I just don't see Aqua as scum. Granted, I didn't see Saki as the Tracker, either.
Posted: Sun Aug 11, 2013 11:19 am
by Bert
You're still thinking TNE?
Posted: Sun Aug 11, 2013 11:20 am
by DoctorPepper
I am surprised to see that i survived today.
FSnake is cleared.
GiF, why did you kill Saki? I would have assumed you thought he was a PR after he hammered with an L-1 statement before to look like a quickhammer, like in that newbie game.
In post 1002, DoctorPepper wrote:GiF, why did you kill Saki? I would have assumed you thought he was a PR after he hammered with an L-1 statement before to look like a quickhammer, like in that newbie game.
because I was compulsive and I didn't know who you were gonna jail and I wanted to make my kill count.
Also I had no clue Saki was a PR
Posted: Sun Aug 11, 2013 11:34 am
by GuyInFreezer
Oh. Also Saki kill was complete diceroll between {Saki/TNE/Sakura}
In post 784, Saki wrote:hey guys I claim two shot deathless dayvig
Well, weighed dice actually <.< (Just to make sure)
Posted: Sun Aug 11, 2013 11:38 am
by Bert
I'll help you all lynch TNE for sure (or maybe Sakura - who I have no confidence reading) if you'll shoot Aqua or lynch him tomorrow lol
Posted: Sun Aug 11, 2013 11:39 am
by GuyInFreezer
Can only shoot in even night bby
Posted: Sun Aug 11, 2013 11:39 am
by Bert
And Fuzzy, it's a strong gut read for Aqua from when I re-read the game during Night 1. And it was reinforced Day 2. You can read one of toxic's posts or even FSnake's where they have made cases on Aqua
and Aww GIF
Posted: Sun Aug 11, 2013 11:42 am
by GuyInFreezer
The fact that DP is still alive leans toward that the last scum is a newer player :<
Posted: Sun Aug 11, 2013 11:43 am
by Bert
And Aquaman joined on the 29th of July.....
Posted: Sun Aug 11, 2013 11:44 am
by GuyInFreezer
Let's do this, then.
VOTE: Aquaman
Posted: Sun Aug 11, 2013 11:47 am
by Sakura Hana
Sure thing VOTE: Aquaman
@Bert: My most recent scum game just finished with a win, if you're interested on checking it.
Posted: Sun Aug 11, 2013 11:55 am
by DoctorPepper
I think that makes sense. It could be toxic or aqua.
I'll vote after a VC
Posted: Sun Aug 11, 2013 12:47 pm
by fuzzybutternut
Meh. If it helps. VOTE: Aqua
Posted: Sun Aug 11, 2013 1:35 pm
by EspeciallyTheLies
Aquaman (4) L-1:
Bert, GuyInFreezer, Sakura Hana, fuzzybutternut
GuyInFreezer (1):
DoctorPepper
Not Voting:
FSnake, toxic-banana, Aquaman, thenewearth
With 9 alive, it's 5 to lynch.
The deadline for Day 3 is Sunday, August 25, 2013 at 16:15 EST which is in (expired on 2013-08-25 16:15:00).
[/area]
Posted: Sun Aug 11, 2013 2:02 pm
by toxic-banana
Noooo SAKI my favourite firebrand!
...but I can't say the same for Timeater. Things should run a bit more smoothly here.
Anyways, let me iso Aqua and see what's up there. Are we sure we want to end the day so quickly?
Posted: Sun Aug 11, 2013 2:04 pm
by thenewearth
Ok so everyone whom I said was town was scum
And everyone who I said scum was town.
You know what, I'll just sheep bert =w=
Intent hammer and whatever
Posted: Sun Aug 11, 2013 2:04 pm
by fuzzybutternut
heyheyheyhey. I said you were scum too. >.> still do.
Posted: Sun Aug 11, 2013 2:06 pm
by toxic-banana
Yuck, check out these posts:
In post 657, Aquaman wrote:From what little of Rach's posts there are, it does feel like she's lightly coaching Toxic. Between that and their mutual townreads, I think Toxic's probably scum. After that, I'm thinking the last scum is probably one of Sakura or TNE. But first things first:
Vote: ToxicBanana
In post 663, Aquaman wrote:I think GiF is probably town. Maybe Bert, too, I remember some of his posts felt pretty townish.
Not as suspicious of Saki anymore either. I'm not certain that scum would have pulled what she did with the hammer yesterday, and her posts don't feel as scummy to me in hindsight.
In post 694, FSnake wrote:@Aquaman - what is your general experience with mafia-games. did you play it before off- or online?
I've played on another site before. Their playstyle is pretty different from here, though, and it's been about a year since I've played.
As for Timeater, I skimmed his iso and some of his posts do look really bad, but I think he probably needs to be prodded so he can respond before actually lynching. Looks like he hasn't posted on D2 at all.
It's all so generalized and overcautious...
I especially don't like the Timeater comments. Seem really overcautious for the situation. Holding back on a scum team-mate perhaps?
My gut says scum from these posts, but I don't want to end the day so quickly.
Posted: Sun Aug 11, 2013 2:55 pm
by Bert
Lol I miss Saki and her impulsive quickhammers
I suck at making cases...always a gut reader and nothing much more hahaha oh wait that's why I get lynched as useless as all alignments
ANYWHO...my closing PoE before aforementioned HAMMA (wishful thinking) comes down on Aqua-scumbag...Towniest to least townie
DoctorPepper
- bussing and declaring JKing scum with 1 scum down on D2...town to me
fuzzybutternut, toxic-banana, GuyInFreezer
- pretty town (gut)
FSnake
- jailed by DP and kills went through...probably town...had a little paranoia about this guy in the back of my mind but gut said town, brain said watch out...now with DP's result I feel comfortable with town on him/her
Sakura Hana
- can't read worth anything but ppl say she/he is town
thenewearth
- plays like a wild man (ohey, meet me, Bert-derp) in all games apparently, and Fuzzy says might be scum, and his play has been "scummy" but can't determine if scummy = scum in this case...was in my initial scumread pool during my N1 re-read along with timeater and Aqua...would only lynch this player if Aquaman somehow flips town (doubt it)...all that "SAKI YOU N BERT R SCUM TOGETHER, HI SAKI AKA BUSSER" stuff was so freakin blatant, I doubt it was faked...came off initially as super scummy because it made no sense, but it's hard to tell if this person is avoiding serious play (as scum) by being this way...or just being chatty super wild town
Aquaman
- strongest gut scumread in scumreading histories <3
Posted: Sun Aug 11, 2013 4:40 pm
by FSnake
In post 704, Saki wrote:im inclined to believe sakura is town at this point
was cookies! not saki enough for you
i think saki tracked Sakura D1, but it doesn't clear her. it would make sense to not make the kill N1 and let Timeater do it. but wifom... maybe you should jail her next DP.
i read a scum game where GiF claimed uneven/even tracker as scum, his vig-claim reminds me of that one. if i have time later i will try to find it. is there such a thing as scum-vig?
In post 704, Saki wrote:im inclined to believe sakura is town at this point
was cookies! not saki enough for you
i think saki tracked Sakura D1, but it doesn't clear her. it would make sense to not make the kill N1 and let Timeater do it. but wifom... maybe you should jail her next DP.
i read a scum game where GiF claimed uneven/even tracker as scum, his vig-claim reminds me of that one. if i have time later i will try to find it. is there such a thing as scum-vig?
Aquaman you should claim.
You sure it wasn't one where he claimed Even JOAT? I recall him(I think it was him) doing that.