Page 41 of 310
Posted: Tue Apr 07, 2020 4:10 pm
by Wonderwalll
Ehh you’re not being obnoxious
We just think you’re quite likely to be scum although we feel more strongly on jjh
Posted: Tue Apr 07, 2020 4:15 pm
by Shuichi Saihara
In post 984, Wonderwalll wrote:Ali hasn’t commented on this but I also think him not understanding who you meant by firemapoka is +town for him as I think he’d check that in scum pt instead of comment on how it’s weird to have a read on that slot when they haven’t posted in thread
People suggest this often, but I think it's pretty easy to conclude that it's a safe thing to post.
In post 989, Trojan Horses wrote: In post 439, mastina wrote:SirCakez is also pretty damn painfully obviously town. His contributions, his analysis, his thoughts, his process, his aura, everything he is doing, pushing, just feels like it is in the right mindset, where even if his reads/reasons aren't right, their sincerity and genuineness means it's probably not from him as scum. Admittedly, he's a strong scum player, but I just don't think what he's doing is him as scum.
Mastina, I'd like you to elaborate on this read. Seeing as most of the game finds him obvtown I might be wrong and just not seeing it, but can you actually show sincerity/genuineness in his posts that's not trivially faked by scum? Can you put his mindset into words and show me how that's very likely to be a town one?
If you have played with mastina before you should know that she cannot. But even if she weren't physically incapable of explanation, this would seem like a tall order.
In post 993, Wonderwalll wrote:You know cakez a lot of your posts are making me just want to *yawn* you in response
Is this disaffection or a parody thereof?
Posted: Tue Apr 07, 2020 4:37 pm
by jjh927
I think I need to read some pages of this and put some reads down
But I'm not doing that rn I'm going to bed
Posted: Tue Apr 07, 2020 4:38 pm
by jjh927
Oh yeah I think I needed to say Wonderwall is town because of chasing RC down on that shit he accused me of at some point but I don't remember who asked me
Posted: Tue Apr 07, 2020 4:38 pm
by Trojan Horses
In post 998, Shuichi Saihara wrote:Okay but that wasn't really true either.
And what made them difficult to read if not density?
I don't think this point is super important but I do think it's bizarre.
Did you stop sheeping mastina before or after it was pointed out that scum might do this?
Perhaps your quote walls where you had many one-liner replies which didn't really say anything <- which I termed fluff.
Lol no, I stopped sheeping mastina when I started pursuing my own leads. I know Mastina could do that as scum.
I still however did like her explanations at that point of time for a number of slots, even if they were feeble and off one post.
I had assumed non-posters were in her null pile and didn't notice she was weak townreading non-posters till that was pointed out in thread.
As a note, she hasn't appeared yet and she should respond to the question about your placement on her list.
Even if she cannot put her mindset into words, I want to see her attempt at doing so.
Posted: Tue Apr 07, 2020 4:39 pm
by Trojan Horses
If you're Cephrir I like this style of posting more than what I've seen before, though.
Posted: Tue Apr 07, 2020 4:40 pm
by Shuichi Saihara
I guess my posts must be difficult to read, since you don't appear to have read them.
Posted: Tue Apr 07, 2020 4:42 pm
by Shuichi Saihara
Right but like when was that.
Posted: Tue Apr 07, 2020 5:06 pm
by Baezu
In post 989, Trojan Horses wrote: In post 439, mastina wrote:SirCakez is also pretty damn painfully obviously town. His contributions, his analysis, his thoughts, his process, his aura, everything he is doing, pushing, just feels like it is in the right mindset, where even if his reads/reasons aren't right, their sincerity and genuineness means it's probably not from him as scum. Admittedly, he's a strong scum player, but I just don't think what he's doing is him as scum.
Mastina, I'd like you to elaborate on this read. Seeing as most of the game finds him obvtown I might be wrong and just not seeing it, but can you actually show sincerity/genuineness in his posts that's not trivially faked by scum? Can you put his mindset into words and show me how that's very likely to be a town one?
If Mastina is town as a lot of people seem to think wouldn't this point to her distancing from cake therefore cake scum?
Posted: Tue Apr 07, 2020 5:08 pm
by Baezu
In post 1008, Baezu wrote: In post 989, Trojan Horses wrote: In post 439, mastina wrote:SirCakez is also pretty damn painfully obviously town. His contributions, his analysis, his thoughts, his process, his aura, everything he is doing, pushing, just feels like it is in the right mindset, where even if his reads/reasons aren't right, their sincerity and genuineness means it's probably not from him as scum. Admittedly, he's a strong scum player, but I just don't think what he's doing is him as scum.
Mastina, I'd like you to elaborate on this read. Seeing as most of the game finds him obvtown I might be wrong and just not seeing it, but can you actually show sincerity/genuineness in his posts that's not trivially faked by scum? Can you put his mindset into words and show me how that's very likely to be a town one?
If Mastina is scum as a lot of people seem to think wouldn't this point to her distancing from cake therefore cake scum?
Posted: Tue Apr 07, 2020 5:09 pm
by Lie Ren
Well that wasn't what I expected. If that's what I think it's supposed to mean you actually figured out who I am already. Might as well just say it, this is Gamma Emerald. I wanted to see how I played as an alt if I embraced the tendency to not do as much in alt games. In addition I mentioned wanting to play a way I normally don't, that's in reference to my experience in Perfect Masquerade, where I enjoyed playing as a hidden alt in that game, as well as writing posts in a more "proper" manner compared to what I normally do.
Now although I did enjoy that jape, I must kindly refuse that avatar because I would like to have one of the character this alt is named after. I'll continue skimming to see if one was posted in the thread, and if not I'll find one myself because I'm on a device where I can do that rather seamlessly right now.
