In post 16, hutmeil wrote:I guess since this is Day 1, all the current votes are senseless.
My notes:
Alianna
- was informed that furtiveglance is Town?? (Mason or Friendly Neighbor?)
- asks who wants to be nightkilled (sus)
Well this is just a disgusting post to start off the game.
Disgusting? Sure. But is it scummy? Ehhh...I think newbscum tries harder to look townie. Pretty sure it was just meant to be a joke post since it was during RVS.
Then again, they disappeared afterward. I understand that not much is going on right now, but it's been almost three days since their last post. Let's get some pressure going, maybe?
VOTE: Hutmeil
smells more like something newb-scum would do and could get away with it.
If it is a joke it seems like a role-fishy joke to me.
it's obvious that FG & aliana have a hx together so I didn't find it so incredibly suspicious..
The post itself sucked, but the follow-up was promising. When I was a Newbie, I only had a general idea of how the roles worked and I can see a bit of a townie mindset right there.
Posted: Sat May 28, 2022 4:28 am
by Greeting
In post 78, furtiveglance wrote:I have early townleans on whiskey delta and hutmeil. I don't think anyone else has earned one yet.
I just really hope you are scum thats fishing for reactions right now, but at least if you are town you will be learning a good experience for the future to never really point out stuff like this and drag it on because it helps scum aid in finding who the PR's are based on reactions.
I respectfully disagree. Town is at a disadvantage because of lack of information. One of the most logical ways to counter this is to bring information to the forefront. Sometimes this means role revealing if it has to come to that. But right now since it's still Day 1 we don't have to do so.
In post 68, whiskey delta wrote:hutmeil seems Elim Bait ish to me but I am bothered by how they assumed Alianna meant a Town role in her post 11. Can you talk about that
@hutmeil
?
Dislike Roden hedging on that wagon more though
VOTE: Roden
Well, according to Alianna, she was "informed" that furtiveglance is Town. That could mean several things:
- Alianna is a Mason, so it was the mod that "informed" her
- Alianna is FN, which is not likely since we started with Day 1 and not Night 1. She can only be informed after Night 1 (if I'm right).
Based on above, she's likely Mason (assuming she's Town). So that means, we're either setup Col A Row 3 or Col C Row 3.
Right now, I'm not inclined to vote either of them because if both of them are Town, then the other will die on Night 1. So that's 2 Towns in a row. I'd rather vote someone who like to bandwagon like:
UNVOTE: takotsubo syndrome
VOTE: Roden
If Roden, turns out scum, then I'd say takotsubo is scum too since they're the ones who started the bandwagon on me.
On another note, sorry about my late replies. I'm from GMT +8 so most probably not same timezone as you guys.
Neither Mason nor FN work in this way. Alianna was joking that she is mafia. I like your notes though
Please enlighten me on how these roles work.
Posted: Sat May 28, 2022 6:05 am
by whiskey delta
You should read the wiki if you want more info. Alianna was not claiming anything, just making a joke to Furtive. Let’s leave it at that
I just really hope you are scum thats fishing for reactions right now, but at least if you are town you will be learning a good experience for the future to never really point out stuff like this and drag it on because it helps scum aid in finding who the PR's are based on reactions.
I respectfully disagree. Town is at a disadvantage because of lack of information. One of the most logical ways to counter this is to bring information to the forefront. Sometimes this means role revealing if it has to come to that. But right now since it's still Day 1 we don't have to do so.
Has everyone sounded off already?
Role revealing is generally only a good idea if you're at E-1 with intent to hammer, there's a massclaim, or you have crucial information (like a cop guilty). Otherwise, it's anti-town to discuss roles.
In post 68, whiskey delta wrote:hutmeil seems Elim Bait ish to me but I am bothered by how they assumed Alianna meant a Town role in her post 11. Can you talk about that
@hutmeil
?
Dislike Roden hedging on that wagon more though
VOTE: Roden
Well, according to Alianna, she was "informed" that furtiveglance is Town. That could mean several things:
- Alianna is a Mason, so it was the mod that "informed" her
- Alianna is FN, which is not likely since we started with Day 1 and not Night 1. She can only be informed after Night 1 (if I'm right).
Based on above, she's likely Mason (assuming she's Town). So that means, we're either setup Col A Row 3 or Col C Row 3.
Right now, I'm not inclined to vote either of them because if both of them are Town, then the other will die on Night 1. So that's 2 Towns in a row. I'd rather vote someone who like to bandwagon like:
UNVOTE: takotsubo syndrome
VOTE: Roden
If Roden, turns out scum, then I'd say takotsubo is scum too since they're the ones who started the bandwagon on me.
On another note, sorry about my late replies. I'm from GMT +8 so most probably not same timezone as you guys.
