Mafiascum.net

In post 519, Channel Fireball wrote:

In post 516, skitter30 wrote:i actually believe that pp is a jk (or at least, had something to do with the fact that nobody died last night)

I can say with certainty that it had nothing to do with it.

- Fireball.

Saving this for later...

In post 611, skitter30 wrote:also i think sky is scummy

Do you have any idea who, besides sky is in your group?

In post 1017, Acute Right Obtuse wrote:

eh fine i'll fullclaim.

i'm the True whisperer and i have to live and have the Prophet guess who i am at endgame. i know the prophet is town

In post 1021, gobbledygook wrote:I think someone claimed the Prophet, ARO

Who?

In post 1022, gobbledygook wrote:Is the false whisperer mafia, ARO?

In post 1017, Acute Right Obtuse wrote:

eh fine i'll fullclaim.

i'm the True whisperer and i have to live and have the Prophet guess who i am at endgame. i know the prophet is town

Ok, so we know there is a true whisperer and a false whisperer...ARO could be the false one but I’m not getting that vibe from him

All of the above was bae

-bae

Pine ~ bandit, unknown wincon
cyrus62 ~ bandit, unknown wincon; apparently different than pine's/pp's
Menalque - not outlaw
skitter30- possibly in trio with sky
Skygazer- possibly in trio with skitter
Elements ~ identify the bandits
Baezu Leaf
123456789 ~ town empress; survive to day 4; claims super loved and bp-
Dr Easy Bake- is he even in this game?
gobbledygook ~ says wincon is like impossible, not outlaw
PenguinPower ~ bandit guard thing who says that they jk'd pine; same wincon as pine's
Channel Fireball ~ outlaw with vig shot- looking for other outlaw. claimed to shoot aro, they didnt' die; claimed to have rolecopped a priest
Acute Right Obtuse ~ apparently cf's target - not outlaw. true whisperer, knows there is a false whisperer and prophet and needs prophet to ID him

The most likely outlaw is DEB, followed by gobble imo

There is also a priest, a prophet and a false whisperer that need accounting for.

Can we POE the roles from this info?

-bae

In post 1011, Menalque wrote:Which requires reading through D2 and deciding how fucked I think the balance of the game is

Let me help you with that:

In post 1, Errantparabola wrote:- This game sucks, both balance and mechanics wise. You will hate it. Most of you will not win. I'm not sorry. Be warned.

In post 1019, 123456789 wrote:Wouldn't he be bound by the primary win condition of the mafia having to win the game first and foremost?

No. There is no primary wincon; there are two wincons. He would have to fulfill both.

In post 1, Errantparabola wrote:- Each player has a separate win condition that they MUST fulfill in addition to their factional win condition to win.

Sucks for you, but..

In post 1, Errantparabola wrote:- This game sucks, both balance and mechanics wise. You will hate it. Most of you will not win. I'm not sorry. Be warned.

VOTE: ARO

Wtf is that claim

welp;

i'm the true whisperer; i know the prophet's alignment but i know there's a fake whisperer

my wincondition is basically the same as his claimed wincon, the prophet needs to correctly guess me as the whisperer. im assuming skitter is the prophet based on the trio discussion stuff

im able to send messages to the prophet at night too. my message was basically "i have no idea what's going on" but long so assuming skitter is the prophet i can see why she'd scumread me for that lol

considering i'm town and the prophet isn't conf-town to me, this probably means aro is scum. which basically conftowns skitter anyways

VOTE: ARO

welp;

i'm the true whisperer; i know the prophet's alignment but i know there's a fake whisperer

my wincondition is basically the same as his claimed wincon, the prophet needs to correctly guess me as the whisperer. im assuming skitter is the prophet based on the trio discussion stuff

im able to send messages to the prophet at night too. my message was basically "i have no idea what's going on" but long so assuming skitter is the prophet i can see why she'd scumread me for that lol

considering i'm town and the prophet isn't conf-town to me, this probably means aro is scum. which basically conftowns skitter anyways

VOTE: ARO

I dunno. I think ARO's claim makes more sense.

@Penguin --> My point still stands. The mafia have to win in order for him to win. Getting rid of his buddy just for his alt wincon isn't gonna increase his win chances, presuming we are both scum (which we aren't).

I’m not outlaw, I’m the damsel and I have to chose a prince to win

Updated list:

Pine ~ bandit, unknown wincon
cyrus62 ~ bandit, unknown wincon; apparently different than pine's/pp's
Menalque - not outlaw- (prince?)
skitter30- prophet?
Skygazer- true whisperer
Elements ~ identify the bandits (prince?)
Baezu Leaf
123456789 ~ town empress; survive to day 4; claims super loved and bp- probs scum
Dr Easy Bake- PoE outlaw- probs scum
gobbledygook ~ damsel in distress- needs to find prince
PenguinPower ~ bandit guard thing who says that they jk'd pine; same wincon as pine's
Channel Fireball ~ outlaw with vig shot- looking for other outlaw. claimed to shoot aro, they didnt' die; claimed to have rolecopped a priest
Acute Right Obtuse ~ whisperer- probs false- probs scum

Seems the game was aptly named- we are all searching for something

At least we have a 50/50- only one of ARO/sky is scum

In post 1037, 123456789 wrote:I dunno. I think ARO's claim makes more sense.

@Penguin --> My point still stands. The mafia have to win in order for him to win. Getting rid of his buddy just for his alt wincon isn't gonna increase his win chances, presuming we are both scum (which we aren't).

He has to get rid of you to win though.

In post 1042, PenguinPower wrote:

In post 1037, 123456789 wrote:I dunno. I think ARO's claim makes more sense.

@Penguin --> My point still stands. The mafia have to win in order for him to win. Getting rid of his buddy just for his alt wincon isn't gonna increase his win chances, presuming we are both scum (which we aren't).

He has to get rid of you to win though.

To be more clear - he can’t win if you do, and you can’t win if he does.

So, your point doesn’t make sense.

I had to choose a prince pregame by the way so like good luck to me if I chose scum. They have to live to endgame. My ability is to send a message after I’m dead lmao so... like fuck me I guess

In post 1041, Baezu Leaf wrote:At least we have a 50/50- only one of ARO/sky is scum

Why

In post 1027, Baezu Leaf wrote:

In post 1017, Acute Right Obtuse wrote:

eh fine i'll fullclaim.

i'm the True whisperer and i have to live and have the Prophet guess who i am at endgame. i know the prophet is town

In post 1021, gobbledygook wrote:I think someone claimed the Prophet, ARO

Who?

I actually thought it was you. But you just said you thought someone was prophet and I’m day drinking at a beac so I don’t know anything anymore. Carry me

What is an outlaw?

Why am I scum?

Is the Earth even round?