Mafiascum.net

OH YEEEEEAH

Has there been a murder yet?

In post 1002, Bambi Jay wrote:Has there been a murder yet?

You seems to be coasting since page 5, its pretty underwhelming

Whats your confident reads? top trs, srs etc

In post 995, Gamma Emerald wrote:It's called other scum exist, and if Cloudy brings up a good reason to townread you I might take his word
Like the reason I called your content abysmal was to state that tone wasn't going to change my mind without explanation
And again, what about that wall was appealing to others

Hey, with all honesty, it's just that some of his posts are well above average what I expect from an average scum range of someone I don't know about. The post I ^'d was amazing tone wise, I feel like he just genuinely feels like someone who's unjustly fosed/pushed and not in a scummy way.

If you want to see it that way, IMO he ''won'' the exchange with you and he doesn't look like someone with that much experience. On average, using the premise that an unknown slot would not play above average is correct almost everytime, but I have been wrong in the past (on vifam namely, yourself and others) and I also sometimes have a tendency to disregard content in favour of tone alone for random slots (which works most of the time, but as always, sometimes its a huge miss)

But tone wise, his day 1 has some pristine posts and I don't want to lynch them, IMO he will towntell more and people will eventually agree, so take the tr as a blessing for his d1 survival

: are you even going to answer about the fred/myself post, you aren't answering when I brought it up twice

: Can you make a summary read list with your 5 ish most confident reads

In post 155, thecoldheartedking wrote:I didn't think it was possible to have four reads in six pages. I'm so proud of you guys.

VOTE: Rautherdir

Baa.

Can you go on about your reads when you come back

I can vaguely see what you're saying Cloudy but I'm still not sure, like you say it feels like someone who feels unjustly pushed but I don't see that.
But I also think I can agree with the idea of leaving him to post more and seeing what happens
VOTE: MariaR though because I stand by the fact this isn't how town!Maria approaches me at all

In post 1006, Gamma Emerald wrote:I can vaguely see what you're saying Cloudy but I'm still not sure, like you say it feels like someone who feels unjustly pushed but I don't see that.
But I also think I can agree with the idea of leaving him to post more and seeing what happens
VOTE: MariaR though because I stand by the fact this isn't how town!Maria approaches me at all

It is not tesxtbook scum!mariar either, I think she's just purposefully trying to not AI tell at all, she's being opaque.

That being said, I have played with her in years & with any of you either, did her scum play changes?
How about your play gamma, I want to include you in my town circle but I recall having misread you in the past even if you strike me playing different and better this game than the one I mistownread you in

I don't know if her scum play changed but aside from the dance game we both played I don't think I've ever failed to catch MariaR as scum and we both have a good record of reading each other, and even when MariaR is scumreading me as town I don't recall her ever pushing me this single-mindedly, but I do recall she did this once a long time ago as scum.
As for myself I don't know which specific game you misread me in so I can't say too well what you should expect

CK I've been playing Forum Mafia since like 2010 and just got done winning a towngame for everyone respect ur elders bub

In post 1009, unwnd wrote:CK I've been playing Forum Mafia since like 2010 and just got done winning a towngame for everyone respect ur elders bub

Okay then i retract my read on you, either you answer the dichotomy post in your next post or i will be parking my vote on you

In post 1008, Gamma Emerald wrote:I don't know if her scum play changed but aside from the dance game we both played I don't think I've ever failed to catch MariaR as scum and we both have a good record of reading each other, and even when MariaR is scumreading me as town I don't recall her ever pushing me this single-mindedly, but I do recall she did this once a long time ago as scum.
As for myself I don't know which specific game you misread me in so I can't say too well what you should expect

I think it was the game you had a great single post that I townread pretty hard, along with A50. I fakeclaimed mason w/ kokichi as VT and i was under Joey_

In post 1007, CloudKicker wrote:

In post 1006, Gamma Emerald wrote:I can vaguely see what you're saying Cloudy but I'm still not sure, like you say it feels like someone who feels unjustly pushed but I don't see that.
But I also think I can agree with the idea of leaving him to post more and seeing what happens
VOTE: MariaR though because I stand by the fact this isn't how town!Maria approaches me at all

It is not tesxtbook scum!mariar either, I think she's just purposefully trying to not AI tell at all, she's being opaque.