Neither Mason nor FN work in this way. Alianna was joking that she is mafia. I like your notes though :wink:
Please enlighten me on how these roles work.
Masons - are confirmed as town to each other and share a PT.
FN - targets one player each night, the targeted player is informed that the FN is town.
If it still isn't clear, you can read the sample role PMs in 2.
And now I would like to cease the role discussion.
Posted: Sat May 28, 2022 8:11 am
by hutmeil
In post 108, Alianna wrote:hutmeil, I think you're probably town, but this discussion is anti-town, so I'll clarify these and we'll leave it at that.
I just really hope you are scum thats fishing for reactions right now, but at least if you are town you will be learning a good experience for the future to never really point out stuff like this and drag it on because it helps scum aid in finding who the PR's are based on reactions.
I respectfully disagree. Town is at a disadvantage because of lack of information. One of the most logical ways to counter this is to bring information to the forefront. Sometimes this means role revealing if it has to come to that. But right now since it's still Day 1 we don't have to do so.
Has everyone sounded off already?
Role revealing is generally only a good idea if you're at E-1 with intent to hammer, there's a massclaim, or you have crucial information (like a cop guilty). Otherwise, it's anti-town to discuss roles.
In post 68, whiskey delta wrote:hutmeil seems Elim Bait ish to me but I am bothered by how they assumed Alianna meant a Town role in her post 11. Can you talk about that
@hutmeil
?
Dislike Roden hedging on that wagon more though
VOTE: Roden
Well, according to Alianna, she was "informed" that furtiveglance is Town. That could mean several things:
- Alianna is a Mason, so it was the mod that "informed" her
- Alianna is FN, which is not likely since we started with Day 1 and not Night 1. She can only be informed after Night 1 (if I'm right).
Based on above, she's likely Mason (assuming she's Town). So that means, we're either setup Col A Row 3 or Col C Row 3.
Right now, I'm not inclined to vote either of them because if both of them are Town, then the other will die on Night 1. So that's 2 Towns in a row. I'd rather vote someone who like to bandwagon like:
UNVOTE: takotsubo syndrome
VOTE: Roden
If Roden, turns out scum, then I'd say takotsubo is scum too since they're the ones who started the bandwagon on me.
On another note, sorry about my late replies. I'm from GMT +8 so most probably not same timezone as you guys.
Neither Mason nor FN work in this way. Alianna was joking that she is mafia. I like your notes though
Please enlighten me on how these roles work.
Masons - are confirmed as town to each other and share a PT.
FN - targets one player each night, the targeted player is informed that the FN is town.
If it still isn't clear, you can read the sample role PMs in 2.
And now I would like to cease the role discussion.
Interesting.
Thanks for the role infos, that's exactly how I understood them.
My vote stays.
Posted: Sat May 28, 2022 8:49 am
by Tidus of the X
I don't think we should speculate on this FN/Mason thing too much, it could likely be a joke post for the start of the day
I used to play a lot but it’s probably been about ~3 years since I did last. My home website went the way of the dodo sadly
Played ages ago but not here, but thru email threads.
Posted: Sat May 28, 2022 12:54 pm
by Roden
I saw that, I mean what was their actual experience playing the game.
Posted: Sat May 28, 2022 1:01 pm
by Alianna
Oh, I misinterpreted then.
I second that question though.
Posted: Sat May 28, 2022 1:02 pm
by Alianna
Also, @72, you've posted twice. Have you any thoughts on this game?
Posted: Sat May 28, 2022 1:56 pm
by the worst
Prodding 72offsuit.
Posted: Sat May 28, 2022 2:36 pm
by 72offsuit
Apologies for the prods. Will reread later today.
@Alianna sure. I do. But before I do, who would you eliminate right now if you theoretically had the hammer right now as at post 117?
Posted: Sat May 28, 2022 3:32 pm
by hutmeil
In post 113, Roden wrote:I saw that, I mean what was their actual experience playing the game.
Hmmm not sure exactly what you're asking but I played via email as I've said and that was like more than a decade ago. I guess I have 10-15 games under my belt.
Posted: Sat May 28, 2022 4:08 pm
by whiskey delta
Provided hutmeil = Town, I might slot Alianna as my top TR now for post 79
Posted: Sat May 28, 2022 4:15 pm
by furtiveglance
79 is just mech talk and speculation, why does Alianna get a townread?
This is unfair. Townread ME even though I don't deserve it. D:<
Posted: Sat May 28, 2022 4:21 pm
by whiskey delta
Because in the greater context of the game Town clearing a possible MisElim early on as scum doesn’t make a lot of sense to me. Could be faked, of course, yadda yadda but the post shows some depth I’m not sure scum go to just to TR someone they didn’t have to. lolme if wrong but I kinda like that read for where we are currently.
