Am I allowed to lynch him for this or do we still think scum don't rolefish
I don't think this is a good reason to lynch.
I frequently PR hunt as town. And as scum, but nobody on this board has ever seen my scum game so you just have to believe me on that one.
Unless scum really screw up, we all make up reasons to suspect each other and then lynch the least charismatic player
I feel like scum haven't really screwed up yet in a way that's noticeable to me, so I'm just sorta bored/frustrated with it being d1
I don't exactly relate to a "game solved" mentality I guess
I'm actually going to get you a cake for this string of sentences. Also I don't see anything else I can actually comment on rn but hmu if you need anything.
I think we're on the same page with MD
Posted: Thu May 31, 2018 3:19 pm
by Something_Smart
In post 1043, Mathdino wrote:I know why I'm town this game but I don't think it's within your Mathdino reading range to actually see it
So I'm very confused
Even assuming he hasn't successfully identified a single alignment-indicative thing for you in this game, his read on you over a large number of games would probably fall in a normal distribution meaning that he'd sometimes come up with such a read that has no basis in fact.
More likely though, if you're town, it's some combination of valid tells and the right side of the bell curve.
Posted: Thu May 31, 2018 3:24 pm
by the worst
one thing that's irritating me
Math you how I treat you 75% of the time and also know that I am a deeply inept meta reader so I'm not sure why you're expecting me to cough up a specific towndino tell? unless I'm totally misreading your question?
In post 1038, Mathdino wrote:His vote on me is awful but I don't think he's reading particularly closely either so I'm really not sure
I'm not townreading him as much as he seems to think in saying that I'm buddying him this game
He wishes I would buddy him
That said, he's a bad lynch d1 and I think he's better saved for lategame
You're welcome duckling I did it for you
Maybe my brain isn't working at the moment, but I'm confused about pronouns in a couple of these.
Line one: His = JJH, me = the_worst
Line two: I'm = the_worst, he = Mathdino?
Line three & four: He / him = Mathdino?
Everything is the worst talking about Mathdino except the last line
I was being cheeky
Posted: Thu May 31, 2018 3:39 pm
by Almost50
Sharing is Caring D1 VC #17
(expired on 2018-06-06 23:00:00)
It was Christmas, and the judge was in a merry mood as he asked the prisoner “What are you charged with?”
“Doing my Christmas shopping early,” replied the defendant.
“That’s no offense,” said the judge. “How early were you doing this shopping?”
The prisoner answered “Before the store opened.”
Posted: Thu May 31, 2018 5:11 pm
by Zoronos
Hey - HeWhoSwims:
a) You never answered my question about ofhrz vs the_worst.
b) What is your opinion on JJH? You talked about him a little bit way back near the start of the day 121, but if I'm understanding right by 273 that had turned around a bit? So I'm curious where your head is at now.
In post 1008, davesaz wrote:He seems to be holding back, not committing to any scumreads nor rocking the boat until there is something that suits his purposes.
This pretty much describes me too, what's the difference?
I disagree, you're doing some things that I see as trying to sort people.
Posted: Fri Jun 01, 2018 1:29 am
by Something_Smart
I definitely am, but you didn't say anything about sorting in 1008. You said that he's not committing to scumreads and not drawing attention to himself. If I'm also doing those things but you think I'm town, do you really think they're scum indicative?
Based on your response to me, it sounds like the REAL reason you scumread him is that you don't think he's trying to sort people. Is that accurate, and if so, what gives you that impression?
As of this votecount, I think everyone should be voting in one of the three major wagons.
Already at this point I feel like one of these wagons has to be on scum, so we go about flipping someone so that the game can move forward. (Hint: duckduckduck)
I'd bet some money on two scum being on the same wagon as of this VC, and one on a separate wagon or unvoted.
Posted: Fri Jun 01, 2018 8:17 am
by Something_Smart
V/LA until Monday
Posted: Fri Jun 01, 2018 8:18 am
by Something_Smart
In post 1061, HitAlt wrote:Already at this point I feel like one of these wagons has to be on scum
Why?
Posted: Fri Jun 01, 2018 8:20 am
by pinturicchio
Yeah, why, and why to the other analysis too; do you have anything to backup those feelings? I do feel we got one scum because of the stagnation of the game, but the "2 scum in one wagon and 1 scum in other or not voting" seems like a stretch
Posted: Fri Jun 01, 2018 8:21 am
by Mathdino
I mean all 3 are pretty scummy
The chance that we're getting snowed is hilariously low
The 2 scum on one wagon is in fact the most statistically likely scenario
Or it would be if smart and hws were voting
Posted: Fri Jun 01, 2018 9:50 am
by HitAlt
Listen to MathDino.
If he is scum, at least he's being honest and astute here.
Posted: Fri Jun 01, 2018 10:01 am
by BlackStar
In post 1064, pinturicchio wrote:Yeah, why, and why to the other analysis too; do you have anything to backup those feelings? I do feel we got one scum because of the stagnation of the game, but the "2 scum in one wagon and 1 scum in other or not voting" seems like a stretch
If everyone votes, then there has to be at least 2 scum on one of the wagons
In post 1064, pinturicchio wrote:Yeah, why, and why to the other analysis too; do you have anything to backup those feelings? I do feel we got one scum because of the stagnation of the game, but the "2 scum in one wagon and 1 scum in other or not voting" seems like a stretch
If everyone votes, then there has to be at least 2 scum on one of the wagons
Why. There are 3 scums and three wagons. Am I missing something?
Posted: Fri Jun 01, 2018 10:28 am
by Almost50
In post 1068, pinturicchio wrote:Why. There are 3 scums and three wagons. Am I missing something?
Yes. You're missing a '?' after the 'Why'.
Posted: Fri Jun 01, 2018 10:33 am
by northsidegal
In post 1065, Mathdino wrote:I mean all 3 are pretty scummy
The chance that we're getting snowed is hilariously low
Mathdino hasn't actually played with me iirc, he's just seen me play at least twice. I'm pretty easy to read if you know how I play but I am of the opinion I don't obvtown conventionally. Like, math would probably agree I obvtowned in team mafia, but I still got wagoned significantly day 1.
So basically, Math is wrong. If I have a reputation for being obvtown it's within the group of people who have frequently played with me.
You got anything else?
I also think nsg is town, her reads tend to be sheepworthy, and she's scumreading you
Speaking of jjh, I find it kinda interesting that this was never followed up on (considering he posted again later that day)
I feel like town with the same mindset as 771 is more often like "well her reasons are shit too and you're sheeping her onto a shit wagon" but he just sorta dropped it? I feel like that points in the direction of faked indignation and/or him knowing nsg's reasons for scumreading him are actually AI
