not, slightly leaning more towards Town if only on the basis of "Scum don't wanna be seen, so they'd talk less."
In post 99, xx2008 wrote:I understand you're joking, but something tells me they're scummy.
Is this your normal playstyle?
Were ypuvreally just suspicious of korina or are you distracting everyone else from the possibility of you being scummy
Has xx come off as scum to you so far?
Like I said earlier, I find xx to be over all nullish so far.
Then again, I haven't really put forth a lot of time in trying to sort people yet.
Posted: Thu Sep 27, 2018 6:25 am
by Lamees
VOTE: kaldridge1025
sorry I know it's your first game but so is it for many of us, but no lurkiness/lack of activity from anyone else
Posted: Thu Sep 27, 2018 6:59 am
by acrimoniusalpaca
Agreeing with Lamees, I feel that it is in Town's benefit to lynch silent lurking players. If they are town, they are not doing any good for the town. If they are mafia, then it is good for the town. So I'm voting UNVOTE: Flavour Leaf VOTE: kalridge1025
I feel this also makes RVS less R.
Posted: Thu Sep 27, 2018 7:02 am
by dojaj
In post 111, LCpl Jones wrote:... I'm not entirely sure what you mean by that but ok, fair enough. Maybe you mean that I'm a bit "verbose" for lack of a better word? That's my normal playstyle, always has been.
Also, I don't like that you immediiately jump from attacking XX on his Korina push then to me then you agree with XX about Korina. That seems a bit inconsistent, kind of like you're flailing around a bit trying to push a few different people and see what happens. But... that's more of a towntell to me imo in this stage since that's the only way to get info this early.
Hmmmmm
Posted: Thu Sep 27, 2018 7:14 am
by Korina
VOTE: kaldridge
Sure, let's start a wagon to help get us further out of RVS.
Normally I would be against lynching lurkers, (mainly because of the site frowns upon it), however, I'll put that aside for now, seeing as everyone else has posted a bit, and they haven't.
My vote is currently L-2, so if two more people vote Kald, then Kald would be lynched.
I'll quickly catch-up and reply to a few posts that I'm curious about in a few moments.
In post 99, xx2008 wrote:I understand you're joking, but something tells me they're scummy.
Is this your normal playstyle?
Were ypuvreally just suspicious of korina or are you distracting everyone else from the possibility of you being scummy
I was suspicious of him, because the tone of his posts didn't seem natural at first.
True hmmmm
Care to share what you make of that post?
In post 111, LCpl Jones wrote:... I'm not entirely sure what you mean by that but ok, fair enough. Maybe you mean that I'm a bit "verbose" for lack of a better word? That's my normal playstyle, always has been.
Also, I don't like that you immediiately jump from attacking XX on his Korina push then to me then you agree with XX about Korina. That seems a bit inconsistent, kind of like you're flailing around a bit trying to push a few different people and see what happens. But... that's more of a towntell to me imo in this stage since that's the only way to get info this early.
Do you care to explain why that's townie to you?
I don't really see it as townie, however, I'm struggling to get into words why I exactly find it scummy
In post 111, LCpl Jones wrote:... I'm not entirely sure what you mean by that but ok, fair enough. Maybe you mean that I'm a bit "verbose" for lack of a better word? That's my normal playstyle, always has been.
Also, I don't like that you immediiately jump from attacking XX on his Korina push then to me then you agree with XX about Korina. That seems a bit inconsistent, kind of like you're flailing around a bit trying to push a few different people and see what happens. But... that's more of a towntell to me imo in this stage since that's the only way to get info this early.
Hmmmmm
Once again, what do you make of this post? "Hmmmmm" doesn't really help us out in trying to determine what you're thinking.
In post 99, xx2008 wrote:I understand you're joking, but something tells me they're scummy.
Is this your normal playstyle?
Were ypuvreally just suspicious of korina or are you distracting everyone else from the possibility of you being scummy
I was suspicious of him, because the tone of his posts didn't seem natural at first.
True hmmmm
Care to share what you make of that post?
In post 111, LCpl Jones wrote:... I'm not entirely sure what you mean by that but ok, fair enough. Maybe you mean that I'm a bit "verbose" for lack of a better word? That's my normal playstyle, always has been.
Also, I don't like that you immediiately jump from attacking XX on his Korina push then to me then you agree with XX about Korina. That seems a bit inconsistent, kind of like you're flailing around a bit trying to push a few different people and see what happens. But... that's more of a towntell to me imo in this stage since that's the only way to get info this early.
Do you care to explain why that's townie to you?
I don't really see it as townie, however, I'm struggling to get into words why I exactly find it scummy
In post 111, LCpl Jones wrote:... I'm not entirely sure what you mean by that but ok, fair enough. Maybe you mean that I'm a bit "verbose" for lack of a better word? That's my normal playstyle, always has been.
Also, I don't like that you immediiately jump from attacking XX on his Korina push then to me then you agree with XX about Korina. That seems a bit inconsistent, kind of like you're flailing around a bit trying to push a few different people and see what happens. But... that's more of a towntell to me imo in this stage since that's the only way to get info this early.
Hmmmmm
Once again, what do you make of this post? "Hmmmmm" doesn't really help us out in trying to determine what you're thinking.
Idk guys I really still can’t tell anyone’s intentions I’m wondering if it’s Jones regular play or f my initial method of him being super nice is a revrse psychology method hmmm who knows. And the contradiction is cuz I understood his point of view. I just tend to be diplomatic anyways I still feel suspicious about jones so I’ll wait it out a day or two more
Posted: Thu Sep 27, 2018 10:25 am
by xx2008
I don’t like to put too much pressure on a lurky player because they could be either alignment and simply not put that much time into this game.
I actually find dojaj a bit scummy.
anyways I still feel suspicious about jones so I’ll wait it out a day or two more