Posted: Sat May 28, 2022 4:41 pm
by furtiveglance
Some players love dismissing others as limbait town and really labouring the point as scum. I'm not accusing Alianna of doing this, it's just something I've seen before.
In post 113, Roden wrote:I saw that, I mean what was their actual experience playing the game.
Hmmm not sure exactly what you're asking but I played via email as I've said and that was like more than a decade ago. I guess I have 10-15 games under my belt.
Not quite the answer that I was expecting, but it's interesting to know nonetheless.
In post 16, hutmeil wrote:I guess since this is Day 1, all the current votes are senseless.
My notes:
Alianna
- was informed that furtiveglance is Town?? (Mason or Friendly Neighbor?)
- asks who wants to be nightkilled (sus)
Originally, I thought this was just a joke, but then you made this post:
In post 68, whiskey delta wrote:hutmeil seems Elim Bait ish to me but I am bothered by how they assumed Alianna meant a Town role in her post 11. Can you talk about that
@hutmeil
?
Dislike Roden hedging on that wagon more though
VOTE: Roden
Well, according to Alianna, she was "informed" that furtiveglance is Town. That could mean several things:
- Alianna is a Mason, so it was the mod that "informed" her
- Alianna is FN, which is not likely since we started with Day 1 and not Night 1. She can only be informed after Night 1 (if I'm right).
Based on above, she's likely Mason (assuming she's Town). So that means, we're either setup Col A Row 3 or Col C Row 3.
Right now, I'm not inclined to vote either of them because if both of them are Town, then the other will die on Night 1. So that's 2 Towns in a row. I'd rather vote someone who like to bandwagon like:
UNVOTE: takotsubo syndrome
VOTE: Roden
If Roden, turns out scum, then I'd say takotsubo is scum too since they're the ones who started the bandwagon on me.
On another note, sorry about my late replies. I'm from GMT +8 so most probably not same timezone as you guys.
You double down on discussing PRs even though you've been told it's an anti-town thing to do. I could understand making this kind of mistake if you were just new, but you're claiming to have a pretty decent amount of experience under your belt. For comparison, it only takes five games to be considered SE (Semi-Experienced) on this site.
So considering your experience with the game, and your general tone that gives me the feeling that you know what you're doing, it makes me think that you openly discussing PRs is just feigned ignorance.
I just really hope you are scum thats fishing for reactions right now, but at least if you are town you will be learning a good experience for the future to never really point out stuff like this and drag it on because it helps scum aid in finding who the PR's are based on reactions.
I respectfully disagree. Town is at a disadvantage because of lack of information. One of the most logical ways to counter this is to bring information to the forefront. Sometimes this means role revealing if it has to come to that. But right now since it's still Day 1 we don't have to do so.
Has everyone sounded off already?
Role revealing is generally only a good idea if you're at E-1 with intent to hammer, there's a massclaim, or you have crucial information (like a cop guilty). Otherwise, it's anti-town to discuss roles.
In post 68, whiskey delta wrote:hutmeil seems Elim Bait ish to me but I am bothered by how they assumed Alianna meant a Town role in her post 11. Can you talk about that
@hutmeil
?
Dislike Roden hedging on that wagon more though
VOTE: Roden
Well, according to Alianna, she was "informed" that furtiveglance is Town. That could mean several things:
- Alianna is a Mason, so it was the mod that "informed" her
- Alianna is FN, which is not likely since we started with Day 1 and not Night 1. She can only be informed after Night 1 (if I'm right).
Based on above, she's likely Mason (assuming she's Town). So that means, we're either setup Col A Row 3 or Col C Row 3.
Right now, I'm not inclined to vote either of them because if both of them are Town, then the other will die on Night 1. So that's 2 Towns in a row. I'd rather vote someone who like to bandwagon like:
UNVOTE: takotsubo syndrome
VOTE: Roden
If Roden, turns out scum, then I'd say takotsubo is scum too since they're the ones who started the bandwagon on me.
On another note, sorry about my late replies. I'm from GMT +8 so most probably not same timezone as you guys.
Neither Mason nor FN work in this way. Alianna was joking that she is mafia. I like your notes though
Please enlighten me on how these roles work.
Masons - are confirmed as town to each other and share a PT.
FN - targets one player each night, the targeted player is informed that the FN is town.
If it still isn't clear, you can read the sample role PMs in 2.
And now I would like to cease the role discussion.
Interesting.
Thanks for the role infos, that's exactly how I understood them.
My vote stays.
Additionally, this implies that you're only voting me because I voted you, and that you did so because I had more momentum on my wagon than the other person who suspects you, which makes it an opportunistic vote.
