Catch-22 Mafia [The end?]

[Parama]

Nuwen why are you so inactive this game?

[Shmugen]

I'll give Kuribo an ISOing later today, but I don't see a world where Near isn't the lynch today.

Why do you hold this belief?

Because unless Near's play really picks up, he's going to have a difficult time being useful to the town on later days by doing anything but providing a wagon to analyze. By that time we may have better targets.

[Nuwen]

I'll be confirming my vote on Near every page or three. The octuplet of voters should get over here.

[Staeg]

Yeah you're just a fan of wagons ain't you?

To an extent - I'll have some reasons for most votes, but at this point I want to make the day end.

[MattP]

I'll be confirming my vote on Near every page or three. The octuplet of voters should get over here.

[Toogeloo]

I've lost interest in this first Day. Over 40 pages in less than a week of play, and most of it I just glazed over.

Unvote;
Vote: Near

Sheeping my vote on one of the big wagons. Near has more people I believe are town, so there ya have it. Thinking I might just claim a V/LA until Day 2.

[Near]

Toogeloo, vote Kuribo. His wagon is as big as mine.

[kuribo]

...

[Staeg]

Herp
A
God damn derp

[Papa Zito]

Man. I can't get my head into this game right now. Realtime stuff. But I promised a response to Shmugen so. (also I apologize for the size of this thing)

1. The Ellibereth vote came at a time where the thread was flowing at a fast pace. Not to say I have a townread on Elli now, but the Elli vote was glorified RVS on a player who, as it turns out, doesn't respond to that sort of thing

I don't believe this at all. Your RVS vote was on Chesskid here. Ellibereth posted 8 times before your vote on him. Plus, your vote was very obviously a result of this:

heyhey bro leave that for the qt. There's daytalk.

There is? Do tell me more, Elli.

Unvote, Vote: Ellibereth

Furthermore, in your iso 20 post you say that "I am slightly reluctant to move my vote from Elli." Why would anyone be reluctant to move an RVS vote?

---

2. As you'll have it. I saw a player voting me solely for thinking Tiercescum wouldn't go for something so off the wall for her first post. I've been in a game or two with MattP *Remind me, Matt, were you in Pine's Lightning Mafia?' and didn't recognize this Matt as the town one I've played with.

This is not the reasoning you gave for your MattP vote at all. In that post you cite that his post feels "phoned in", that there's "a lot of absolutes there that shouldn't be much more than gut reads", and that "explanation is at an all time low." If you were actually voting because of his vote on you then you hid that fact because you knew it to be OMGUS.

---

3. I meant what I said. Chesskid made some convincing statements regarding Vijay, and looking back, so did Kuribo. Note that MattP had one post between my vote on him and my change to Vijay. I moved from RVS to slot with behavior I didn't like to slot with a light case made against it that rang true.

What? You made a case on MattP and then voted him for it. In that case you give three reasons why you believe MattP is scum. Why would you follow a person of unknown alignment instead of sticking with your own case?

---

4. Slandaar's presence was tearing this game apart. We lost Glork because of it, and many were lurking until the shit stopped flying. If it could make the game fun again, I'd have gladly taken the handicap of starting this game with a potential two town down.

This one really gets me. You argue you liked chesskid's post about vijay. The crux of Chesskid's argument was "Seems like a nice way to dodge D1 wagons to me", and you agreed with this, then turn around and do

the exact same thing

by attempting a policy lynch on Slandaar.

---

5. Already mentioned. With the Slandaar vote no longer necessary, I moved back.

Fair enough.

---

6. I wouldn't say my vote has been hopping too badly. Calling people out on silly statements, like Near saying there could easily be zero scum in that list when that list contained his lynch target, is supposed to spark discussion of what the hell Near is talking about. Not to sound too much like a scrub, but this is the sort of play/scumhunting I see all the time from my peers.

Here are your votes thus far this game:

Spoiler: votes

Iso 2: VOTE: CHESSKID
Iso 5: Unvote, Vote: Ellibereth
Iso 9: Unvote, VOTE: MattP
Iso 13: Unvote, Vote: Vijay
Iso 20: Unvote, Vote: Slandaar
Iso 22: Unvote, Vote: Vijay
Iso 23: Unvote, Vote: Near

Reminder: We have yet to complete Day 1. I am seeing a player who is throwing his vote around anywhere he can, primarily on the popular wagons, and seeing what will stick. This is reinforced by your re-voting Near in the exact post I'm responding to - you forgot where your vote even was.

---

Sorry but no, these explanations don't fare well under scrutiny.

UNVOTE: Magister Ludi
VOTE: Shmugen

[SpyreX]

Parama sorry reneg'd

Unvote, Vote: Near

[Magister Ludi]

Double vote activate!

unvote
vote: near

[kuribo]

about fucking time, sheesh

[Parama]

unvote, vote: Near

is he hammered or not

[Tierce]

...You're fucking idiots.

Are you all ignoring that glaring towntell of when he analyzed MattP's play even as it was against the rules?

NEAR IS FRIGGING OBVTOWN.

Lynch kuribo.

SERIOUSLY, WTF IS WRONG WITH THOSE OF YOU WHO ARE VOTING NEAR AND ARE TOWN.

[kuribo]

oh just bus him already tierce

[Tierce]

This is L-2. I will take any fucking votes on Near at this stage to be scum claims.

LOL HELLO THIS IS AN OBV EZWAGON.

My life. What a bunch of brainless chickens.

[Tierce]

Be more obvscum, kuribo. It's p. evident they won't give a damn and just carry on the easiest mislynch ever. At this time a scumclaim could dance naked wearing only a teapot cozy and no one would give two fucks.

[kuribo]

There there, tierce, you've done a good job protecting him, but every time he starts to type again, it just comes out worse and worse

And, hell, you know how hard it is to mislynch me, you'll just have to try again tomorrow.

[SpyreX]

Called a fucking idiot.

Stopped reading.

[kuribo]

Called a fucking idiot.

Stopped reading.

HEY SPYSPY DON'T THINK I'VE FORGOTTEN YOU

you better be bringing the good stuff on day 2

[SpyreX]

I'll try but good lord these infinite page games suck the will and THIS particular debacle was double sweet.

Staaeg is still probably scum though for real

[Near]

OMG. I am a Nurse Duckett

[Near]

Am I lynched??

[Near]

GOD GEEZ