The game of the year: town won!

[Elmo TeH AzN]

elmo is still blatantly scum

Na broski its how I play
VOTE: CC

[TeChNoWC]

on one hand, i think CC is lurking scum. but on the other hand, i don't think scum would cast that second bandwagon vote. so CC is null for now.

t-bone is town. although i don't agree with his accusation on UN, it doesn't seem to be forced.

milk can't be read without reading the exact context. but i don't want to spend time reading that now. so i'll read later.

will vote later.

Why would scum not cast a bandwagon vote??

[mykonian]

Votecount

Captain Corporal (7): Ellibereth, peregrinev, BBmolla, Muffin Wednesday, Petapan, YYR, Elmo Teh Azn
uberninja (4): chevre, T-Bone, luffy, RedFF
T-bone (4): theamatuer, Thetrollie, amrun, Captain Corporal
Milk (4): Trevor, Spyrex, Technowc, dramonic
Spyrex (2): milk, Hoopla
Fritzler (1): Uberninja
muffin wednesday (1): zdenek
BBmolla (1): MattP
TechnoWC (1): imaginality
petapan (1): syndromeofadown

[Hoopla]

...

Look at the players voting for CC. They're all individually scummier than him. Except maybe petapan and Muffin is OK.

[TeChNoWC]

...

Look at the players voting for CC. They're all individually scummier than him. Except maybe petapan and Muffin is OK.

Was going to agree with you until you said 'petapan and muffin is ok'.

Peregrine is the only one I have a substantial townread on in that entire list.

[manho]

on one hand, i think CC is lurking scum. but on the other hand, i don't think scum would cast that second bandwagon vote. so CC is null for now.

t-bone is town. although i don't agree with his accusation on UN, it doesn't seem to be forced.

milk can't be read without reading the exact context. but i don't want to spend time reading that now. so i'll read later.

will vote later.

Why would scum not cast a bandwagon vote??

too scummy to be scum.

need more posts from him to have a better read.

[Staeg]

Okay, erm, I got neither a link to this thread nor a "D1 has started come post" PM, and I'd say that it's really unlikely that I'll be reading 40 pages that are (probably) mostly composed of nothing
I see spyrex has a vote down

vote: Milk

[zoraster]

um. apparently this game started. yeah... 41 pages in. Not going to read all of that. will be following now.

[Muffin Wednesday]

Muffin Wednesday

:
You've been riding T-bone for having bad town reads and claiming he got his reads from random.org WHEN YOU YOURSELF have inconsistent reads and you hate him for having a long list of town reads he doesn't explain when YOU YOURSELF do the same.

Your case on me is horrible. Your whole thing was based on the fact that you think I'm a mime, but then you call me non-mime in the exact same post and now you say I'm scum even though the mimes are all dead! Complete inconsistancy.

But it's not just me. Your case on Chevre is equally bad. You actually gave no reason for hating him so much other than "I disagree with him". Actually, I could go on, you're pushing so many BS cases at once, your scumreads are my town read and you've given town-reads to people I think are blatantly scummy and I generally dislike that.[/quote]

What the fuck is this?

It seems like you're problem is that you think I'm super-suspicious of the people I put in my scum list. I'm not super-suspicious of ANYONE. My scumlist consists of people who have done small suspicious things and haven't given me any town vibes. My TOWN list is concrete.

That probably answers most of your post.

[Captain Corporal]

That moment where I'm called lurking scum and 3 people have less posts than me. Not sure where those people on my wagon got their BS logic from.

[TeChNoWC]

That moment where I'm called lurking scum and 3 people have less posts than me. Not sure where those people on my wagon got their BS logic from.

Hence I'm watching your bandwagon very closely.

Though in their defence, you did vote without an explanation. Hardly lynchingworthy, but still.

Care to explain now that you are on?

[SpyreX]

Not bothering catching up on what I missed.

Unvote, Vote: CC

[petapan]

...

Look at the players voting for CC. They're all individually scummier than him. Except maybe petapan and Muffin is OK.

nah ellibereth is town

[TeChNoWC]

Not bothering catching up on what I missed.

Unvote, Vote: CC

Another suspected scummy gives in to the desire for a quicklynch. Eager for nightphase?

In terms of what you MISSED, three posts above you CC turned up, so maybe it would be best to let him speak before he gets hammered over two posts.

[TeChNoWC]

...

Look at the players voting for CC. They're all individually scummier than him. Except maybe petapan and Muffin is OK.

nah ellibereth is town

How do you come to that conclusion?

[petapan]

elmo is still blatantly scum

Na broski its how I play
VOTE: CC

this is false also

[petapan]

...

Look at the players voting for CC. They're all individually scummier than him. Except maybe petapan and Muffin is OK.

nah ellibereth is town

How do you come to that conclusion?

because i see an implicit town thought process in the way he posts

[Milk]

Another suspected scummy gives in to the desire for a quicklynch. Eager for nightphase?

