Mafiascum.net

In post 98, Servant Saber wrote:

In post 90, Servant Archer wrote:It is more that it looked like they were overselling

This is fair. I feel like I have a duty to go after the master role and that might come across as overselling.

Why is that?

In post 84, Servant Archer wrote:Alter Ego - what are your thoughts on being the one with a master - you look like you are building up the most town reads so far

I've no particular interest in being a leader - I don't feel as though I work well as conftown. I read people better off how they interact with me when I'm not cleared, being confirmed messes that all up. I'm also subject to bouts of paranoia and indecisiveness when I have to take the lead. I much prefer to play a supporting role in games. I'm certainly no Assassin v1.

I believe I have a 3rd townread.

My two TR's so far are Saber and Lancer. Berserker seems okay, but I may be reading in too much there.

After that, I can't really tell. Alter ego seems surface thoughtful. Bu they're taking pains to avoid being misunderstood.

In post 99, Servant Archer wrote:Saber seems to think that their ability would be about on par with Assassins, so if we are making a mech choice, I would rather Assassin over Saber.

This isn't quite right. Each is situational. It's hard to compare the two was my point.

In post 96, Servant Caster wrote:

In post 93, Servant Berserker wrote:but it doesn’t seem likely scum is this.. off.

?

How am I off?

You have some very awkward stances, and I would think if you were scum you would at least have some kind of idea of the past game from one of your buddies by now. At this point in the game, I’m leaning you are the type of person I’d butt heads with, causing my initial skepticisms.

Pedit-
I disagree. Assassins overselling feels very inorganic, like a presidential election almost. And again, do not vote a master for solely role based reasons.

I also think that between Assassin and Saber's claims, I think we have mech choices, and people should probably avoid talking about their NP from her on.

Although, I am not entirely sold that a mech choice is better then a TR choice.

Scratch that, I've four townreads. Catching up with the page count.

I think Saber is both town and mechanically a good choice though.
So I don't feel quite so conflicted.

I honestly find it questionable that someone who gained a guaranteed cop shot from their NP would out it openly without possible consideration of it being blocked as a result.

I think at this point for me Saber is a TR/Mech choice combined into one so I'm comfortable with this vote.

In post 100, Servant Lancer wrote:

In post 98, Servant Saber wrote:

In post 90, Servant Archer wrote:It is more that it looked like they were overselling

This is fair. I feel like I have a duty to go after the master role and that might come across as overselling.

Why is that?

It's hard to state without getting to far into my NP. Think about why town lose games. Think if someone could prevent that from happening.

Put that with a town leader.

I feel like it's my responsibility to prevent us from ruining ourselves if that makes sense.

In that sense Saber's vagueness and caginess about their role seems more town.

Gotta love when a Saber acts all Sabery.

alright

townread-wise I think I like alter ego more but I’m not scumreading saber

In post 102, Servant Beast wrote:My two TR's so far are Saber and Lancer. Berserker seems okay, but I may be reading in too much there.

After that, I can't really tell. Alter ego seems surface thoughtful. Bu they're taking pains to avoid being misunderstood.

I'm not sure what you mean by this?

In post 103, Servant Saber wrote:

In post 99, Servant Archer wrote:Saber seems to think that their ability would be about on par with Assassins, so if we are making a mech choice, I would rather Assassin over Saber.

This isn't quite right. Each is situational. It's hard to compare the two was my point.

If yours is worse in some situations, and worse in others, and you cannot guarantee we will be in a situation where yours is better - then I'm gonna boil that down to them being on par with one another.

Alter Ego makes a decent point about the caginess tho

In post 108, Servant Alter Ego wrote:I honestly find it questionable that someone who gained a guaranteed cop shot from their NP would out it openly without possible consideration of it being blocked as a result.

It has been considered. I can guarantee its effectiveness.

In post 114, Servant Alter Ego wrote:

In post 102, Servant Beast wrote:My two TR's so far are Saber and Lancer. Berserker seems okay, but I may be reading in too much there.

After that, I can't really tell. Alter ego seems surface thoughtful. Bu they're taking pains to avoid being misunderstood.

I'm not sure what you mean by this?

imo, that looks like beast is reaching for a reason to keep you out of their town reads

You're being clear and calculated. You're not saying who your town reads are nor are you justifying them. You're explaining your mindset to avoid being misconstrued.
I don't think every post you make is designed to help town and that wiggles me. Scum have an incentive to be town read and the earlier the better.
I'm null on you.

In post 117, Servant Archer wrote:

In post 114, Servant Alter Ego wrote:

In post 102, Servant Beast wrote:My two TR's so far are Saber and Lancer. Berserker seems okay, but I may be reading in too much there.

After that, I can't really tell. Alter ego seems surface thoughtful. Bu they're taking pains to avoid being misunderstood.

I'm not sure what you mean by this?

imo, that looks like beast is reaching for a reason to keep you out of their town reads

That seems like a rather uncharitable interpretation of Beast's words.

In post 108, Servant Alter Ego wrote:I honestly find it questionable that someone who gained a guaranteed cop shot from their NP would out it openly without possible consideration of it being blocked as a result.

Also, if they don't get the the master, outing it puts a target on themselves before they will have their NP charged

In post 120, Servant Archer wrote:

In post 108, Servant Alter Ego wrote:I honestly find it questionable that someone who gained a guaranteed cop shot from their NP would out it openly without possible consideration of it being blocked as a result.

Also, if they don't get the the master, outing it puts a target on themselves before they will have their NP charged

I agree with this. It feels wrong but maybe that's self-interest talking.

Assassins entire play has screamed “I want the master power up from whoever gets it.” I can’t be the only one who saw that.

Is there some reason you're pretending to be Fferylit AE? Just like, trying out a new style because it's an anon game or? It's worth trying to read you early I think.

In post 123, Servant Beast wrote:Is there some reason you're pretending to be Fferylit AE? Just like, trying out a new style because it's an anon game or? It's worth trying to read you early I think.

Can anyone answer that within the rules?