Posted: Tue Apr 07, 2020 5:13 pm
by Lie Ren
In post 857, BBmolla wrote: In post 766, Lie Ren wrote:
I can tell this is going to be annoying.
And I will get an avatar if I can find one I like. If someone cares to help out they can be Day 1 masons with me.
You obviously don't watch RWBY.
Just to make things clear by the way, this is just me skimming to find if a usable avatar was posted, I'll analyze the content from where I left off after dealing with the avatar situation.
Posted: Tue Apr 07, 2020 5:21 pm
by Shuichi Saihara
In post 1010, Lie Ren wrote:
Well that wasn't what I expected. If that's what I think it's supposed to mean you actually figured out who I am already. Might as well just say it, this is Gamma Emerald. I wanted to see how I played as an alt if I embraced the tendency to not do as much in alt games. In addition I mentioned wanting to play a way I normally don't, that's in reference to my experience in Perfect Masquerade, where I enjoyed playing as a hidden alt in that game, as well as writing posts in a more "proper" manner compared to what I normally do.
Now although I did enjoy that jape, I must kindly refuse that avatar because I would like to have one of the character this alt is named after. I'll continue skimming to see if one was posted in the thread, and if not I'll find one myself because I'm on a device where I can do that rather seamlessly right now.
Oh, that's funny. Nice one nsg.
Posted: Tue Apr 07, 2020 5:39 pm
by Lie Ren
Explain why you say buddies, plural? I get that the 4 scum are all together but in my mind I would only consider the scum in the same game a "buddy", the others re just associates as I see it. Plus you only need to find 2 scum to win. This game works somewhat like Red Flag except probably way harder for scum, as I see it.
Also when it comes to being my Day 1 mason, NSG made me smile with her keen alt hunting so she wins that contest. I will contest any proposed lynch on her for Day 1 of her game.
Posted: Tue Apr 07, 2020 5:44 pm
by Lie Ren
In post 365, gobbledygook wrote:With amount of people townreading me I feel like people are just setting me up to die n1 and feels bad man
Has that happened a lot recently? Before I left I didn't recall you being an exceptional player, did you become more of a strong town presence after I left?
Posted: Tue Apr 07, 2020 5:49 pm
by Lie Ren
In post 385, SirCakez wrote:Trojan Horses wrote:
It's a gut read
you're dirty for this
VOTE: jormun
I want to shake this tree. I feel his pop-in and pop-out earlier without dropping any content were scummy af and everyone ignored it mostly
I could be talked into agreeing with this, go into it more? I recall RC also called Jormungand "outed scum" around the time I was posting and am curious what that was about.
Posted: Tue Apr 07, 2020 5:53 pm
by Lie Ren
On Page 16, while I think WANH is town, if I had a day vigilante shot I might shoot them just to silence Firebringer because he is obnoxious this game.
Posted: Tue Apr 07, 2020 6:04 pm
by SirCakez
In post 1000, Wonderwalll wrote:Ehh you’re not being obnoxious
We just think you’re quite likely to be scum although we feel more strongly on jjh
Ok I can accept this
Lie Even - that Jormun stuff is pretty old. Right now there's a debate as to whether they really are scum who's really scummy or potentially lynchbait noob town
Posted: Tue Apr 07, 2020 6:04 pm
by SirCakez
Lie Ren*
Stupid autocorrect
Posted: Tue Apr 07, 2020 6:45 pm
by Lie Ren
I personally disagree. I think there'd be a much different game direction if he were scum. Like, he's feeling like he's genuinely sorting at this point and it doesn't feel like an attempt to dictate the game.
I'll probably be checking out soon, but I'll try to reach Page 20 before tapping out for the night.
Posted: Tue Apr 07, 2020 6:55 pm
by Lie Ren
This is exactly what I was thinking about asking.
Posted: Tue Apr 07, 2020 6:58 pm
by Lie Ren
In post 508, mastina wrote:Oh yeah, definitely. Like, I can get more scummy later in the game as town if I have a massive mental health dive, massive physical dive in availabilty, am around less, am motivated less, etc., but like. Almost every single game I get more and more obviously town as town the later the game goes and more and more obviously scum as scum the later the game goes.
Could you go into why you think your alignment becomes clearer the further along the game gets?
Anyway, gonna tap out but won't be completely off-site for a little bit.
Posted: Tue Apr 07, 2020 8:59 pm
by BBmolla
In post 1010, Lie Ren wrote:
Well that wasn't what I expected. If that's what I think it's supposed to mean you actually figured out who I am already. Might as well just say it, this is Gamma Emerald. I wanted to see how I played as an alt if I embraced the tendency to not do as much in alt games. In addition I mentioned wanting to play a way I normally don't, that's in reference to my experience in Perfect Masquerade, where I enjoyed playing as a hidden alt in that game, as well as writing posts in a more "proper" manner compared to what I normally do.
Now although I did enjoy that jape, I must kindly refuse that avatar because I would like to have one of the character this alt is named after. I'll continue skimming to see if one was posted in the thread, and if not I'll find one myself because I'm on a device where I can do that rather seamlessly right now.
lul
unsurprised that Trojan doesn't townread me
Posted: Tue Apr 07, 2020 9:01 pm
by BBmolla
In post 1014, Lie Ren wrote: In post 365, gobbledygook wrote:With amount of people townreading me I feel like people are just setting me up to die n1 and feels bad man
Has that happened a lot recently? Before I left I didn't recall you being an exceptional player, did you become more of a strong town presence after I left?
yo if you talking shit about my boy gobbles I'll throw down, he single handedly was wrecking scum in Chkflip's large before getting culted
Posted: Tue Apr 07, 2020 9:04 pm
by BBmolla
Seriously Christmas get the fuck in here I can't do anything if its just me and Gobbles posting fuck
