MINI 1423 Dark Souls: Prepare to die....YOU DIED

[ThAdmiral]

you can claim your real claim now if you want

[ThAdmiral]

(i.e. your scum role)

[Human Destroyer]

unvote

HD, why wouldn't you claim to kill ThAd scum?

Why did you protect me 3 times?

@fourtrouble - Where do you think the other kill came from if Levi is lying?

Because I wanted to survive another night. It's the same reason I wanted to wait till LYLO to mass claim.

I am Capra Demon. I am a tracker/watcher. My two abilities are each of my two dogs that fight with me, neither had been used by the time I replaced in. I found out last night that I could only use one per night, and used my watch ability on vp baltar. No one visited him.

I'm not sure whether to believe this.

On the one hand, claiming no visit watcher on someone that has a decent chance of being protected seems risky as hell.

On the other, Rest was a scummy little fucker.

VPB and FT, I think you're both town. Thoughts?

Does this sound like someone who knows I'm scum?

Lol, fake claim is fake.

Lol, faked fencing is fake.

Like, duh, I don't want people picking up on the fact that I have role-related info yet; I wanted to get him lynched without claiming.

[Human Destroyer]

(i.e. your scum role)

Don't have one.

I like how people are pushing a doc lynch now though, that's super pro-town.

[ThAdmiral]

Nah we're pushing for a fake-claiming scum lynch. It's a bit different.

[ThAdmiral]

I am Capra Demon. I am a tracker/watcher. My two abilities are each of my two dogs that fight with me, neither had been used by the time I replaced in. I found out last night that I could only use one per night, and used my watch ability on vp baltar. No one visited him.

I'm not sure whether to believe this.

On the one hand, claiming no visit watcher on someone that has a decent chance of being protected seems risky as hell.

On the other, Rest was a scummy little fucker.

VPB and FT, I think you're both town. Thoughts?

Ok lets look at this post again. To set the scene you had already voted me because you found some things that rest said scummy. After I claim, according to you, you would have KNOWN I was lying, and therefore KNOWN I was scum.
Instead of saying "I don't believe your claim", you say "I'm not sure whether to believe this" and even imply that you might be coming round to thinking I'm town based on my claim! There is no excuse of "I wanted to live another day" and that you were "trying to get me lynched without claiming".

Fact is after claiming you came after me

less

than you did before. You

backed off

, rather than

attacking me harder

.

Here's another gem from you:

I still think you're scum it's just that the claim gives me doubts

You think I'm scum,

despite

the claim. The claim is the only thing making you think I could be town? That is not the language of someone who "knows" I am scum

because of my claim

!

Dude, think about what you've said in the thread before fake claiming in the future. Honestly you've played a pretty good scum game, but this is a big slip up and will probably cost your team the win.

[Human Destroyer]

Lol, faked fencing is fake.

Like, duh, I don't want people picking up on the fact that I have role-related info yet; I wanted to get him lynched without claiming.

Durr hurr

If I was actually fencing, I'd have taken my vote off of you.

[Human Destroyer]

Nah we're pushing for a fake-claiming scum lynch. It's a bit different.

translation: I AM SCUM PUSHING FOR DOCTOR LYNCH, PLEASE IGNORE THE FACT THAT I AM CONFIRMED SCUM

[Human Destroyer]

Also, how about you explain why, if scum-me had no plans to claim Doctor until the moment I did, made the stupidest no kill in the fucking world (Vengeful kill would eventually take us to MYLO)?

Oh wait right that's not possible

End of the line, scum!

[ThAdmiral]

Why would I target vp baltar for the night kill...

know

that he was protected by a doc because the kill didn't go through...

...wait for it...

and then claim that I watched him last night and that no one visited him???

Explain that doozy to me.


Why didn't you kill? I don't know you probably had your reasons though. Perhaps to lend credence to a fake doc claim for one.

[Nachomamma8]

Great Grey Wolf Sif, night kill immune town.
I think that vengeful + limited investigative role + bulletproof makes a hell of a lot more sense than a bulletproof + full doctor + limited investigative role.

[Nachomamma8]

ThAd, do you agree with me that FT is likely the last scum so tomorrow can be quick?

[Nachomamma8]

I'm 120% that levi is telling the truth and is town. The reason my immediate response of SK in the setup was because tigerzone was in DDD's townslot for a while and he never said anything that changed that read in the least bit. But levi shooting the tigerzone slot makes a hell of a lot more since, considering that she had a townread on most active players but not really on tigerzone, followed with the "fuck..." immediately after chkflip's death.

[Sotty7]

"Well, you are a rare visitor."

5th vote count of Day four

Human Destroyer: 3 (Nachomamma8, ThAdmiral, leviathan93)

ThAdmiral: 1 (Human Destroyer)
leviathan93: 1 (Empking)

Not voting: 2 (FourTrouble, VP Baltar)

With

7

alive it will take

4

to lynch.

Deadline for the end of the day is in (expired on 2013-04-12 07:00:00)

[FourTrouble]

Nacho, your claim suggests ThAd is mafia.

[Nachomamma8]

How so?

[Nachomamma8]

Right now it just looks like you're weaseling your way out of the hammer :/

[FourTrouble]

Nacho, I'm town.

If mafia tried to kill you, they would have assumed no one visited VP. It makes for a really easy fake-claim. If HD is mafia, I see no incentive to make a 1-for-1 trade. ThAd makes more sense as mafia, my opinion.

[Nachomamma8]

HD's making a 1 for 1 trade because otherwise he's getting lynched.
I could see your point if he brought that out immediately, but his prod dodging until he had to claim + waffling on ThAd's claim initially + just somehow having incriminating information on his top suspect... it doesn't add up.

[Nachomamma8]

I am Capra Demon. I am a tracker/watcher. My two abilities are each of my two dogs that fight with me, neither had been used by the time I replaced in. I found out last night that I could only use one per night, and used my watch ability on vp baltar. No one visited him.

I'm not sure whether to believe this.

On the one hand, claiming no visit watcher on someone that has a decent chance of being protected seems risky as hell.

On the other, Rest was a scummy little fucker.

VPB and FT, I think you're both town. Thoughts?

For example, who sees a claim that provides conflicting information with your own, calls it "risky" and implies it makes them town?

[Nachomamma8]

FT...?

[FourTrouble]

You're right about Levi, his claim makes too much sense for him to be scum. I'm looking over Empking/HD interactions. HD's suspicion of Empking is somewhat unrealistic, could be scum-scum.

[Empking]

I don't think Levi's claim does make sense. DDD's role does say Vengeful (Hidden), for Levi to be telling the truth the mod has to be lying, surely.

[Empking]

Gracelord Nito, Vt, BTW.

[Nachomamma8]

I don't think Levi's claim does make sense. DDD's role does say Vengeful (Hidden), for Levi to be telling the truth the mod has to be lying, surely.

DDD and levi were partners.
If one died, there was a hidden vengeful.