I've played with a fair few people here before. Of those alive:-
the worst ~ my fav scummer!
Taly ~ know thru sitechat (I live on his head)
Ausuka ~ played with heaps
Chickadee ~ one game + sitechat fave
Iconeum ~ played with heaps
Momrangal ~ played with twice
Srceenplay ~ played with thrice
randomidget ~ we've ..... been in games together
Vaxkiller ~ trolled once as a hydra, was a voice in his head once
TheBrie ~ #teamcyclops2018
Lovebird ~ played with twice
I think Ico and Mom have seen my scumgame first hand, everyone else just town.
If you want a better ref check Gunner Mafia (large theme, just finished). Sorry for being boring here but I really struggle getting invested when there's so many people around, and NEVER get decent reads off setup spec stuff.
Posted: Mon May 07, 2018 1:01 am
by Iconeum
the following players have not used their shot for day 1: Iconeum, randomidget, TheBrie, Archwing, wingedcatgirl
So i'm willing to shoot Screen.
Maybe Brie can take another shot at screen if he survives, otherwise maybe his shot can go to Random?
What do you think?
Posted: Mon May 07, 2018 1:02 am
by the worst
Good thinking. Ot do we vig Arch for replacing out?
¯\(°_o)/¯
Posted: Mon May 07, 2018 1:05 am
by Iconeum
Rather shoot the actual scum in this game
Posted: Mon May 07, 2018 1:06 am
by the worst
Acfually nvm. I like Arch's ISO and I feel bad I never talked to him
pedit: ya well said :/
Posted: Mon May 07, 2018 1:10 am
by Iconeum
Well, I'm gonna use my shot today anyway so might as well
shoot: screen
Posted: Mon May 07, 2018 3:12 am
by Chickadee
In post 1002, the worst wrote:Good thinking. Ot do we vig Arch for replacing out?
¯\(°_o)/¯
Replacing out is NAI, however I rather like his replace out.
Posted: Mon May 07, 2018 4:20 am
by Srceenplay
I was going to shoot light gankski or Taly
Posted: Mon May 07, 2018 4:23 am
by xyzzy
Srceenplay, Echo Bay 1-shot bulletproof citizen, has died.
Posted: Mon May 07, 2018 4:41 am
by Vaxkiller
Random would be a approved shot, and I would like an arch shot too, becuase I feel it would prove some ppl.
Posted: Mon May 07, 2018 4:49 am
by Ausuka
I guess my scumread now would be BBMolla. I don't really buy the PGO claim.
was really town? I'm shocked and a bit sad about that. Sorry X_X...
I'm working to cultivate a stronger readslist and emphasis on my thoughts; I probably won't be getting to it much today because I have 2 finals in the next 2 days.
((And I just got back home from taking one))
My hands are tied at the moment.
Posted: Mon May 07, 2018 6:44 am
by Momrangal
So. I'm scum for having a scum read and taking responsibility for it, basically according to dav.
Also does anyone else think that literally more than half the game =/= most of the game?
More than half the players are dead. But yea, I still dont get what specifically is being referred to.
Posted: Mon May 07, 2018 7:13 am
by Davsto
In post 1019, Momrangal wrote:So. I'm scum for having a scum read and taking responsibility for it, basically according to dav.
This is gross oversimplification and misrepresentation.
Also does anyone else think that literally more than half the game =/= most of the game?
Holy shit I have literally already addressed this and you're changing my words, putting things I haven't said in my mouth.
I
never once
used the phrase "most of the game" referring to how much you'd read before shooting. Not a single fucking time. Go to my ISO and ctrl+f "most" if you don't believe me, anyone else. It's one of the first things I said in my big post. Yet you're
again claiming
I said it.
The word I used was "much", which has considerably different connotations to "most", and I would say that when the game is only 14 pages that not having read it all before shooting is "not reading much" of it.
Posted: Mon May 07, 2018 7:15 am
by Davsto
Seriously for all that is holy someone shoot Mom. They made a bad case against me that I deconstructed in detail, and it (and their most recent post too) is full of misrepresentation, twisting of words, selective reading, the whole works of "what makes a case scummy 101". This needs to die.
In post 570, Taly wrote:Also, I don't think it's known whether or not being BP is AI? I highly doubt it is, so I'm iffy here.
Oh I don't think that BP is alignment indicative independent of other factors. It's just that it counters the main reason for discounting Mom-scum and also makes sense with their actions.
Maybe it's just sorta the fact that my theory for Mom!scum involved them being BP and they turned out BP that's making me see it as a bit of a confirmation so maybe it has the potential to be a little biased. I still think they're scummy regardless. It's just a final little bit that settles it for me yk?
In post 767, StefanB wrote:Davsto: What was the argument again?
Sometimes between back and forth, this is kind of lost.
Can you state clear what this is about for us lazy people.
If you scroll to the bottom of the page there's a little box with the label in front saying "Display posts by user". If you select me in the box, click the little plus sign to the right and then select Momrangel (and then Go) you'll get all of just mine and Mom's posts. That'll give you a better explanation than I really can but I'll attempt anyway
> I think Mom is scummy because she made a quick and lazy shot without even reading the game but also made it clear it was a serious scumread shot. She also has basically not explained a single one of her reads, and her only reasoning for her read on me is stating "IIoA", something which I've explained for various reasons as being invalid yet she largely just brushed it off and ignored it. There are also other minor points.
> Mom thinks I am scummy because ??? and IIoA I guess. After I pointed out she ignored my counter of that, she made a bizarre post where she attempted to defend herself from me but largely formed half-thoughts or even didn't counter anything I said just acknowledged it, and also made several other flawed points that I'll get to tomorrow when I give more of a shit.
Maybe a little biased but in my defence, she is scum.
The second sentence is to statement that I hadn't read "much of the game "
But OK. Who thinks that me getting a scum read at 10 pages in is ridiculous when the game was only 14 pages long at that point.
Moreover what other content could I get from the last four pages that I already did have
