Posted: Sun Jun 14, 2020 5:22 am
I guess it was Hoopla who said it the best this game?
VOTE: PranaDevil
VOTE: PranaDevil
What do your orange reads represent exactly?In post 997, UnaBombaH wrote:My reads so far have been dismissed more or less, and I guess I've deserved that with my own posting then.
Like I said earlier this game, and I've said many many times in other situations as well - I think that if enough people vote to lynch me, there's something wrong with MY play as well.
That being said, I'm disappointed for not having a votecount of my wagon at it's latest peak.
I am very confident there were 1-2 scum on me at the time CoolDog joined as well.
My top guesses for scum would have to be amongstgobbledygook, Klick, CoolDogONthe wagon (1-2 there), andPranaoff the wagon with that latest post.
These are my top4 scumreads, and while I'm not saying there's literally the full team in there, I wouldn't be surprised to find 2.
Guess I gotta misread someone as town..
I truly believeGypyxis noobtown, andEmperorFlippynipsis doing Flippynips-things.
Not feeling as confident about them because some of their posts still rub me the wrong way, but wouldn't consider them too scummy either.
AGarandHirakiare likely my top townreads, and I do not see either of them being scum this game.
BobandBattlemageare both slots that have had replacements, right?
Neither has taken a solid stance on me or Gobbledy as far as I know?
I think both of them should, and if they have, I apologise for missing it.
These slots are both in the middle for me simply because I haven't got an idea on which way to lean on them yet.
Hooplaandnotscienceare the hardest slots for me to sort right now.
I have this unnatural gutfeel and read on Hoopla being town here, and yet I do not feel my usual paranoia whenever I get one of these as early as D1.
notscience isn't "null" in the sense that I can't find anything alignment indicative about them, but more so because they have managed to come across scummy to me in the start, and yet look more towny as the game progressed. And still, I do not like the position they have amongst my scumreads, which keeps them from getting that green color in my eyes..
I guess these are as far as I can push myself slotting people D1.
So you wanted this response before doing stuff notscience, but instead of engaging with it you're just going to push a different lynch through and leave your Una townread super vague?In post 957, Klick wrote:I feel like CooLDoG is on another planet when it comes to his view of optimal town play. I do feel like his perception of the game is complex enough that it's probably not fake though. His Hoopla read is easy, but some of his peripheral comments have felt genuine (see 602 and my thoughts on it earlier).In post 878, notscience wrote:One trend from Cooldog’s gameplay I’ve noticed thus far (149) is it seems very integral on optimal townplay- which is both good and bad. On the one hand it makes his life (if scum) harder, but it allows pretty easy reads to hide behind too.
I feel like I have the same 'optimal play' criticism of AGar though. And reading further into your read-through you seem to feel the same way. Except I don't see the same depth of play from AGar that I do from CooLDoG.
I don't really understand your Hiraki townread beyond 'I agree with what he's saying a lot'. You mention 411, but I don't think I agree that that couldn't come from scum. It was approached from a removed perspective similarly to how Hoopla presented it, almost academically, and feels a bit like busy work to me. From someone who has continually said 'why does this matter?' I question why he felt the need to go in-depth at that particular moment. The motives of the post itself were to question why my slot was read as town, which for obvious reasons doesn't inspire me with confidence.
I'd be fine-ish with a Prana wagon starting up. I have problems with the amount of words he's produced versus the actual content he's provided. I do feel like this slot could sort itself given time though, and he's BoP'd himself into giving us more in later days. Bellaphant (my IRL fiancee) plays almost identically to this, so that could be making me give him the benefit of the doubt. But I think there are better options for a lynch today.
I don't agree with your Una townread. Equally, I don't see that much to respond to? This read doesn't feel concrete. I think it's possible that you're seeing 'quirky' and reading 'genuine' into it. It's worth noting that a lot of what you wind up townreading Una for is his interaction with gobble (and I thought I had a point in pointing this out, but I can no longer remember why... Oh well, I'll leave it and maybe you'll get something from it?)
