Mafiascum.net

In post 1040, Nachomamma8 wrote:

In post 0, northsidegal wrote:Once a Baton Holder has been decided upon by majority vote (or plurality, if no majority is reached by deadline), all discussion ceases.

oh lol i missed this

In post 996, Goodies wrote:That doesnt bode well for him. The last time i can remember him being like that I ended up with pie in my face.

Really? This is pretty normal for me.

Also I think the townreads on RC due to Nancy this early off of the minimal relevant posting Nancy has done (and knowing that she has won games as scum before) are a bit... hasty.

In post 1049, Gay Dance Gone Wrong wrote:Link?

BoP and FotM

https://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=84&t=79095
https://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=3&t=79045

My problem isn't that you're townreading RC or that you're sheeping his reads, it's that you're presenting doing so as objectively the best course of action <24 hours into a game with reads that probably should not be strong enough (unless you're not town, I guess) for you to be presenting anyone's non mod confirmed alignment as a factual and un-counterable basis for argument, nor should RC's history with reads be the sole reason you sheep him ever.

Everything is still -E, BTW

By the way. I hate it when people worship RC as much as the next guy (though not many people have done it this game). But I'm really surprised at the number of people going "I don't understand RC's case on Shoshin so I'm going to ignore it and trust my own read there instead."

Like, I thought it was well-known that RC's ability to form good reads far outweighs his ability to explain them.

Also I would like to point out that RC did have a similar initial spat with Shoshin in BoP (where he was town) and he scum read her correctly there, but a relatively short while afterwards he dropped the scum read of her and moved to a more neutral position.

In post 1050, Wisdom wrote:

In post 1040, Nachomamma8 wrote:

In post 0, northsidegal wrote:Once a Baton Holder has been decided upon by majority vote (or plurality, if no majority is reached by deadline), all discussion ceases.

oh lol i missed this

Same. I wonder what NSG would do if people decided to talk?

...Lock the thread?

Then how would people choose batons? PMs? Seems clunky.

RC
is a human being who plays mafia and is better at reading people on average than most other people who play mafia.

He's not so perfect/consistent that you can base an objective logical argument around him, nor should he always be the night 1 kill.
He's also not so good that it's worth wasting your time directly opposing/disagreeing with him in one way or another so that you feel better about yourself because "RC has flaws too." or because you managed to find the one time RC was wrong and you were right therefore you're a better player than RC.

Can we all just relax? I'm pretty sure a majority of this thread hates it when people worship RC, I've seen far too many comments about it to really believe otherwise. Please just treat him like another player and let's move on with the game.

I'm gonna skip FotM since RC was scum there.
BoP it looks like RC fluctuated but still had her as scum but just couldn't bring himself to lynch her?

In post 0, northsidegal wrote:The Baton Holder will then private message me "

Pass: X

" to another player of their choosing.

It's a little bit clunky but presumably she wouldn't have done this if she didn't check her PM's frequently.

hard to do so when everyone wants to bp him and sheeps his reads

if people ignored him i would be cool

@enter

I find Shoshin scummy for a similar reason I find Gay Dance scummy. I did not like how they only self voted after people started saying they were town.

In post 1064, Something_Smart wrote:

In post 0, northsidegal wrote:The Baton Holder will then private message me "

Pass: X

" to another player of their choosing.

It's a little bit clunky but presumably she wouldn't have done this if she didn't check her PM's frequently.

I should read mechanics

SS do you have a single townread

In post 1062, Oh wrote:Can we all just relax? I'm pretty sure a majority of this thread hates it when people worship RC, I've seen far too many comments about it to really believe otherwise. Please just treat him like another player and let's move on with the game.

You know that ain't happening.
That's why I'm trying to see if anyone can break my logical proof.
They can say all they want in terms of reads and all that.
But they can't invalidate correct logical proof.
And so far, it stands.

In post 1066, Oversoul wrote:I find Shoshin scummy for a similar reason I find Gay Dance scummy. I did not like how they only self voted after people started saying they were town.

dont think thats scummy
its pointless to vote yourself if other people dont vote you ie have a real chance to get batoned

gif without even looking im positive rc hasnt read anyone 100% correctly

I think Bitmap voted himself as a meme there but I'm not Bitmap so

In post 1070, Wisdom wrote:

In post 1066, Oversoul wrote:I find Shoshin scummy for a similar reason I find Gay Dance scummy. I did not like how they only self voted after people started saying they were town.

dont think thats scummy
its pointless to vote yourself if other people dont vote you ie have a real chance to get batoned

I don’t think it’s pointless to do. Discussion has to start somewhere. I immediately self voted and several people agreed, so that defeats your argument entirely.

In post 1071, Wisdom wrote:gif without even looking im positive rc hasnt read anyone 100% correctly

Well he states so, so you'll have to prove that it's false or my thing still stands.
So far Enter's links did not prove the contradictory.