I think it's a good sign the thread is so active but we've got too many different wagons going for me to viable keep track of all of what's going on, so let's do this:
Everyone please post a reads list and a quick case for whoever your vote is on right now.
I'll be back tomorrow to catch up and do the same.
These two have been spamming all game. I'm calling my shot now, this is the scumteam. Come join me on the urap wagon, game is already solved.
Also correct me if I'm wrong because I have no experience in setup spec, but this game probably has more than two scum in it, right? with 13 people? This was a legit dumb!tell I think. He's only played newbie games up until now and they have 2 person teams.
Hmm yeah. This didn't occur to me. I don't have nearly enough time for a proper readthrough, but I'm definitely townreading urap2 now, his play has developed into what I'm used to from town!urap at this point. I definitely don't see the motivation for the tris fakehammer, I've pulled that before, but the only reason to do it imho is because the wagon is under significant pressure, and the fakehammer could fit in the progression the game was going in. The fake lolhammer came out of nowhere, I would have checked it anyway, this seems like either bad play (which I wouldn't expect coming from the alt of an experienced player, which I think someone said tris is) or scum trying to get towncred.
Posted: Sat Mar 02, 2019 3:51 am
by Ankamius
Town:
Enter
u r a person 2
skitter30
xRECKONERx
tris
NotMySpamAccount
Scum:
Brigitte
Chara?
Flubbernugget?
Who the fuck knows :
Elbirn
Nimueh
tictac
Posted: Sat Mar 02, 2019 4:01 am
by Ankamius
Funny thing is that if I was able to locktown all my townreads, this would be a solve.
These two have been spamming all game. I'm calling my shot now, this is the scumteam. Come join me on the urap wagon, game is already solved.
Also correct me if I'm wrong because I have no experience in setup spec, but this game probably has more than two scum in it, right? with 13 people? This was a legit dumb!tell I think. He's only played newbie games up until now and they have 2 person teams.
Hmm yeah. This didn't occur to me. I don't have nearly enough time for a proper readthrough, but I'm definitely townreading urap2 now, his play has developed into what I'm used to from town!urap at this point. I definitely don't see the motivation for the tris fakehammer, I've pulled that before, but the only reason to do it imho is because the wagon is under significant pressure, and the fakehammer could fit in the progression the game was going in. The fake lolhammer came out of nowhere, I would have checked it anyway, this seems like either bad play (which I wouldn't expect coming from the alt of an experienced player, which I think someone said tris is) or scum trying to get towncred.
I'm only somewhat experienced. I had some games back in 2014, a number of which I flaked on, and then I was gone for a while. I played one game in 2017, and now I'm here with 2 other games with this account.
Chara wrote:i still think u2's turnaround there is more towny than not. and it's hard to tell if a random fakehammer amid another fakehammer is trolling or not when you don't actually comment on it.
so u2 bringing it up for discussion didn't strike me as bad.
i also don't think consistency is towny, anyway, but i might have accepted that Ank's thought processes are drastically different from mine.
pedit: hahaha. of course you'd say that after i've typed this.
I think in a bubble, urap asking about my fakehammer is fine. When there's not much more in the way of looking for scum reads than "here's what my memory serves, a bunch of gut town reads," it's a straw grasp and an attempt to look town.
In post 854, skitter30 wrote:like i'm not sure what the scum motivation is for such a massive read reversal here
cuz if they're partners i don't think he just randomly drops the push
and if nmsa is town and urap is scum like why bother doing this rn?
the fact that i still went "but u2 might still be scum here doing this as a smokescreen in spite of nmsa being town!"
and that's... stupid. and my gut is being stupid. i think this is a case where i have to agree with you on u2 being town and just ignore my gutread on him because it's just making zero sense.
but yes, i agree. i'm kind of happy he's dropped it too, as i never really liked the wagon.
In post 863, Chara wrote:Ankamius, are you still scumreading skitter? maybe i'm tired but i can't tell right now.
This is probably a stretch, but these read to me like the deflation of scum watching both today and tomorrow's mislynches evaporating
Chara says they are happy I've dropped the push, but the whole post reads disappointed.
Do you think his ISO seems particularly scummy? I don’t didn’t find anything particularly pinging about it.
he's being pushed because he's an easy push
I haven't seen any evidence of otherwise, and even then my personal 'scumread' of him is a bit of a stretch that's dependent on my Brigitte scumread
sooooooooooooooo
I think you’re probably town. I agree, tictac seems like mislynchbait.
Why do you think Ank is town?
Scum prey on easy lynchbaity players, so it’s townie to question that. I also agree with her as I don’t see why he’s scum. I think scum is probably on his wagon though.
I think it's a good sign the thread is so active but we've got too many different wagons going for me to viable keep track of all of what's going on, so let's do this:
Everyone please post a reads list and a quick case for whoever your vote is on right now.
I'll be back tomorrow to catch up and do the same.
Are these all of the tictac votes?
Posted: Sat Mar 02, 2019 8:05 am
by Enter
In post 1064, Nimueh wrote:Who is currently voting tictac that was on NMSA wagon? Unfortunately, there’s no VC for that.
There is, it's in my ISO.
I think everyone on tictac rn was on NMSA but I'm not certain, I know me, urap, reck were all on both wagons