It seems like those are our main points of contention? Neither of us seems to feel super strongly about Battle Mage, though we lean different ways.
What about that implies town to you?In post 977, Gypyx wrote:I have you as leantown currenrly even though i didn't like renaissance's playstyle, what bugged me about the wagon is that it was sort of "there" for a long time, no one seemed to be against it but yet it never took off until now, i'm reading this as una being town
And why does your wagon analysis take precedence over what you see as valid points against Una?I have to admit you got some very valid points on Una, i'm waiting to see una's reaction to your vote though
What happened to the townbloc being your scumpool/where you wanted to lynch today?In post 997, UnaBombaH wrote:My top guesses for scum would have to be amongst gobbledygook, Klick, CoolDog ON the wagon (1-2 there), and Prana off the wagon with that latest post.
These are my top4 scumreads, and while I'm not saying there's literally the full team in there, I wouldn't be surprised to find 2.
excellent, I am on bored!In post 1001, UnaBombaH wrote:L-2 apparently- be aware about this potentially being false since official votecount hasn't been given in a while.
brunch me daddy!In post 1009, notscience wrote:I haven’t had the chance to read in depth yet bc it’s hella walls
We’re out getting brunch I intended to read this morning but surprise last minute plans
I'm pretty sure I said Gobbledy was conftown...let me ISO myself to refresh my memory...In post 997, UnaBombaH wrote:My reads so far have been dismissed more or less, and I guess I've deserved that with my own posting then.
Like I said earlier this game, and I've said many many times in other situations as well - I think that if enough people vote to lynch me, there's something wrong with MY play as well.
That being said, I'm disappointed for not having a votecount of my wagon at it's latest peak.
I am very confident there were 1-2 scum on me at the time CoolDog joined as well.
My top guesses for scum would have to be amongstgobbledygook, Klick, CoolDogONthe wagon (1-2 there), andPranaoff the wagon with that latest post.
These are my top4 scumreads, and while I'm not saying there's literally the full team in there, I wouldn't be surprised to find 2.
Guess I gotta misread someone as town..
I truly believeGypyxis noobtown, andEmperorFlippynipsis doing Flippynips-things.
Not feeling as confident about them because some of their posts still rub me the wrong way, but wouldn't consider them too scummy either.
AGarandHirakiare likely my top townreads, and I do not see either of them being scum this game.
BobandBattlemageare both slots that have had replacements, right?
Neither has taken a solid stance on me or Gobbledy as far as I know?
I think both of them should, and if they have, I apologise for missing it.
These slots are both in the middle for me simply because I haven't got an idea on which way to lean on them yet.
Hooplaandnotscienceare the hardest slots for me to sort right now.
I have this unnatural gutfeel and read on Hoopla being town here, and yet I do not feel my usual paranoia whenever I get one of these as early as D1.
notscience isn't "null" in the sense that I can't find anything alignment indicative about them, but more so because they have managed to come across scummy to me in the start, and yet look more towny as the game progressed. And still, I do not like the position they have amongst my scumreads, which keeps them from getting that green color in my eyes..
I guess these are as far as I can push myself slotting people D1.
BAH, you're no fun!In post 1015, notscience wrote:Yeah but I’m not chill with lolhammers
This is me!In post 989, notscience wrote:The wagon for prana is taking all applicants who think the other wagons are bad, we thank you for your consideration in these trying times and hope you decide to join our righteous wagon.In post 975, Emperor flippyNips wrote:I’m still around. I would like to iso una but I’m not gonna be around tomorrow. Currently I’m still not on board for a gobble or una kill, I liked my last interactions with NS I got decent vibes from him. Other than that I’m at a loss for who I want to vote. I like where I am now. I really have no clue who else could be scum
Lunch or brunch? Do you have a food based post restriction?In post 996, notscience wrote:You know if you’re town you could help us lunch that scum candidate
then how come you said lunch here, before you said brunch? Something doesn't add up!In post 1020, notscience wrote:We are ending up with lunch but it was supposed to be brunch but we were having transport issues so now it’s lunch