Mafiascum.net

In post 94, Chara wrote:i wonder if this game will solve the old 'can Maria and Dunn read each other' debate.

spoiler alert: they cant

In post 101, Nosferatu wrote:

In post 94, Chara wrote:i wonder if this game will solve the old 'can Maria and Dunn read each other' debate.

spoiler alert: they cant

I
https://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=3&t=77288
beg
https://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=84&t=74958
to
https://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=54&t=73659
differ
https://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=23&t=76680

Dunn backing off is note worthy but I'm not outting my read on him yet given if I do everyone's gonna sheep it. So I'll let others handle it for now.

In post 90, Joey_ wrote:And even if i was objectively scummy in my first few posts regarding what is normal scum behavior and what not; I expect better than just calling me obv scum in page 4 like you think you can read me that well so

So you admit you were objectively scummy. Also if I can't read you well like you're implying shouldn't me scumreading you be a town tell? Don't think you're really thinking this through.

In post 94, Chara wrote:i wonder if

this

game will solve the old 'can Maria and Dunn read each other' debate.
most games i remember with both of them where they weren't hydraed had them as opposite alignments.

VOTE: Almost

Oh yeah I forgot you and almost50 in the same game...this'll be fun.

In post 98, Carcalilly wrote:why though

Dunn Red pm

Can already tell my strategy will start mainly day 2.

For now Elsa will go into hiding. Become one with the shadows...

I've never seen dunn sr maria this fast when he was town.

VOTE: dunn

^ Scummy

In post 104, MariaR wrote:

In post 90, Joey_ wrote:And even if i was objectively scummy in my first few posts regarding what is normal scum behavior and what not; I expect better than just calling me obv scum in page 4 like you think you can read me that well so

So you admit you were objectively scummy. Also if I can't read you well like you're implying shouldn't me scumreading you be a town tell? Don't think you're really thinking this through.

Absolute bullshit rhetoric and this is far from outstanding performance as either alignment

I never mentioned that i admitted i was being scummy, I said "even if" meaning "in the possibility you actually thought i was being scummy from general scum behavior aka mech talk"

In post 108, Dunnstral wrote:^ Scummy

VOTE: Dunnstral

Every single time Creature has been mentioned to me it's because of his scum meta being so obvious it hurts.

VOTE: Creature

If we only got 24 hours, might as well go for the garunteed, amirite?

It feels like this thread is in a state of limbo...

Joey is my strongest town read. Setup spec is easy to do as scum, but the way he did it (interacting with everyone, bouncing ideas around) was pretty towny. His regular activity and his aggression against Maria also suggests town.

I don't like Maria's vote or her reasons for scum-reading Joey, but post 83 is gold. Also don't think her ascetic claim is scum motivated.

In post 52, ManateeDude wrote:why would VT or Toxic Goo claim?

Considering we've already spent two pages discussing the topic at the time of this post this question didn't seem necessary, particularly the "Toxic Goo" part.

In post 110, ManateeDude wrote:

In post 108, Dunnstral wrote:^ Scummy

VOTE: Dunnstral

Pops back in to drop essentially a naked vote on the leading wagon. Seems pretty opportunistic.

First impression of Dunn was that his "toxic goo and VT should claim" entrance would be pretty forward coming from scum. I thought his Maria vote was fine but his later "Maria's claim is convenient" post and later backtracking was less so. Still could see Dunn being town here, but both of Manetee's posts are drenched in scum.

VOTE: ManateeDude

VOTE: Creature

And if this flips red; Snowman is also red.

I'm not going to vote someone who hasn't even posted in the game. Literally the only indication that his flip has a >rand chance of being scum is the notion that "his scum meta is obvious", but unless his scum meta is to not even post at all that doesn't mean anything. More than likely he just flaked out / over-gamed / straight out forgot about this game, which is NAI at best.

But his scum meta IS not even posting at all.

Like, not posting at all, period? Is there a scum-game of his where he has to be prodded D1 for literally not posting a single time?

I'm telling you as a guy who previously replaced into his slot he tapped out. It was a scum slot. Granted, I made everyone forget who was in that slot before me and pulled a hard AF victory, but still...

Just flipped through a few Creature scum games and holy moly does he play an obvious scum.

Still don't see a point in voting him before he follows through with his prod / is replaced. If he is scum it'd probably be obvious by the end of D1 anyways. I just think its a shot in the dark rn even considering his scum meta.

In post 111, AnonymousGhost wrote:

Creature has been prodded.

(expired on 2018-11-03 11:04:10)

We have 20 damn hours and I'm not feeling the Dunn and Mana wagons. So we get rid of the slot that'll fuck us later.

Um... the deadlines not in 20 hours? That's just his prod timer.