Newbie 2057: Mars! - End!

[WhemeStar]

T3 May I suggest finding an avatar to use? A lot of people on this site use avatars to know who they are talking to ( or at least I do) so having an avatar helps putting a face to the name

[WhemeStar]

94 threw me way off

what exactly about 94 threw you off so much to change your read?

That was a sort of sharpish turn from "obv town" to "maybe not obv town"

I would prefer to not talk about it until later

[T3]

T3 May I suggest finding an avatar to use? A lot of people on this site use avatars to know who they are talking to ( or at least I do) so having an avatar helps putting a face to the name

Sure, I'll do that soon.

[T3]

94 threw me way off

what exactly about 94 threw you off so much to change your read?

That was a sort of sharpish turn from "obv town" to "maybe not obv town"

I would prefer to not talk about it until later

Why is that?

[WhemeStar]

94 threw me way off

what exactly about 94 threw you off so much to change your read?

That was a sort of sharpish turn from "obv town" to "maybe not obv town"

I would prefer to not talk about it until later

Why is that?

I would prefer to not talk about it until later

[CreativeName]

94 threw me way off

what exactly about 94 threw you off so much to change your read?

That was a sort of sharpish turn from "obv town" to "maybe not obv town"

I would prefer to not talk about it until later

Why is that?

Something I find interesting too because you never know when you will die, X amount of people could come and hammer you and that thing you were going to say later will never be said. Also it's not townish to withhold info unless it's such as a town result from a cop and you don't want to out yourself yet or a role of a town power

[WhemeStar]

94 threw me way off

what exactly about 94 threw you off so much to change your read?

That was a sort of sharpish turn from "obv town" to "maybe not obv town"

I would prefer to not talk about it until later

Why is that?

Something I find interesting too because you never know when you will die, X amount of people could come and hammer you and that thing you were going to say later will never be said. Also it's not townish to withhold info unless it's such as a town result from a cop and you don't want to out yourself yet or a role of a town power

I’m not the type of player who really gets night killed

I also don’t think me getting flash wagoned hammered happens ever

[CreativeName]

I’m not the type of player who really gets night killed

I also don’t think me getting flash wagoned hammered happens ever

Don't tempt fate, it's a cruel mistress

[CreativeName]

I messed that up it's post 106 not post 97

[skitter30]

Skitter do you have a lot of experience with pooky?

This play from him currently seems fake and sounds like he’s trying to put on a front for no reason.

Unless he does this type of thing every game then that would change my mind.

i have a lot of experience with him (usually tvt, once or twice him s i think, i don't htink i've ever been s)
this is the first time he's done this sort of thing, it's making a little worried he's trying to like ~broadly discredit~ me, esp as he's still doing it (and not much else)

~
i think all of wheme/creative/kazyan are town

don't have enuf on t3 yet

i'm not sure what to do abt pooky

i don't think the other people have posted yet

other than pooky wouldn't be surprised if all the scumz were in the people who haven't posted yet tbh

[WhemeStar]

All good creative your more advanced with the forum posting/quoting than I am.

[CreativeName]

Skitter do you have a lot of experience with pooky?

This play from him currently seems fake and sounds like he’s trying to put on a front for no reason.

Unless he does this type of thing every game then that would change my mind.

i have a lot of experience with him (usually tvt, once or twice him s i think, i don't htink i've ever been s)
this is the first time he's done this sort of thing, it's making a little worried he's trying to like ~broadly discredit~ me, esp as he's still doing it (and not much else)

~
i think all of wheme/creative/kazyan are town

don't have enuf on t3 yet

i'm not sure what to do abt pooky

i don't think the other people have posted yet

other than pooky wouldn't be surprised if all the scumz were in the people who haven't posted yet tbh

Possible 1 active 1 inactive scum team, I have seen it before where a single scum does all the legwork while the inactive scum(s) get picked off, the best way to figure it out is to kill the active one as it forces the inactive/lurker to appear and defend themselves

[T3]

I've been playing mafia for about 5 years but this is my first forum game in 2 years so feel free to slap me with a trout if I'm being stupid.