In terms of what you MISSED, three posts above you CC turned up, so maybe it would be best to let him speak before he gets hammered over two posts.

If you read spyrex like I asked you to you would know that he's only interested in policy lynching people, and he hardly cares what their alignment is.

[TeChNoWC]

Chevre: Its gut. He's definitely not a mime AND if he's scum I'd be shocked. The nonchalance combined with doing things is that "if I had a button to kill 49 players" he'd be the one that survived.


Ohh to have that button.

So you would kill yourself over another player that MIGHT be town?

Milk and Ice should both be killed at night. If that doesn't end the Mime threat then they're far craftier than I thought.

Ohh my vote on Red is unabashed policy. I'm 100% on lynching wasteposters in this game and thats why I want(ed maybe we'll see) BB dead.

Uber before BB though. The idea that ... the post is a good idea is a death warrant.

OMGUSing Milk much? Did you ever provide a reasoning as to why you thought he was scum?

If you force scum to overcommit to poor lynches you already win, especially in this game.

Doubly so when you consider that there is no way in hell its a 10 person scumteam and if its something like 2 5s they're more than happy to lynch each other too.

Unvote, Vote: Milk

How could you possibly know this? A 10 man scum team (though much less likely) could still be possible; just because they would have enough votes to lynch does not make them unstoppable. A mafia lynch killing machine would soon become obvious if they didn't play subtle and split their votes around.

Not bothering catching up on what I missed.

Unvote, Vote: CC

Scummy.

Unvote
Vote: Spyrex

[petapan]

That moment where I'm called lurking scum and 3 people have less posts than me. Not sure where those people on my wagon got their BS logic from.

Still reading :X
VOTE: T-Bone

it's for this post actually and you're defense is less than stirring

[TeChNoWC]

Another suspected scummy gives in to the desire for a quicklynch. Eager for nightphase?

In terms of what you MISSED, three posts above you CC turned up, so maybe it would be best to let him speak before he gets hammered over two posts.

If you read spyrex like I asked you to you would know that he's only interested in policy lynching people, and he hardly cares what their alignment is.

Your timing is impeccable.

[TeChNoWC]

I would still like to know why you voted for Spyrex earlier, what exactly it was in response to, and why you didn't state your reasoning. Though I did find something about you talking about a stupid vote he made.

That being said, my read on Spyrex has somewhat changed due to his last post and a second iso, and with that, my read on you too.

[Luffy]

Agree with petapan, Ellibereth is town. Well, probably. Placing him there for now.

I'll be pretty mad if the CC wagon turns out to be like the moneybags one. "Oh let's lynch CC", and then everyone sheeps into the wagon. Though I am contemplating whether to actually join it or now, because it seems a bit better than the moneybags one. As I said before, anyone who votes in the same post as they say "I'm still catching up" is either dull, psycho, or scum. But I'll keep an eye on there for now.

In other news, can we please get an UberNinja or T-bone lynch in? I actually prefer T-bone now to UberNinja, mainly because what I said before concerning the moneybags lynch. So without further ado:

UNVOTE:
VOTE: T-bone

I'll be pretty happy to take arms against UN again, but I really feel it dying down, both on the thread and inside myself. But if someone wants to spark it up again, I definitely won't mind.

[callforjudgement]

Vote Count

• Captain Corporal (8)
  : Ellibereth PeregrineV BBmolla Muffin Wednesday petapan YYR Elmo TeH AzN SpyreX
  
• T-Bone (5)
  : theamatuer TheTrollie Amrun Captain Corporal Luffy
  
• Milk (3)
  : Trevor dramonic Staeg
  
• SpyreX (3)
  : Milk Hoopla TeChNoWC
  
• UberNinja (3)
  : Chevre T-Bone redFF
  
• BBmolla (1)
  : MattP
  
• Fritzler (1)
  : UberNinja
  
• Muffin Wednesday (1)
  : Zdenek
  
• petapan (1)
  : syndromeofadown
  
• TeChNoWC (1)
  : imaginality
  
• Not voting:
  callforjudgement Chronopie Fritzler funkybike1 Kairyuu Lupo manho Mastermind of Sin Nobody Special Rhinox Robotnick2 SleepyKrew sykedoc Zajnet zoraster

With 42 alive it is 10 to lynch.

[callforjudgement]

This Captain Corporal wagon is ridiculous; and for reasons unrelated to the Corporal himself. I've just been rereading the thread (after sleeping in all morning) to update the vote count, and what really stood out to me was the way that all the most recent votes on the wagon have been unexplained and looked more like trolling than anything else.

VOTE: SpyreX
Elmo's and SpyreX's votes are just as bad, but SpyreX's wagon is bigger.