Mainstream Mafia II: D&D Edition [FIN]

[Amrun]

There’s also a lot of self confirming roles. I still don’t understand EP’s role. But that’s you, PB, and EP who are alignment confirming roles? Seems like a LOT.

[Rautherdir]

UNVOTE:

Alright. Also wondering if there might be better lynches for today. (Dave, UT, DEB, for example)

yeah bro let's lynch the fucking cult cop

That role does not make you town. And we're still missing a killer in Amrun's list if they are to be believed.

[Cephrir]

4. We should probably massclaim. 85% of the game has claimed so far.

Is there an actual reason to out those of us who have not vomited our roles into the thread? Perhaps there is a reason for that.

17:5 - traditional town/scum break doe. That is currently in this game

Huh?

[gobbledygook]

There’s also a lot of self confirming roles. I still don’t understand EP’s role. But that’s you, PB, and EP who are alignment confirming roles? Seems like a LOT.

It makes sense from a balance perspective. There are 4 killing roles going around (5 if you include AaronFrost). Plus, the cult dies if it targets scum.

[gobbledygook]

4. We should probably massclaim. 85% of the game has claimed so far.

Is there an actual reason to out those of us who have not vomited our roles into the thread? Perhaps there is a reason for that.

17:5 - traditional town/scum break doe. That is currently in this game

Huh?

I am not going to force anyone to claim. I do think we should because it may help confirm other people. But if the majority says no, then the majority says no.

That post was a garbled mess. If we operate under the assumption of traditional forum mafia, then a game with 40 players has 8 scum max (20% of players scum). From there, if this was just town vs mafia, with 22 players alive and 3 dead mafia that would leave us in 17:5 town to scum ratio just based off raw numbers.

[Cephrir]

@People who received inventions: Without telling me what the inventions are, are they strong abilities?

[Cephrir]

That post was a garbled mess. If we operate under the assumption of traditional forum mafia, then a game with 40 players has 8 scum max (20% of players scum). From there, if this was just town vs mafia, with 22 players alive and 3 dead mafia that would leave us in 17:5 town to scum ratio just based off raw numbers.

I guess, but cult/SK/SK-buddy might interact with this idea in nonstandard ways.

[Amrun]

I think it’s very easy to resolve the formerfish list with flavorcop(s). I’m not interested in lynching in it further without a flavor cop saying UT or EP is the Aasimar woman. As I said I think it’s some other flavor explanation and that more likely one or zor or Korina was behind that kill.

[Cephrir]

We do have flavor cops for days, that seems like a solid idea

[EspressoPatronum]

@gobble I support a mass claim.

[pisskop]

I dont

[pisskop]

Christ we still have more players alive than most games have players total.

[gobbledygook]

I think it’s very easy to resolve the formerfish list with flavorcop(s). I’m not interested in lynching in it further without a flavor cop saying UT or EP is the Aasimar woman. As I said I think it’s some other flavor explanation and that more likely one or zor or Korina was behind that kill.

I support that limited claiming if BB or pisskop has the relevant information.

[EspressoPatronum]

Christ we still have more players alive than most games have players total.

But we have a lot more information being thrown around than most other games.

Claiming now could help us verify later on. It could also provide a pseudo-shield for some of the roles already claimed.

[gobbledygook]

Zor because I thought it might be usefull,

which it turned out to be

but I was stalking EP and it didn't post anything Night Action related so I didn't push that.

Iconeum, how did it turn out to be useful to you? Other than being able to dodge bullets?

[RCEnigma]

@People who received inventions: Without telling me what the inventions are, are they strong abilities?

Its useful, not strong.

[pisskop]

Christ we still have more players alive than most games have players total.

But we have a lot more information being thrown around than most other games.

Claiming now could help us verify later on. It could also provide a pseudo-shield for some of the roles already claimed.

We need a list of people's role claims.
A list of people who need to add lie detector claims.
We need a list for use to catch the cult leader.

[RCEnigma]

Gobble has all that.

[pisskop]

I know they have their own version of 3, and so do you.
I dont have 1 and Im only vaguely aware of 2.

Do you think it adds more benefit to the mass? We will obviously have a lot of liars, and i bet we can catch a few.

[pisskop]

I really feel like we'd benefit a lot from hearing from the other half of the playerlist. This feels like a big day.

[Amrun]

I’m fine with massclaiming at this point.

[Dr Easy Bake]

Is it really a massclaim if there are just a few of us?

[Amrun]

Is it really a massclaim if there are just a few of us?

What?

[BBmolla]

mass claiming is fine

[Untrod Tripod]

I'm still a cult cop