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

this is the first time he's done this sort of thing, it's making a little worried he's trying to like ~broadly discredit~ me, esp as he's still doing it (and not much else)

I am not broadly discrediting you :<

[T3]

Anyways, rereading this I only felt skitter was scummy for that one post. Creative is probably town... not sure about pooky.

[Kazyan]

I would prefer to not talk about it until later

Why is that?

I would prefer to not talk about it until later

Looking like a doofus is a great way to not get nightkilled, but it doesn't help us find scum. Or town, for that matter.

Possible 1 active 1 inactive scum team, I have seen it before where a single scum does all the legwork while the inactive scum(s) get picked off, the best way to figure it out is to kill the active one as it forces the inactive/lurker to appear and defend themselves

I figure the same distribution. UNVOTE: CreativeName, since I'm not longer getting LAMIST vibes. Off the top of your head, if you're correct, who do you think the active scum would be?

i have a lot of experience with him (usually tvt, once or twice him s i think, i don't htink i've ever been s)
this is the first time he's done this sort of thing, it's making a little worried he's trying to like ~broadly discredit~ me, esp as he's still doing it (and not much else)

Do other players normally commit funposting as scum? i.e. is this kind of thing alignment-indicative in general?

[CreativeName]

Possible 1 active 1 inactive scum team, I have seen it before where a single scum does all the legwork while the inactive scum(s) get picked off, the best way to figure it out is to kill the active one as it forces the inactive/lurker to appear and defend themselves

I figure the same distribution. UNVOTE: CreativeName, since I'm not longer getting LAMIST vibes. Off the top of your head, if you're correct, who do you think the active scum would be?

If we split players into 2 groups based on activity

Active:
Me - Creative
You - Kazyan
Skitter
Wheme
Pooky

Inactive/low activity
Megan
T3
Griff
SAMCRO

Possibly my 2 most likely from active grouping is either Pooky or Wheme, I'd possibly order it from most to least as Pooky, Wheme, Kazyan, Skitter, Me

As for IA because of the nature of inactivity it makes players harder to read however from what i read of T3 they'd be less likely to be scum compared to some of the others, due to maybe some of them possibly lurking

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

ok why am I likely to be scum?

[WhemeStar]

Is there any reason you believe 1 scum is active and 1 scum is inactive?

[WhemeStar]

I don’t see why you would ever think that unless you have meta on player

[CreativeName]

Is there any reason you believe 1 scum is active and 1 scum is inactive?

due to a near half split in actives and inactive it's more probable that one is lurking, especially in a newbie game

ok why am I likely to be scum?

The "discrediting" of skitter, as it was referred to, I see it as maybe a pocket attempt disguised as a warning or maybe it's being a bit over cautious

she is going to eat you :O

i have to warn the newbies of the horrors I have seen :3

also I had said before

VOTE: POOKY

Seems like a scum move to try make an active wagon

It seemed scummy to push a wagon on skitter before she even said a word

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

The "discrediting" of skitter, as it was referred to, I see it as maybe a pocket attempt disguised as a warning or maybe it's being a bit over cautious

um how am I discrediting her?

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

It seemed scummy to push a wagon on skitter before she even said a word

explain?

[Kazyan]

If we split players into 2 groups based on activity

Active:
Me - Creative
You - Kazyan
Skitter
Wheme
Pooky

Inactive/low activity
Megan
T3
Griff
SAMCRO

Possibly my 2 most likely from active grouping is either Pooky or Wheme, I'd possibly order it from most to least as Pooky, Wheme, Kazyan, Skitter, Me

As for IA because of the nature of inactivity it makes players harder to read however from what i read of T3 they'd be less likely to be scum compared to some of the others, due to maybe some of them possibly lurking

I understand the Pooky read, but for a different reason: Up until now, Pooky's posts felt content-free rather than that he was trying to sort people. I really disagree that the Skitter wagon was scummy. Not trying to sort people might be, though.

[skitter30]

this is the first time he's done this sort of thing, it's making a little worried he's trying to like ~broadly discredit~ me, esp as he's still doing it (and not much else)

I am not broadly discrediting you :<

ok, sure, what are you doing then?