That being said, I have played with her in years & with any of you either, did her scum play changes?
How about your play gamma, I want to include you in my town circle but I recall having misread you in the past even if you strike me playing different and better this game than the one I mistownread you in

FWIW I think there's a non-zero chance MariaR/GE is scum theatre. I would be incredibly impressed/depressed/freshly pressed if neither slot flipped scum.

Scum theater ? They basically mentionned each-other and voted w/ no case at all, nothing that has been done between those 2 slots even points that they are non-scum together

I'm leaning town on CloudKicker, they do appear to be doing sorting, though I'd appreciate if they gave in-depth reads at some point.
I kind of doubt that MariaR is scum on reason of the possibly-not-real-posting restriction, I have faked a posting restriction as scum before and this doesn't look like that sort of thing. (At least I personally would not commit to that in-depth of a posting restriction unless I actually had to) There's also the chance MariaR is doing it for fun, but that would honestly be NAI. Her actual content though... I'm not really able to tell if she's town or scum (or third party), she can be resolved later.
KidAmn is... maybe town maybe scum. Some of their logic doesn't really work but I'm not sure if that's just wrong conclusions or misconstruing on their part. I'll do an in-depth read of them later and see what I can figure out.
I'll go ahead and again say that I'm aligned with town.
Celestial Coordinates is probably town, their progression generally matches town!Radiant (Though I'm not sure if Nancy has posted much or not, I don't remember how their posting feels.)
Omochao is currently null due to being on V/LA with no posts of content to read.
RCS is a lean-town for me. They have done sorting on people, but not much. I don't see anything suspect about them though either.
Bambi Jay, well first of all thanks for getting this game out of RVS. That doesn't necessarily make you town though, and you're later content isn't really that good either. I do get more of a 'I just want to get past day 1' vibe from them though instead of anything malicious. Will be able to better sort on a later day.
Gamma I'm not sure about. I'll do an in-depth read later and see if I can uncover anything.

In post 1014, Rautherdir wrote:though I'd appreciate if they gave in-depth reads at some point.

Its done purposefully, im not playing cards on table just yet

Understandable. I would have done that, but uh... I'd rather be alive to give better reads later then get quick-lynched day 1.

Chemist1422, I don't really see much from you yet. I'll be able to give a better read of him later on in day 1.
Fred the Cat. Even if you are an alt for a certain person I've decided not to give that any attention, the point of the alt would probably have been to get away from that. It would be appreciated if you could give reads on people instead of sheeping though. (I know it's day 1, but there is actually stuff to read from most everyone at this point.)
RedPanda, I don't see very much open reasoning about your reads, that would be more helpful then just saying whether you think a person is town or not. That said, you are giving reads, and appear to be interacting with others to build them. A town-lean for now, I can evaluate you better later on in day 1.
WhemeStar. First of all you're horrifyingly difficult to read. I can tell you're sorting people but I'm not sure if that's just keeping up appearances or not. I would wait and see if he can be sorted better in a later day.

Vifam, could you explain why the unwnd wagon is bad? You do appear to be doing sorting, I'll mostly leave you to it for now. Will be sorted later.

thecoldheartedking is awaiting replacement and I don't know them well enough to make a read based on their existing content. Will sort later.
Primate is currently null. Joined in with mechanics talk at the beginning, then that question which threw me off because WHY didn't you just ask if I was third party or not if that's what you were looking for. I'll read you better later, you have stuff to work on from me now.
Sakura Hana is probably town. I'd appreciate more content from you though, and you've mostly been sheeping. (Again, even though it's day 1 there is enough content to actually do some scum hunting now.)
Dunnstral is probably town. They've been doing quite a bit of sorting and while he's not always open with his reads I can tell he's developing them.
unwnd is... lean-town right now? I think they'll be easier read later, though I'm not sure if I like how they appear to be openly pacing themselves or not. They have been doing some hunting, I just really am not sure about their current tactics.

