Newbie 1973 | Mountain | Over

[Farren]

I think Cheeky is Town. I like the poking and prodding attitude so far.

[PenguinPower]

Agree with town for now. She can exhibit that behavior as both alignments and had me snowed in our last game together before she repped out.

[PenguinPower]

Normally I try to prioritize reading Newbie games over others for meta-reads on SEs. Given that you're the listmod and post in literally every Newbie game ... yeah, no, not happening.

You can click the wiki button under my avatar and look at 2016/2017 for my Newbie games.

[Plotinus]

Official Vote Count 1.04

Alpamayo, Cordillera Blanca, Peru

---

Lynching

With 9 votes in play, it takes 5 to lynch.

EspeciallyTheLies

(2): CheekyTeeky, ArthurConyl

Gyro Zeppeli

(2): PenguinPower, Farren

Nomanssky101

(1): Gyro Zeppeli

CheekyTeeky

(1): EspeciallyTheLies

chazary

(1): Ph0enix

Not Voting

(2): Nomanssky101, chazary

Deadline:

(expired on 2019-12-21 08:00:00).

Mod notes:

Nomanssky101 has (expired on 2019-12-13 08:00:00) to confirm before I will start looking for a replacement.

Prods will go out in about 2.5 hours to anyone who hasn't posted in the thread yet.[/area]

[Gyro Zeppeli]

VOTE: especiallytheliea

Providing no backup claims to his vote.

Also nomansky and chaz seem dead

[Plotinus]

chazary¹ has been prodded. They have (expired on 2019-12-13 05:31:42) to post before I start looking for a replacement. Nomanssky101 has another (expired on 2019-12-13 08:00:00) to remember that MafiaScum exists before they will be replaced.

[chazary]

Wow I am sorry I had no clue how fast this game would pick up. But I'm here now!

VOTE: ArthurConyl
(wow i hope i did that right)

Just to make everyone feels wanted

[Gyro Zeppeli]

Wow I am sorry I had no clue how fast this game would pick up. But I'm here now!

VOTE: ArthurConyl
(wow i hope i did that right)

Just to make everyone feels wanted

Why the Arthur vote?

you just appeared said sorry for being late then vote him?

[Plotinus]

Gyro Zeppeli has been banned for a couple weeks, so you don't have to play with him anymore. I'll find someone else for the slot.

[chazary]

Just wanted everyone to have a vote since this round of voting doesn't seem to mean anything.

But since it was such a controversial choice then fine.

VOTE: PenguinPower

[PenguinPower]

I mean - we're at the point where the votes are starting to mean something and aren't completely random. The same question still extends to your hop, though. Why a vote on me? Do you think ETL and Gyro are both town?

[chazary]

Do you think ETL and Gyro are both town?

Well Gyro just voted ETL and also just got banned and you were the only one I could tell still didn't have a vote on you atm. It really was just random. Just trying to get involved in the scheming and whatnot.

[chazary]

Wait I misread the voting. My bad. I can't read. Let me reevaluate the situation.

UNVOTE: PenguinPower

[PenguinPower]

What do you think of ETL and Gyro - or the slot that was previously occupied by Gyro?

[Ph0enix]

Small Pp is prob maf then imo, i see a 3rd vote as needless pressure

Gyro why didn't you vote PP here?

+1

If Gyro's motives for voting Nomanssky were to apply pressure and/or perform a reaction test, I'd expect a different reaction to realizing that Nomanssky hadn't checked in. Voting elsewhere; unvoting; challenging my premises if he thought my logic was flawed. Not just acknowledging, leaving the vote in place, and saying nothing else.
VOTE: Gyro Zeppeli

I absolutely agree. Will let him explain himself before voting, though.

I think Cheeky is Town. I like the poking and prodding attitude so far.

Agree with town for now. She can exhibit that behavior as both alignments and had me snowed in our last game together before she repped out.

To both: could you further explain why you believe Cheeky is town?

VOTE: especiallytheliea
Providing no backup claims to his vote.

Neither did we earlier, what's your point?

I mean - we're at the point where the votes are starting to mean something and aren't completely random.

How's that, given the fact that about half of the current votes

are

completely random (including mine)? I mean, I voted chazary but it's not like it'll make a difference or something. That being said:
UNVOTE: chazary

[PenguinPower]

To both: could you further explain why you believe Cheeky is town?

She's making an effort to actually sort people through questioning (e.g. not empty questions). It's an early, tentative read, but it's a start.

How's that, given the fact that about half of the current votes are completely random (including mine)? I mean, I voted chazary but it's not like it'll make a difference or something. That being said:

We've got a primary wagon and a counterwagon, and people are beginning to ask substantive questions. Hence why I said "starting to."

Why are you asking questions to/waiting for an explanation from an empty slot that won't be able to provide a response?

[Ph0enix]

Why are you asking questions to/waiting for an explanation from an empty slot that won't be able to provide a response?

Who are you referring to?

[PenguinPower]

You.

[PenguinPower]

You.

If you mean which slot am I referring to, I would direct you to this post:

Gyro Zeppeli has been banned for a couple weeks, so you don't have to play with him anymore. I'll find someone else for the slot.

More than half your post was in regard to that Gyro's slot.

[Ph0enix]

That one's on me, honestly. My bad.

[PenguinPower]

So, given Gyro - and his future replacement - can't explain do you still want to vote there given you agree with what Farren said?

[Ph0enix]

So, given Gyro - and his future replacement - can't explain do you still want to vote there given you agree with what Farren said?

No.

[Ph0enix]

She's making an effort to actually sort people through questioning (e.g. not empty questions). It's an early, tentative read, but it's a start.

Again, I fail to see how that makes you think she's Town necessarily. She doesn't have to be Town to do so.

[PenguinPower]

Why not? Did you not find his actions suspect?

Also, I forgot to ask earlier, but what are your thoughts on Cheeky?

[PenguinPower]

She's making an effort to actually sort people through questioning (e.g. not empty questions). It's an early, tentative read, but it's a start.

Again, I fail to see how that makes you think she's Town necessarily. She doesn't have to be Town to do so.

It's a good starting point. Reads can change and evolve, but a player who come across as genuinely trying to sort people's alignment is a towntell (scum already know everyone's alignment).

How do you think we should go about trying to sort alignment?