Mafiascum.net

In post 10174, MURDERCAT wrote:Kinda goes against the whole theme though

Well technically the scroll holders were like temp treestumps but I see your point. I think if Noraa had shot Bellon the first scroll, it would have worked.

Do people want my take on the players this game or would prefer I not.

I want to hear your take on me at least

OwO

In post 4039, PookyTheMagicalBear wrote:

In post 4028, Noraa wrote:This isnt a game of "who has the best reads, big ego pooky or big ego murder"

MC why is this a scum-slip? :3

In post 4041, MURDERCAT wrote:

In post 4039, PookyTheMagicalBear wrote:

In post 4028, Noraa wrote:This isnt a game of "who has the best reads, big ego pooky or big ego murder"

MC why is this a scum-slip? :3

You see Noraa, it assumes that Pooky and I are both town. I believe you are scum reading Pooky though, is that correct?

Wait a second

In post 10179, MURDERCAT wrote:Wait a second

lmfao it wasn't really a scum slip cuz I'd say it as town too but u can view it as that if u want.

Yeah I still agree

Funny in retrospect though

Did u both tie because u both only got 2 scum

when I saw those day 1 solves, I legitimately was like huh WTF is this a reaction test or something?

4 MORE POST!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Which two did Pooky list?

In post 10185, MURDERCAT wrote:Which two did Pooky list?

don't remember.

noraa was the only one I got right :3

When do I get my scummy nom

In post 10187, PookyTheMagicalBear wrote:noraa was the only one I got right :3

RIP. nvm then murder won.
2:1

In post 10188, MURDERCAT wrote:When do I get my scummy nom

*writes down* Murder played an amazing game where he nailed 2 scum on day 1 :O

1500 posts!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

In post 10160, MURDERCAT wrote:At the risk of interrupting Noraa, what did you think of how the setup played out Hectic? In theory, would you make any changes if you ran it again?
I thought I agreed with Isis that it might be a bit town sided. But the power of getting a wolf into the town block is evident.
Maybe the dayvig is actually a bit hard to use in practice?

I think it's a little townsided. It's too close to nightless and scum on average only get 2.66 nightkills (4 deaths * 2/3 chance to be first in first two passes). The vig sounds nice in theory, but if you use it super early to snipe an obvtown leader, you make it twice as difficult for 1 scum to win all the way down the line in final 5 (which turns into 4).

I think an adjustment in having scrolled players immediately treestumped, but only removed from the game and flipped upon the 3rd pass is good. It means scum win with parity slightly earlier in situations, and makes the dayvig a lot more versatile.

Role PM

Welcome,

Noraa

. You are a

Self-Aligned Hyperposter

!

Win condition:

• You win when your post count exceeds 1500 in the game thread before it is locked.

Game thread is here. Please confirm by telling me your alignment, any partner's names, and acknowledging that the mafia has daytalk.

PEdit: hectic ur a meanie

In post 10193, Hectic wrote:

In post 10160, MURDERCAT wrote:At the risk of interrupting Noraa, what did you think of how the setup played out Hectic? In theory, would you make any changes if you ran it again?
I thought I agreed with Isis that it might be a bit town sided. But the power of getting a wolf into the town block is evident.
Maybe the dayvig is actually a bit hard to use in practice?

I think it's a little townsided. It's too close to nightless and scum on average only get 2.66 nightkills (4 deaths * 2/3 chance to be first in first two passes). The vig sounds nice in theory, but if you use it super early to snipe an obvtown leader, you make it twice as difficult for 1 scum to win all the way down the line in final 5 (which turns into 4).

I think an adjustment in having scrolled players immediately treestumped, but only removed from the game and flipped upon the 3rd pass is good. It means scum win with parity slightly earlier in situations, and makes the dayvig a lot more versatile.

Yeah, that’s kind of what I suggested. Noraa would have absolutely won in that case.

In post 10193, Hectic wrote:

In post 10160, MURDERCAT wrote:At the risk of interrupting Noraa, what did you think of how the setup played out Hectic? In theory, would you make any changes if you ran it again?
I thought I agreed with Isis that it might be a bit town sided. But the power of getting a wolf into the town block is evident.
Maybe the dayvig is actually a bit hard to use in practice?

I think it's a little townsided. It's too close to nightless and scum on average only get 2.66 nightkills (4 deaths * 2/3 chance to be first in first two passes). The vig sounds nice in theory, but if you use it super early to snipe an obvtown leader, you make it twice as difficult for 1 scum to win all the way down the line in final 5 (which turns into 4).

I think an adjustment in having scrolled players immediately treestumped, but only removed from the game and flipped upon the 3rd pass is good. It means scum win with parity slightly earlier in situations, and makes the dayvig a lot more versatile.

that is effectively what is already happening though i think

mechanically the scroll is a public vengekill by a treestumped player
if scum achieve parity but a vengekill by town still needs to be resolved
then scum do not automatically win then and there because they can still lose that parity due to the vengekill
the vengekill still needs to be resolved

ya'll coulda made it where the last scum has scroll immunity or something

actually

giving town more players but giving scum an additional factional dayvig each time they die might help with that balance

each time a scum player dies that is