I'll get back into this again later to do actual reads on KidAmn and Gamma.

It's not that there's no content to do scumhunting is more of a i dont have time atm to do it properly plus my strength is finding town.

In post 1017, Rautherdir wrote:Chemist1422, I don't really see much from you yet. I'll be able to give a better read of him later on in day 1.
Fred the Cat. Even if you are an alt for a certain person I've decided not to give that any attention, the point of the alt would probably have been to get away from that. It would be appreciated if you could give reads on people instead of sheeping though. (I know it's day 1, but there is actually stuff to read from most everyone at this point.)
RedPanda, I don't see very much open reasoning about your reads, that would be more helpful then just saying whether you think a person is town or not. That said, you are giving reads, and appear to be interacting with others to build them. A town-lean for now, I can evaluate you better later on in day 1.
WhemeStar. First of all you're horrifyingly difficult to read. I can tell you're sorting people but I'm not sure if that's just keeping up appearances or not. I would wait and see if he can be sorted better in a later day.

Vifam, could you explain why the unwnd wagon is bad? You do appear to be doing sorting, I'll mostly leave you to it for now. Will be sorted later.

thecoldheartedking is awaiting replacement and I don't know them well enough to make a read based on their existing content. Will sort later.
Primate is currently null. Joined in with mechanics talk at the beginning, then that question which threw me off because WHY didn't you just ask if I was third party or not if that's what you were looking for. I'll read you better later, you have stuff to work on from me now.
Sakura Hana is probably town. I'd appreciate more content from you though, and you've mostly been sheeping. (Again, even though it's day 1 there is enough content to actually do some scum hunting now.)
Dunnstral is probably town. They've been doing quite a bit of sorting and while he's not always open with his reads I can tell he's developing them.
unwnd is... lean-town right now? I think they'll be easier read later, though I'm not sure if I like how they appear to be openly pacing themselves or not. They have been doing some hunting, I just really am not sure about their current tactics.

I'll get back into this again later to do actual reads on KidAmn and Gamma.

Don't you have any srs?

In post 1005, CloudKicker wrote:

In post 155, thecoldheartedking wrote:I didn't think it was possible to have four reads in six pages. I'm so proud of you guys.

VOTE: Rautherdir

Baa.

Can you go on about your reads when you come back

He’s getting replaced

In post 1017, Rautherdir wrote:WhemeStar. First of all you're horrifyingly difficult to read.

Haha thanks I try

In post 1013, CloudKicker wrote:Scum theater ? They basically mentionned each-other and voted w/ no case at all, nothing that has been done between those 2 slots even points that they are non-scum together

If you think this is scum theatre between me and Maria then you're wrong, we've done that before and it was not like this
Also ah, got it about the game, yeah I did really try my hardest that game which made my crash and burn really fucking painful

In post 1022, Gamma Emerald wrote:

In post 1013, CloudKicker wrote:Scum theater ? They basically mentionned each-other and voted w/ no case at all, nothing that has been done between those 2 slots even points that they are non-scum together

If you think this is scum theatre between me and Maria then you're wrong, we've done that before and it was not like this
Also ah, got it about the game, yeah I did really try my hardest that game which made my crash and burn really fucking painful

Thats what im saying, this isn't scum theatre as in, it doesn't even gives tells about associations because both stances are way too shallow

Felt a bit forced from Rauth but maybe a victim of the covering all posters format.

I don't think Unwnd is scummy. I thought he had a specific tone that could be seen that way but he's got it in his other games too.

MariaR was the main one that rumpletumple comment was about. There's people saying about the PR that it means this or that because it's her and I just really have to take it at face value. Personally I thinks she's been a little basic in content but it's not overly concerning me.

VOTE: Gamma Emerald

Think BambiJay is scummy too.